14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Misinformation and Glorification, July 20, 2003
This review is from: Courtney Love: The Real Story (Paperback)
In the last paragraph of this book's foreword, author Poppy Z. Brite states: "The purpose of this book is not to condemn or defend Courtney Love - everyone seems to feel obliged to do one or the other - but to chronicle the first thirty-two years of her fascinating life as accurately as possible."
Certainly a noble cause. And it's especially impressive that she'd attempt to write a nonbiased biography, being Courtney's friend. This is one of the reasons I think this book fails as an accurate and unbiased chronicle. You can't turn to the media for solid information on Courtney Love, because there are several different versions of every story about her. And you can't turn to Courtney Love for solid information on herself, because she's the one that gave the media all that misinformation. (This is a woman who's provided three conflicting accounts of her own NAME: over the years, she's variously claimed her birthname to be Courtney Michelle Harrison, Love Michelle Harrison, and Michelle Love Harrison.)
The publishers certainly must have sensed sensationalism. If they'd put an unflattering picture of Love on the cover of the book, it would utterly change the meaning of the phrase "The Real Story." But they chose to put a glowing, smiling, recent photo of her on the cover. For this reason, the book itself screams "shamelessly authorized biography" even before you open it up.
I have no idea how much of this material is true and how much is false. I'm not really a hardcore fan of Courtney Love, so I haven't read enough Courtneylore to know how many different versions of every single story there are. I am, however, a huge Smashing Pumpkins fan, so I personally can account for the misinformation about lead singer Billy Corgan in this book. For one thing, Brite states that Billy is one inch shorter than Courtney. That would make Courtney six and a half feet tall. This is undoubtedly one of the many "facts" Brite obtained directly from Courtney and placed in the book unquestioningly, without doing any backup research to see if she might be lying. (In almost any major article on the Smashing Pumpkins you can find, the journalist makes some comment - however fleeting - about Billy Corgan's surprising tallness.)
Courtney has often talked about how Billy comforted her after Kurt Cobain's death. For a few years after the fact, she even made it sound as if they'd had sex. Only recently did she admit that they didn't have sex, but said Billy did help her a lot in moving on with her life. In "The Real Story," he has no role in the comforting process at all. Being as how he's never said anything about it, Courtney is once again the only source of information - and Brite takes her current word for it without doing the background research and finding all the other, conflicting, things she's said on the subject.
Finally, Celebrity Skin. Probably anyone reading this review is familiar with the infamous Celebrity Skin wars, in which Billy and Courtney went back and forth in the media over how large of a role he had in making the album. In response to his assertation that he'd written six songs, Courtney said that he'd barely done any work at all. In "The Real Story," he calls her up, offering to help her on the album, and doesn't stop helping her until he's completely exhausted. At no point does Courtney ask him to leave. In various other versions of the story, SHE calls HIM up, asking him to help, and only lets him do some of the work, despite his willingness to do more.
There are most definitely more, but I don't know enough about Hole or Nirvana to point them out. It is, however, dubious that Kurt Cobain would have an "obsession" with guns. And then there's Hank Harrison, who's been given all the three-dimensional personality of a comic book supervillain. Like another reviewer mentioned, every man in Courtney's life is portrayed as having been bent on doing her in, while she's always well-meaning. This is the kind of problematic manuscript that results from trying to write a biography about a friend of yours - and assuming that your friend is always going to impart to you "the REAL story" about her life.
This book says more about Courtney Love than any factual biography could. Does she really see herself as the victim she's portrayed as in this book? If she didn't before, why did she suddenly change her perception of herself at the time of this book's publication - 1997? And why in God's name does she feel the need to lie about stupid, insignificant things like her birthname or Billy Corgan's height?
Whether or not she was in fact administered LSD at the age of 4 (or age 2, or 3, as she's claimed in various interviews), this account screams of a little girl whose painful childhood prompted her to escape into her own dreamworld - and whose talkative nature invited countless music journalists into that world.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Definitely not Unauthorized, November 25, 2007
This review is from: Courtney Love: The Real Story (Paperback)
For a woman who claimed she would never have an authorized bio in her house, Courtney certainly seems intent on never allowing anything short of a very edited version of her own life to surface (not that I blame her). For the record, I loved Courtney back in the 90's before she became the fashion freak and Hollywood gadfly. Her music was powerful as was her message that young women should make their own music rather than become groupie trash. For that alone she should be put in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. However, as quickly as she could, she traded in her empowered feminist personna, began to starve, had massive plastic surgery, and abandonned her fans. Sad but true. Now on to the book. If you believe this author, Courtney was basically a modern day female Tom Sawyer. She has rotten parents (reading her mum's autobio might make you think differently), people try to use and abuse her, but Gosh darn it, that Courtney always rises again! One implausible story is how when Courtney was a teen stripping in Japan the owners of the club try to force her into prostitution. Not only does Courtney manage to stay a virgin (if you believe that one, I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you), but she also tricks a guy into buying her a fur coat by only using her wit! Sorry, not buying. I liked Rossi's bio better, though it has problems as well. Since Rossi only can get second hand info on Courtney, obviously many to whom she had spoken had an ax to grind. Also, Rossi's own attitude often seems that of a high school journalist who wants so badly to be part of the "cool crowd" and when they reject her, she writes scathing articles about them. Rossi offers a better overview of Love's younger life while Brite (who had the benefit of Courtney's insight into her own life) writes more indepth about Love's years as a member of Hole and as Cobain's wife and widow. Really, you have to read them both to remotely get an idea of who Courtney is.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
