Customer Reviews

Creating a Mentoring Culture: The Organization's Guide

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

In an increasingly competitive business world, the need for having what Peter Senge describes as a "total learning environment" is greater now than ever before. With all due respect to formal training programs, my own experience has convinced me that on-the-job training (especially cross-functional training) remains the most effective means by which to create and then sustain such an environment. Hence the importance of mentoring relationships which, Zachary correctly points out, "offer an opportunity for individuals to nurture seeds in others so they might become blossoms, and blossoms might become fruit, which then nourishes others." Moreover, "When mentoring relationships are rooted in the fertile soil of a mentoring culture, they also enrich the quality of organizational life."

Zachary carefully organizes her material within two Parts. First, she explains what effective mentoring involves, how to embed it in a culture, how to integrate mentoring within that culture, and then how to implement mentoring initiatives. In Part 2, after identifying the hallmarks of effective mentoring, she focuses on key components: infrastructure, alignment, accountability, communication, value and visibility, demand, multiple mentoring opportunities, education and training, and "safety nets. " What we have in this single volume is a cohesive, comprehensive, and cost-effective system rather than a kaleidoscope of data, anecdotes, personal experiences, bromides, simplistic observations, and all manner of disjointed recommendations. That said, it would be a fool's errand to try to implement all of Zachary's system as is. As she would be the first to point out, all organizational cultures are different and many of them consist of several sub-cultures. Therefore, it remains for each reader to read and then re-read this book, complete the "Mentoring Culture Audit" (Appendix A), and (if possible) check out at least some of the resources recommended (Appendix B).

Regrettably, formal education often fails to help students to "learn how to learn." As a result, many people either do not realize what they don't know or, worse yet, think they fully understand what in fact they do not. My own experience suggests that, in general, people do not fear change; rather, they fear the unknown. That same experience also supports Derek Bok's observation that "If you think education is experience, try ignorance." Effective mentoring, therefore, requires humility and patience as well as knowledge and competence. The best mentors sincerely care about serving the best interests of those with whom they are privileged to be associated. They are passionate life-long learners themselves. Their enthusiasm is often contagious.

Obviously, I think very highly of this book. Zachary combines all of the skills of a cultural anthropologist with those of a clear thinker and eloquent writer. I also appreciate the CD-ROM which the publisher provides with it. Those who read the book can then review its key points while completing interactive exercises. The multiple templates can then assist the necessary modifications of the core concepts when applying them.

Those who share my high regard for this book are urged to check out Zachary's The Mentor's Guide as well as Senge's The Fifth Discipline and then The Dance of Change, Carla O'Dell's If Only We Knew What We know, David Maister's Practice What You Preach, and Gary Harpst's Six Disciplines For Excellence.

Dr. Zachary's book plots the entire process for creating a mentoring culture in the organization. Her book offers clear steps to identify all the issues that need to be addressed prior to a program design and implementation. The book provides insight into the levels of buy-in and commitment needed for mentoring to be successful and imbedded in an organization. Mentoring is a powerful way to engage leadership in their personal growth and development and the advancement of the organization.
This is an easy to read and use guide. The CD is a great gift offering the forms for the exercises.

"Creating a Mentoring Culture" goes well beyond traditional guides for designing and implementing mentoring programs by touching the core of an organization's capacity to embed learning and leadership development throughout its structures and processes. Dr. Zachary's strategies and tools for bringing people together to have deeper conversations about organizational learning will not only help sustain its mentoring efforts; they will help an organization revitalize its values and its focus on human development.

This book is helping me to create an internal mentorship program that will be sustainable. Well-written and easy to follow. It offers good advice and relevant information.

As a first year graduate student I am beginning to pursue my Masters in Communication, and until found Creating a Mentoring Culture, I was not enjoying my graduate experience. For the past year I have been working in the communication field of broadcasting, but all of my graduate classes are geared towards students eventually going into a teaching profession within a university and involve lots of theory, discussion, hypothesis and questioning but never give me any information that I can directly apply to my future career in a communication industry outside of teaching. I'm interested in how to apply it to my real life office. Creating a Mentoring Culture was a light in the dark room of grad school theory. It gives tangible examples that I can follow and put into practice. Lois Zachary has developed exercises, rules and activities that have been tested and will actually work in a real life setting. Creating a Mentoring Culture gave me something that I will be able to use in a real world, business office setting!