Customer Reviews

Cooking Mama: Cook Off

5 star:		(49)
4 star:		(32)
3 star:		(23)
2 star:		(20)
1 star:		(11)

 

 

Sizzling off the Nintendo DS burner, Mama is back for second helpings with Cooking Mama: Cook-Off for the Wii. What can easily be called an import-with-modification, this kitchen simulation emulates the DS version almost identically and although several key distinctions can be made between the two titles, it's a safe wager that if you enjoyed the portable Mama, you'll love her just the same when grounded to Nintendo's new console.

The premise of the game is ridiculously simple which no doubt enhances the title's adorable flair as well as minimizes its already insignificant learning curve. Mama (a ridiculously excitable Japanese woman) has once again decided to open her cheery country-style kitchen to gamers who, under her unblinking supervision, will cook, slice, and dice their way through fifty-five international entrees and desserts.

Each of the missions is further deconstructed into several objectives, all of which can be successfully completed through simple motion-driven minigames. Say, for instance, a gamer chooses to melt and mold chocolate truffles. After confirming his or her selection, a screen will appear detailing the numerous step-by-step activities one must perform in order to properly prepare the cocoa-crunchies. Once briefed, the first minigame will begin with a simple 3-2-1 on-screen countdown. An unwrapped chocolate bar appears on a digital cutting board and the gamer is instructed to flick the Wiimote up and down rapidly to "dice" the dessert. Once chopped, the chocolate must then be boiled, an activity which requires the gamer to monitor oven settings and be vigilant against charring the mixture. After each minigame, a results screen appears, chronicling one's numerous successes or failures. From this evidence Mama renders her verdict which is relayed through a series of annoying, mispronounced "Engrish" phrases (`Better than Mama!,' `No Good!,' `That's Okay. Keep Going!'). Upon accepting her analysis, the instructions screen reappears and another minigame launches.

The title features three primary `game modes' - `Let's Cook,' `Friends and Food of the World,' and `Friends and Food.' In highlighting the first option, Mama's recipe book bursts open, thereby enabling the gamer to access a myriad of single-player entrée-selections, all of which can be independently prepared. `Friends and Food of the World' offers a competitive user-versus-computer challenge during which an exotic e-pal races you to prepare a specialty entrée from his or her own unique nation. The human contestant must not only cook quickly but accurately as both time and precision determine your final score. Lastly, "Friends and Food" allows two human chefs-in-training to compete against one another in a food preparation dual; utilizing a split-screen configuration, both players are given the same tasks to complete but, as expected, their performances can vary greatly.

As for its performance and execution, Cooking Mama: Cook Off provides gamers with a light-hearted, atypical experience, no more, no less. This isn't a game which enthralls its user at the onset and demands his or her undivided attention. You won't have to cancel your social obligations with the excuse that you've "just gotta create those virtual creampuffs." In the same breath, don't underestimate this title to be a useless throw-away deserving of dust collection; Cooking Mama can be a delight, in so long as one keeps his or her expectations in check. This game won't significantly impact your worldviews and mindsets nor will it violently augment your real-life culinary abilities; what it will provide is casual amusement and entertaining escapism from the harsh realities of life. When shoot'em ups get you down and puzzling mysteries confound you, Mama's always there with a gentle smile, sparkling kitchen, and exotic entrée to be prepared. Bon appetite!

PROS -
+ Effervescent environments, entrees, and activities.
+ Excellent and innovative use of the Wiimote as an all-in-one kitchen utensil.
+ Guaranteed to charm even the most cynical of gamers.
+ Easy to play but truly difficult to master.
+ Lovely soundtrack and realistic audio effects; battles between global e-pals feature music tracks unique to the given region.
+ Overall, an addictive oddity; how many cooking simulations have this much depth and diligence?

CONS -
-- Entrees and edible ingredients are beautifully rendered; environments and cell-shaded utensils however lack detail and definition. Too many jagged edges and not enough vectors are integrated.
-- Mama's vocalizations are annoying, repetitive, and sometimes incomprehensible.
-- Literally no "options" exist within the game's options menu; customization is oddly absent.
-- A few Wiimote movements are difficult to perform; mixing becomes exhausting whilst peeling virtual vegetables is actually more challenging than the real thing!
-- Niche-marketed; some gamers will adore this title but many will unfairly treat it with disdain.

Ok... what is that woman SAYING?!?!?
As many have said, Mama is very difficult to understand. This doesn't seem critical for gameplay... just.... weird.
Somewhere in the gaming world of Tokyo is a highly-caffeinated Japanese woman who thinks she has performed an Italian accent.
Anyway.
Moving on.
The game itself is very simple. Childlike. Yet I keep playing it. Why? I would love to know.
Maybe because it is so mindless that I really don't give a [beep] if Mama likes my cooking or not. It is just kinda fun to peel virtual carrots and wonder what the hell that red stuff is they want me to add to scrambled eggs.
And I can tell kids will love it. I haven't shown it to my 10 year old yet (off visiting friends) -- but I just know she'll be thrilled.

As some have also said, some of the controls are frustrating.
Something like "stir" shouldn't be difficult... yet for some reason - no matter which way I move the remote, it never works the right way.
Ditto with some kind of timing thing where I am supposed to add ingredients, change stove heats, etc. They don't really tell you what you are supposed to do, and the controls don't seem to work the way you think they should. I even think it once said "use B button" and "A" is what worked.
Nevertheless, for some silly reason I find it fun to swirl pretend butter around in a cartoon pan and here Mama say something that may or may not resemble the word "awesome."

First of all, when I heard of this game, I thought it would be fun. And I was right. Partially. The thing i didn't like was the actual length of the game. Cooking the dishes was fun, however. We spent a lot of time playing it at home, and also with friends. It was more fun as a multiplayer game. My sister liked it a lot so she played it often. But after about a week, we BEAT THE GAME!!!! BELIEVE THAT! I was cautious from the start, so I rented it first. We beat the game before we returned it! My sister was pretty bummed out. I was also kind of upset at how they could make such a fun game so short. 55 recipes seems like a lot, but it isn't. Each recipes is about a couple of minutes. After an hour of plying, you probably have ended up with 25% complete. And the graphics are okay, same with sound. BUT, for some dumb reason they decided to make "mama" speak some made up language, a cross between English and Japenese. Japanenglish! Half the time you dont understand a word she says. Like when you mess up on something, she says something along the lines of "good, not mine". The other half when you can understand it, she ends up saying something very repetitive. The actual idea of a cooking game for Wii is excellent, but this just doesn't cut it.

Pros:
-Fun and addicting
-Nice graphics
-Nice sound
-Fun multiplayer

Cons:
-Mama is not understandable
-Incredibly short
-Repetitive

Overall, this is not a very good game. Way too short and repetitive. However, very good idea to rent. DO NOT make the mistake to buy it. It will be lying at the bottom of your video game drawer after a week of gameplay. [...]

Lets hope the can make a Cooking Mama 2 woth much longer gameplay and way more understandable language.

This game is sometimes very difficult to play, and the controls are extremely difficult for younger children to understand. The Wii remote does not seem responsive enough ("fast" enough) to work with this game sometimes, and sometimes I feel like the game does not understand what motion I am using. As a result, you end up frustrated. One of the hardest things for me to master is adding ingredients to a pan in the right order so that the fastest cooking ingredients (like onions) don't burn first. The game doesn't really help you understand this, and it doesn't help you through it. I'm an adult and can't master it -- imagine how it would be for children.

There is a wide variety of games within this game, so you won't be bored. However, the sound is not clear. Usually you can't understand what Mama is saying. The graphics are OK.

Honestly, I think they should have "cooked" the game a little more before releasing it. The concept works well with the Wii controller, but it is far from perfect and not nearly as smooth as the control in Wii Sports. This is not the game that makes me want to turn on my Wii.

Cooking Mama is a charming collection of cooking themed minigames. The main objective of the game is to chop, cut, boil, stir, mix and cook a variety of different meals from around the world. The game can be played alone or 2 players can face off against each other. Nintendo has talked a lot about opening the Wii and DS to new audiences, Cooking Mama is undoubtedly an excellent example of the type game it takes to achieve this goal. The game is suitable for young chefs ages 6. And the game may even change or shape your kids attitude towards cooking. Contrary to popular believe Cooking Mama does NOT teach your kids, or husband, or wife how to cook, but it does introduce some of the ingredients and steps required for many different types of meals. Cooking Mama sells for $49 MSRB, which is a lot of dough for a small game that feels more like a XBLA (Xbox Live Arcade) Game in regards of size and presentation. If you don't mind the bitter price tag, you'll find Cooking Mama refreshing and enjoyable.

As many people wrote, this game is both interesting and frustrating. Some actions are very easy to perform (like breaking eggs) and some are frustrating (peeling vegetables). There are too many instructions to read before you go to a mini-game, which rules out kids who are not comfortable reading yet.

Some of the mini-games are very difficult to understand because there are no instructions on how to do some or in which order to use the ingredients. Moreover, once you complete playing all the games (would take not more than 2 hours), there is no more novelty.

For these reasons, I recommend renting this game.

I bought this game because it looked like it would be really silly, but fun. I was right! This game is a great multi-player game for people who don't play video games a lot or want something simple.
The game play isn't extremely hard, but some of the recipes are more challenging then others. The varying difficulty level makes it easy to involve everyone in the game play.
I brought this game to a party with kids ranging from 10 to 20 years of age. Everyone had a good time playing it and picked up the game rather quickly.

If you are looking for a challenging, story filled one player game, this isn't it. It only took me a couple hours to complete the one player mode and unlock all the recipes. But, as a multi-player game, it is the first one everyone wants to play on the Wii.

+ Cute
+ Fairly simple learning curve

- Short with no replay value; each recipe is essentially a string of mini-games that last at most 1 minute and there are very few different mini-games
- Some actions are extremely fustrating with the Wii Remote (e.g. peeling veggies)
- May enterain only young gamers, but game requires significant reading of on-screen instructions

= Rent the game. Use a coupon.

My 6 year old son and I have had a great time competing against each other while creating recipes. It is easy enough for him (and me)! He even wants to cook some of the recipes for real. A very fun family game!

I really love this game! Like the others said, the controls sometimes make you want to throw the remote, but over all fun! (I have found that slower stiring seems to pick up better when stewing.) I'm addicted! I'd never played the DS version, so I didn't know what to expect. Mama is hard to understand, but you don't have to understand her to play the game. I'd recomend it to anyone who enjoys silly-fun games!