Customer Reviews

Counterpoint: Fundamentals of Music Making

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is a primer for the non-conformist western classical musician/performer. It deals profoundly--yet in a tremendously pragmatic way--with the most essential, fundamentally important music-making elements. It is a practical guide for developing well grounded, musically valid, 'weighted', solid musical interpretations. This is a manual that 'teaches us how to fish' instead of the traditional 'fish giving' syndrome of our music educational establishments. Mr. Thakar--an alumni of genius conductor Sergiu Celibidache, now working for the N.Y. Phil--explains, expands and applies in practical examples concepts that are of paramount importance not only for the professional musician, but also for music students and anybody interested in the intricacies inherent to the art of music-making. How does a single melodic line behave? How can we bring elements of interpretational 'cohessiveness' that will give depth to our delivery, & make it come alive? How can we develop our own interpretational capabilities, & Why? This is to--my knowledge--the only textbook in the world concerning this most crutial subject: it should be obligatory study material in every music school, university, & conservatory in the world!

Pedro J. Eustache says:
With all respect, I completely disagree with Mr Alec's review. It seems the point of the book is terribly missed. I don't think Mr. Thakar intended this to be just another "normal counterpoint manual". Mr. Thakar obviously must know that... instead, this is a practical, yet extremely challenging way to convey paramount concepts on interpretation applied into performance, 'DISGUISED' --so to speak-- AS A COUNTERPOINT METHOD!
The importance of this book is not small: to my knowledge it is THE ONLY book exposing, dealing, & explaining interpretational concepts based on a branch of philosophy called phenomenology [& yes, you are right, it might be too advanced for some], championed by the genius orchestral conductor maestro Sergiu Celibidache [Mr. Thakar's teacher].
Yes, I do believe you completely missed the point... Ah, & another little detail: Mr. Thakar was born & raised in New York City --ENGLISH IS HIS NATIVE LENGUAGE!

Shipping was fast.
I got this book for my school and I was the first few who got the book really fast. The cover was ripping out a little so I had to put a tape on it but I don't mind that since I got the used one.
Thank you! ^^