Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not bad, but Viriconium fans might be disappointed, February 10, 2007
I have always thought of M. John Harrison as a science-fiction/fantasy author, and although I know it isn't fair to label him as such, I still prefer it when he writes in these two genres, since he blurs the lines between them so well. The Course of the Heart also contains a blurring of lines, namely between our own reality and a fantastic otherworld called the Pleroma, which affects the four central characters in the novel. Even though Mr. Harrison's detailed descriptions and excellent characterisation does make the book interesting at times, something about it still did not live up to my expectations. Perhaps it was the constant alternating of the narrative between past and present events that confused me a little during the first half of the novel, or perhaps it was simply the fact that I loved his Viriconium books so much that I end up comparing everything he writes with these personal favorites of mine. This is the first fiction of Harrison's that I have read since Viriconium, and I bought the Course of the Heart after seeing it on China Mieville's list of Top Ten (Mieville being a favorite author of mine). Even so, it was not what I expected, but fans of Harrison's recent fiction ("Things that never happen" and "Light") might enjoy it. However, as a Viriconium fan, I still hope that Harrison will one day produce something that could, at least in my mind, live up to his earlier work.
One thing I should mention though, as one of the things that I particularly liked about this novel, is the incomprehensibility of the Pleroma that Harrison conveys to the reader. It was this feeling of strangeness, of a lurking 'otherness' throughout the novel that kept me reading and allowed me to follow the story through to its surprising conclusion.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Course of the Heart, July 5, 2008
M. John Harrison's novel The Course of the Heart, also featured as one of two of the novels in his compilation Anima, is one of Harrison's attempts to create a sense of magic and energy in a real-world situation.
The characters themselves are well drawn, existing in our world, or a rather dreary approximation of it. They are embroiled in a lopsided love triangle that crumbles, is reinforced, crumbles again, simultaneously drawing the characters together and pushing them apart. The sick and troubled Pamela falls desperately ill; her ex-husband Lucas struggles to reconcile with her, using a mutually-constructed legend to do so, as the first-person protagonist watches on. Frustrated by Lucas' indirect attempt at romantic appeasement and his own scabbed-over feelings for Pamela, he is drawn into the crumbling villages of English Derbyshire, which Harrison seems to have a strong dislike for, describing it perhaps not untruthfully as grey and depressed, mirroring the emotions of the protagonist and the feel of the novel overall.
It's not a wholly depressing novel; there are instances of humour, and the observations of the main character serve as welcome minor distractions from the story, which usually end up as opaque metaphors for the relationships between the three primary characters. A lot of the novel is metaphor, including the magic realism aspects I mentioned earlier. The first section feels like a short story, which in fact it was, in part, in his collection Things That Never Happen, which was itself an amalgam of his two earlier publications The Ice Monkey and Travel Arrangements. This shows through horribly, with a fast-paced, fantasy-feel mystery developing halfway in the first chapter, only to be almost wholly ignored for a hundred pages as Harrison sinks his teeth into the comparatively dull lives of his characters. At the end, the fantastical shared history of the three isn't even revealed, leaving the reader forced to find answers and satisfaction in the snippets of information provided earlier of a Heaven-like place called the "Pleroma", which was apparently punctured during a semi-forgotten magical experiment, leaving mad manifestations to pursue the three through the course of their lives.
This fantasy element is in fact the best aspect of the book, making a fascinating and delightfully mysterious read, but the great opening is let down by the rest of the novel. If only Harrison had devoted more time to the interesting metaphor and not the "real-life" complications of his characters, then the novel would be worth a second read. As it stands, the narrative is truly beautiful, extremely powerful and emotive without resorting to clumsy poetry. To read Harrison is to feel whatever he wants you to feel, but also in this case it means to sadly crave the better aspects of the story while making do with whatever Harrison wanted to concentrate on the time, which often feels like mildly irrelevant side-story.
If you like mainstream fiction with a dash of magic, then this is the perfect novel for you. If you were hoping for a plot revolving around one of those aspects of Harrison's wonderful imagination, like his genre novels, you'll be sadly disappointed. By Viriconium instead.
|
|
|
5 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, February 25, 2008
When this book was suggested for my book club, I had never heard of it or the author. The description sounded interesting enough, and I picked it up. Unfortunately I have real trouble relating things in the description to what actually took place in this cold, plodding novel full of unappealing characters only partially realized.
While Harrison's descriptive language can be quite eloquent, I usually found it mired in a stodgy pace. If I had had a clearer idea about the novel beforehand I might have realized it was not for me. Books without traditional plots are acceptable, but for me they must at least have sympathetic or wholly involving characters. Unfortunately _The Course of the Heart_ fell short for me on both counts. The book is short, but still took me a long time to get through. I can find little to recommend about this novel.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|