This is not a review of the contents of the graphic novel. Instead my goal is to shed light on the complex number of editions of this book to aid potential readers and collectors in making sense of the situation.
For some reason the publishers decided to publish at least 7 different "first editions" of this Graphic Novel. Each has a different ISBN number, but not different contents, and in most cases the covers are not substantially changed. You can use the ISBN numbers to search Amazon for copies of each book. At the time of this review, 4 of the 7 editions have Amazon pages, which I have linked to.
The numbers are sequential, beginning with # 1934220000
Cowboys & Aliens, called the "Retail Edition" - Each edition after this changes the last 2 numbers of the sequence, replacing the last 2 zeros.
#...19
Cowboys & Aliens is "Retailer Variant A Edition" and because I have a copy, I know that the retailer is Midtown Comics from NYC. Other than a Midtown logo on the back cover, and the different ISBN number, I believe that this is the same as edition #00. The indicia states "First Edition" and the cover price is $4.99, which is low for a book of this size and quality. Similar books from Marvel and DC usually retail for about $19.95
ISBN#'s 27
Cowboys & Aliens, 1934220035, and 1934220043 are "Retailer Variant" B C and D. Presumably these are like #...19 and were made exclusively for large comics retailers with their logo on the back cover.
ISBN #1934220051 is the "gold edition." - I believe this book is the same except for having a gold foil logo and back cover. The publishers must have used this ISBN # twice because if you search Amazon for it you get their other book "
Watchdogs." But there is a page for the gold edition on Amazon; Search for the ASIN string B003G84ZW2 and you'll find: "
Cowboys & Aliens - Gold Foil Edition" - from the excellent pictures uploaded there we can see that this "GOLD EDITION" was also under-priced at $4.99 and has a gold-tinted back cover in addition to the foil logo.
ISBN ..6X is the "Classic Edition" - Unfortunately, searching Amazon (And Google!) for the ISBN# 193422006X returns 0 matches. I'm not sure what the Classic Edition entails, if in fact it was published. Perhaps the publishers decided to stop after 6 first editions?
A second edition, or perhaps 8th edition depending on you counting, is scheduled for a May 2011 release to coincide with the release of the movie adaptation. The ISBN# is 0061646652.
Cowboys and AliensI realize this isn't a standard review but hopefully it will be of assistance to some shoppers. At the very least, you can now look up each edition to find the lowest priced copy, content in the knowledge that each version isn't substantially different than any other... And at the very most you could collect them all!