3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Provacative theme, same tired business-success advice, June 10, 2009
Titillating title, eh? Sexually dripping front cover. This former VP of Marketing knows the 1st rule of magazines, "They'll judge the book by it's cover." The cover is Sex, and Sex sells.
The inside isn't so helpful, though. The author bases her 'Dominatrix Wins" opinions on "archetypes", a Jungian reference. I don't know if Jung actually created the archetypes she usesor if the author made them up. Either way, the 6 archetypes range from the domineering Queen to passive Schoolgirl, with the other 4 falling between them.
She explains each archetype, gives a vague Cosmo-like quiz, and then allows the reader to label herself. She then gives a couple simplistic business situations that the role is used in.
Here's the key problems:
1) No indication of "When" to use these, just descriptions of "What".
2) The examples conflict. Example: The "Warrior" dominatrix never takes no for an answer. Her project is given to a different employee. So, the "warrior" refuses to give, presents a new project that shows the project can be completed in half the time and half the cost. And the Warrior Wins! Now, in real corporate life, any lead engineer/project manager who basically says "My 1st estimate was 100% overpriced, here's the real cost" will lose instant credibility.
3) The "Queen" stereotype example: "Dress for success. Lisa never dressed down on casual friday. She always said 'I dress assuming the president will drop by." OK. But 3 chapters earlier she talks about the "Nurturing" archetype who does her best to bond with her team. And the Nurturing archetype strives to be one of the team, thus she dresses down to maintain camaraderie. So, does that mean if your Nurturing, you can't be a future CEO?
Regardless of contradictions, the book takes the usual self-help tone: If you make a plan, the plan will succeed.
Good luck with that.
Competition reacts to your actions, so plans don't always work.
And if some coworker starts acting in this way, most people will see through the charade. And then they'll know you're a schemer, and be on the defensive with you.
And once you get past the little "dominatrix" schtick, the success advice is decades old.
This book may attract a recent female graduate, confused on finding her place in the office. But I'd recommend
The 48 Laws of Power for a much better training guide.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Take a new look at the workplace, March 27, 2007
This review is from: The Corporate Dominatrix: Six Roles to Play to Get Your Way at Work (Hardcover)
The Corporate Domantrix is so delightfully interesting, you will want to share it with your entire office! I had never thought about the corporate environment in this way before and will never look at it the same way again. Finding out what role you play is fascinating... It will change the way you look at yourself and those around you. The book is entertaining and highly interactive. This is a really interesting look at a fascinating topic!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No