Most Helpful Customer Reviews
44 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Creole, maybe; Thrift, hell no, November 27, 2006
This review is from: Creole Thrift: Premium Southern Living Without Spending a Mint (Hardcover)
I'm not sure who in the marketing dept. decided on this as a great title for this book, but, um, thrift must mean something quite different to a southern woman who grew up with servants on a plantation than it does to me, pigeonierre-less as I am in Minnesota where I work for a living. She is long on charm & the book is full of pictures of her in non-thrifty shoes and non-thrifty skirts looking non-thriftily adorable. Her ideas are creative and good, and I could do them in a pinch myself if only I had, let's see now, my own seamstress, my own gold-leafer, my own ironworker, my own silkscreener, -- am I forgetting anyone? Then I have pressing needs such as: I simply must redecorate my sunroom, as it has already been photographed in a major spread by one magazine. And, of course, I must needs take trips to the Hamptons, Paris, New York, etc. etc., to bring back trims and silks. Honestly, to be fair, it does mention in the book the fact that Ms. Parlange does not subscribe to the NY Times but rather reads a friend's copy on Tuesdays: this is useful and thrifty. And don't get me wrong: if I could buy enough turquoise silk to make floor to ceiling curtains and enough white marabou to trim them, that would be my first choice. And, putting my cards on the table, I am a self-proclaimed title bitch. Good parts about the book: Absolutely creative ideas. And, really quite well written; the author comes across as somebody I'd like to have lunch with (though she probably wouldn't like to have lunch with me since I'm so damn crabby). Now, supposing I did have a few coins to rattle together & wanted to purchase, say, the author's trademark Madame X fabric: where the heck is it available? Why isn't this information available and easily stated? What can I say, the thrift part started me drooling & then I was so bitterly disappointed. Whiningly, Miss Ford
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I agree with Miss Ford....., December 3, 2006
This review is from: Creole Thrift: Premium Southern Living Without Spending a Mint (Hardcover)
I agree with many comments left by reviewer "Miss Ford". I paid full price for this book and was disappointed.Sorry to say. First, the title "Creole" is quite deceptive, in my opinion. Truly, I have no idea why the author chose to use "Creole" in her title. I realize that her plantation is located in the South, but the term 'Creole' in the title, made me think that the book was going to include many unique "Creole" ideas, --ideas never seen before. Unfortunately, that was not the case. Second, the author gave a few "transformation recipes" but not enough "recipes". I had expected to see so many more "transformation recipes" but did not. In a way, this book reminded me of some of the later "Shabby Chic" books (not the earlier "Shabby Chic" books, but the later ones). This can be a good thing if you like the Shabby Chic's (book) format, but bad if you wish to buy this book in order to get some inspirational & unique Thrift ideas. Third, even though the photos were bright and colorful, there were not enough photos of her transformations or her Thrift store excursions. Many,many photos of the author were included, that is for sure, but not enough photos of her step-by step projects. Example, I saw 2 photos of the author holding a few "thrift" items, but no mention as to how she used them in her transformations(eg:there's one photo in the book of the author holding a big brown foot stool. Why?) (Confusing). Fourth, as mentioned by other reviewers, the author failed to state where most of her "finds" or her papers and fabrics could be found. (example: are the products only available via her site...if she even has one?). I did like the (sepia) vintage photos the author used, especially the before-and-after photos of her plantation. But I wish she would have included some before-and-after photos of her remodeling projects too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I Thought It Would Be Better, November 24, 2006
This review is from: Creole Thrift: Premium Southern Living Without Spending a Mint (Hardcover)
I live in New Orleans. I decorate in New Orleans. I shop in New Orleans. I love New Orleans. I was wildly anticipating this book, knowing of Angele and of her family home Parlange. The production and photography is flat. Angele's stories are typical of many folks who live here, no more no less. Her how-to's are easy if you have a gold leaf artist and a few sewing ladies at your beck and call, as she does. I'm not saying she's not creative, or cute, or has a good story to tell. There are dozens of gals (and guys) like her here in New Orleans. I expected her book to be extraordinary, because New Orleans is extraordinary and it does have a unique visual IQ. Angele has all the advantages of being from an old family with old things to influence her. Maybe she needed a better art director and stylist and photographer and book designer to do her world justice. I also beg to differ with her Oxford dictionary definition of Creole. The Creoles in New Orleans defy that definition.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
