From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 2-Huck's spirited counting rhyme from 1 to 10 and back again trips easily off the tongue, and Smith's black ink on scratchboard with watercolor overlays provide appropriate ghoulish harmony. Beginning with "one tall scarecrow standing on a hill" and "two lumpy toads sitting very still," the verses proceed to "ten tiny mice, feeling very brave." They shriek, "BOO TO YOU," which is set in large yellow letters, and get a horrified reaction from the collected bats, witches, skeletons, ghosts, and wraiths. Then, in reverse order, the creatures disappear-"nine eerie skeletons laid their bones to rest," "eight yowling cats arched their backs and fled" until "one tall scarecrow stood all alone." The mostly black-and-white scenes (ghost eyes are red) are set in large frames, bordered by thin strips of color, focusing the drama. Smith's fluid drawings contain a balance of scariness and humor sure to delight young listeners and with enough detail to invite investigation. Suspended from branches that twine behind the frames are somewhat grotesque, somewhat funny faces that are bound to catch attention. A surefire Halloween treat.
Barbara Elleman, Marquette University, Milwaukee, WICopyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 4^-7. This bit of fun keyed to Halloween gives children the opportunity to hone basic counting skills. Huck uses a simple rhyme to lead little ones through their numbers--1 to 10, then backward to 1 again. The rhyming text isn't particularly fresh, but it has solid child appeal: "One tall scarecrow / standing on a hill. / Two lumpy toads / sitting very still." And Smith's stark scratchboard illustrations are very appealing. Although their frame-within-a-frame design detracts a bit from the main picture, the beautifully detailed scratchboards, overlaid with judiciously placed watercolor, give kids a clear shot at doing their counting. At the same time, they capture the eerie holiday mood without being overly frightening.
Stephanie Zvirin
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.