Customer Reviews

The Coral Sea 1942: The first carrier battle (Campaign)

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Mark Stille is a retired Navy Commander with 30 years experience. This experience includes five years of carrier duty, US Intelligence work, Naval War College and Joint Staff. He is also the author of seven other Osprey titles concerning Naval activities in the Pacific War. The coverage of this book is excellent and well balanced. Each chapter receives their appropriate attention.

In early 1942 the US started to go on the offensive. In Feb and March, the Marshalls, Gilberts, Wake Island, Marcus and New Guinea saw carrier strikes by either Lexington, Yorktown or Hornet. In mid April, Doolittle struck Tokyo. In early May we have the Coral Sea Battle which will have a major impact on Yamamoto's attack on Midway. In early August, the US lands on Guadalcanal. Even with these attacks, the Japanese were not deterred. Their plans for taking over New Guinea and the Solomons continued and even had tentative plans for New Caledonia and Fiji in order to isolate Australia and block communications with the US.
The author provides a nice chronology to help the reader envision the coming action. It covers from Dec 7th, 1941 to May 8th, 1942. The last few days are time sequenced by the hour which was great.
The Opposing Commanders are covered well. Yamamoto, Inoue, Takagi, Hara and Goto are covered while on the US side, Admirals King, Nimitz, Fletcher, Fitch along with Captains Buckmaster and Sherman are discussed.
Opposing Fleets is next and the author devotes 20 pages to this chapter. He describes the different carrier classes including specifications and a brief history of each. Air Defense standards and air groups are then covered. Toward the end the carrier planes are mentioned, stating strengths and weaknesses. Four planes for the Japanese and three for the US (Wildcat, Dauntless, Devastator) are mentioned. The author also squeezes in intelligence operations for the US and the improvements in code breaking that were achieved in 1942. There is much that could be said about this field; I wished the author had more space to develop it more fully. A detailed Order of Battle closes out the chapter.
Opposing Plans is also interesting. The Japanese were still in their expansion phase and were working hard on securing New Guinea, the Solomons. Their appetites even included Australia for the future. After the successful Doolittle run, the Japanese added the invasion plans for Midway with the hope of destroying the US carrier fleet. The author provides excellent coverage of what the Japanese were trying to achieve.
With the help of Ultra, the US had a good estimate of what the Japanese were up to in regards to Midway and the Coral Sea area and the usual cautious Nimitz quickly put together an aggressive plan to stop the Japanese.

The Battle for the Coral Sea starts on page 46 and begins coverage of the opening moves starting in late April and the author deliberately makes his way through May 8th with the sinking of the Lexington and Fletcher retiring to the south. The author ends the battle action by describing Lexington's demise and tallies the wins and loses of the immediate engagement for both sides. The Japanese stopped their carrier invasion plans of New Guinea which was probably the biggest near term benefit to the Allies. In Aftermath the author describes the long term repercussions of the battle. The US lost the Lexington while only sinking the smaller Shoho but strategically it effected Yamamoto's performance at Midway the following month. The Japanese also decided to stop their conquest, at least for the immediate future, to Tugali and Guadalcanal.

There were five 2-D maps and all of them were very good. The first map contains the sphere of Japanese control in May 1942. The next map zooms in on just the Coral Sea area that includes eastern New Guinea, Solomons, New Caledonia and the northern tip of Austrailia. The last three maps shows the ship movements of both sides during the week of May, during the actual battle. There are also three 3-D maps which I haven't seen before in an Osprey book. The US attack of the Shoho, the US attack on the MO Task Force on May 8th and the last concerns the Japanese attack on the Lexington and Yorktown on May 8th. The 8 maps cover the action very well. Most people will probably like these new 3-D maps but I didn't.
The three battle illustrations were also very good. They depict the US attack of the Shoho, the US attack on the Shokaku and the Japanese attack on the Lexington. They were all very good. There are also many fine photos of carriers, other ships and planes. (The photos alone are worth the cover price.) Mr Stille also provides a Reading list and Index.

The author has done an excellent job of describing the Pacific war environment of 1942, the actual battle in the Coral Sea and some of its after effects. If you have an interest in knowing how we lost the Lexington, or the points of victory of the US in this battle or what the Pacific war was like in early 1942 or if you like ships you should consider getting this book.

In my opinion this is one of the best (if not the best) Osprey Campaign Series titles that I've ever purchased. It's filled with well chosen, interesting photos & battle scene paintings and the maps are very well done (no typos).

To the reviewer who only gave it 2 stars: keep in mind that it's an Osprey book so the author is limited to their 96 page format. The author doesn't claim that this book is the last word on the subject. He provides the reader with a list of further reading in the bibliography (including John Lundstrom's work) .

In closing I'd like to say that if you know very little about the battle then this book is a great place to start.

Although the Battle of the Coral Sea in May 1942 is typically overshadowed by the more decisive Battle of Midway a month later, the early action was significant as the first carrier vs. carrier battle of the Second World War. Naval historian Mark Stille does a fine job setting the stage for this first battle between the Japanese and American carriers and he deftly weaves a great deal of insight and analysis into his narrative. Readers need not fear that this is a re-hash of Samuel Elliott Morrison; this is a work based on fresh research and sober assessments. Overall, Coral Sea 1942 is a fine naval history.

After outlining the origins of the campaign and the opposing commanders, the author lays out the strengths and the weaknesses of each side. While the Japanese had a better air-delivered torpedo and longer range aircraft, the Americans had air-search radar and a dive-bomber that packed a more powerful bomb load. It is interesting that the author concludes that while the Americans enjoyed the advantage of superior operational intelligence due to code breaking, that this did not translate to a decisive tactical edge. Indeed, for much of the Battle of the Coral Sea the Americans were unaware where the main Japanese carrier force was located. The author then provides a very detailed order of battle for both sides.

The 9-page section on opposing plans is particularly interesting. The Japanese committed only one-third of their carriers to this operation and exposed themselves to piece-meal defeat for a secondary objective. The author also makes good observations that the Japanese were conducting a major naval operation without benefit of effective land based air support and with little regard for enemy interference. On the other hand, the author views the American decision to send two carriers to the Coral Sea as extremely aggressive and based upon an exaggerated view of our own forces capabilities. Once the operation began and the Japanese made their move on Port Moresby, the author notes that Japanese planning made no allowance for the slightest thing to go wrong and tiny frictions began to unravel their operation. On the other side, coordination between the two American carriers was laughably poor and at this stage, the Americans were not unduly troubled about conducting single carrier attacks. The author then moves through the carrier battles of 7-8 May in sequential fashion and I was satisfied with how the text and maps married up. The book concludes with an assessment and a short bibliography.

The volume includes five 2-D maps (strategic situation May 1942; Southwest Pacific area; movement of US and Japanese naval forces, May 2-6; movement of US and Japanese naval forces, May 7; movement of US and Japanese naval forces, May 8) and three 3-D BEV maps (US attack on Shoho; US attack on Japanese MO carrier strike force; Japanese attack on Lexington). The BEV maps are a new style, that depict altitude of aircraft actions and cloud cover. There are also three Battle scenes (attack on the Shoho, US attack on Shokaku; Japanese attack on Lexington) by John White. Overall, Coral Sea 1942 is a very satisfying volume.

This brief overview of the Battle of the Coral Sea is reasonably complete, and contains a lot of good information. The author goes over the personalities of the commanders, their ships and aircraft, and their plans, with considerable authority and detail, and he does a good job of describing the events of the battle itself. If there's a failing here it's the illustrations. Osprey has designed this elaborate illustration protocol for these Campaign books, and it really works best for land battles from the black powder era. Here, the 3D battle capability of the maps is pretty much completely wasted, since the battle takes place on the open ocean, where that 3rd dimension is essentially meaningless. They try to compensate for this by doing maps that show the attacks of the various air groups on the carriers, but it doesn't work very well: it's pretty hard to tell which of the arrows is supposed to be above one of the others. The detailed illustrations, which usually have many numbered explanations to tell you who the various people portrayed in the illustration are, in this case merely label the ship #1 and the plane attacking it #2. Really, without those numbers, who would be able to tell which was the plane, and which was the ship?

This isn't a bad book, don't get me wrong. The narrative is very well-written and the author lays out his information intelligently. It's just not the best use of the illustrations.

This is one of the best Osprey books I have seen to date. Includes Orders of Battle, fleet and aircraft movement Maps, "3D" renderings of air attacks, and good information on most aspects of the battle. Perhaps a little biased towards intelligence. Also gives somewhat contradicting views on the battle of Midway with the book in this series by that name, oddly by the same author. (This may be due to Osprey rather than the author though, if so Osprey should "shut up and sit down"). While I don't agree with Mr. Stille on some points (and do on others), he makes a good case for his opinions and at least they are well researched and "modern". It's a shame they didn't have him write the Leyte Gulf book as well, it was sorely in need of losing the post-war propagandist British history, and also of more informative descriptions of the battles and units involved.

I rated this book at four stars only because it is difficult to follow when reading. It is a little 'jumpy' with respect to time line, but the content is very good, although it could have been a little more detailed.

To be as concise as possible, if you are into naval warfare history or the history of the Pacific campaign or warships themselves, get this book. Retired navy officer Mark Stille, always provides concise but detailed books that are factual. The Coral Sea is no exception. This giant carrier duel, the first of its kind in indeed naval history, a huge American victory. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

This is another in the Osprey series of brief works on warfare. The focus here is the Battle of the Coral Sea, carried out in 1942. As usual, this is a rather brief book, featuring a slender volume. Nonetheless, there is value to this publication.

The book explores the context and actions during the first major carrier battle in history. The Japanese and American navies converged in the Coral Sea for a contest between the respective aircraft carriers--Lexington and Yorktown representing the American carriers and Shokuku, Zuikaku, and light carrier Shoho for the Imperial Japanese Navy (IJN).

The book itself features a chronology leading up to the battle, a thumbnail sketch of the leading commanders for both sides (e.g., Admiral Yamamoto for the IJN and Admirals Nimitz and Fletcher for the Allies, among others), the opposing fleets (including specifications for the carriers), the opposing plans for battle, and then a description of the battle itself.

The Japanese were at a disadvantage,, since they did not have radar (although American radar was hardly deployed with great effectiveness). They also depended too much on an overly complex plan of action. The battle itself featured errors and missed opportunities by both sides.

In the end, though, the battle took place, and the era of the carrier as the dominant warship began.

This is a useful brief introduction to an important battle.

very basic info on this historic battle....I have read much more in depth accounts from authors such as John Lunstrum.