1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Strange, evocative, but unfinished, May 7, 2008
This review is from: Courting Shadows (Hardcover)
This novel about an early Victorian architect remodeling an ancient village church was hard to get away from, taking just three sittings to finish. But that anticipated finish felt more like a drifting off point than a finale. I'm still puzzling over the author's choice of ending it how and where he did. Sequel teasing?
The major characters were strongly and individually drawn; the protagonist John Stannard was nearly unbearably obnoxious with a stiff, self-obsessed and class-bound personality, yet was tolerable by a small core of genuine vulnerability - he yearned, dreamed, was capable of change. Well, a little change.
The most interesting character, and a perfect counterpoint to the cold Stannard, was Mr. Banks, the parish curate who was so richly thoughtful and god-like in his understanding of human nature that I had to re-read several passages of his mental meanderings to appreciate them fully.
Ann, the beautiful country girl Stannard encounters was opaque and strange though, and while the reasons for this unfold with the story, she was unable to open any emotional doors for this reader and actually seemed to grow more distorted by the end. And what really happened during their last encounter?
Sadly, it's not unusual to meet these unformed, or badly formed women in fiction written by men. What someone like Jem Poster needs is a female colloborator in the creation of his female characters. Just hoping.
And that ending. Not to spoil anything, but it was abrupt, weird and unsatisfying, like a song that forgot why it was singing. Perhaps there's a message in there somewhere but was lost on this no doubt obtuse reader. Sequel?
Good first job though and I will definitely pick up Mr. Poster's next work. He's a class A+ thinker and writer, and "Courting Shadows" was worth the read just for the pleasure of meeting Mr. Banks and frowning over Stannard.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic!, February 19, 2008
This review is from: Courting Shadows (Hardcover)
This novel has to have the most compelling opening sequence ever. I read it with the hairs on the back of my neck standing on end. I meant to put it down after ten minutes; two hours later I was still reading. Apparently Courting Shadows is Jem Poster's first novel, but it's hard to believe - it's so assured and dextrous. Characterisation, sense of place, atmosphere, pace, are all handled brilliantly. That the story is so engrossing is remarkable considering its narrator is creepy, unlikeable, and distinctly unreliable. Stannard, an architect, is restoring an old church in a remote location. Digging under an old wall, the workmen he employs hit a coffin - lead-lined. What follows in not a murder mystery, nor love story, nor historical novel, nor even exactly a gothic novel, though it has elements of all of them. It's an intelligent but thrilling literary novel. Read it, and enjoy reading between Stannard's self-absorbed and delusional lines. John Fowles crossed with Ford Madox Ford.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No