Customer Reviews

Criminal Vol. 2: Lawless

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips' CRIMINAL is the best crime series possibly of all time. It has such a dedication to the pulp-noir roots of artists like authors like Jim Thompson and Paul Auster, and filmmakers like Mike Hodges and Jean-Pierre Melville that these seem like great love notes to the masters of the modern noir. The first arc of CRIMINAL, titled "Coward" is such a pulse-racing and cinematically-styled story that I didn't know if they would be able to top it.

Well, they did.

"Lawless" is such an obvious title for this arc because of its dual meaning: The main character named Tracy Lawless and the seeming amorality of the characters of this world.

The main story is as simple as you can get: A mysterious man seeking vengeance for the death of his younger brother. Sure it seems simple, but as we get more into the back-story of these characters and their lies and truths, which are so brilliantly woven by Brubaker, we see how complicated and brutal their lives are.

As opposed to the 'coward' Leo from the first arc, Tracy is as cold as an arctic whiteout. He is ruthless and calculating, but there is a fire that is burning inside him that he may not be able to contain before the final act draws to a close... a fire that we see glimpses of in his past as a soldier in the current Iraq war. Amd once we do get to the final moments of this story, they're moments that you're not likely to forget anytime soon. The ending is so bleak and brutally honest that it makes most modern noir look like Sunday comic strips.

Phillips' art, as per usual, lends itself perfectly to Brubaker's hard-boiled, no-prisoners storytelling. The art, like Mazzuchelli (whose works include BATMAN: YEAR ONE and DAREDEVIL: BORN AGAIN), is never too cartoony but never too super-realistic. Val Staples, who provides the colors, is also at the top of the game as well.

Crime just doesn't get any easier than this.

I first encountered Ed Brubaker's writing on Marvel's "Captain America" series, which is perhaps the greatest run in the character's history, and I have followed him to such titles as "Uncanny X-Men", "Daredevil", and "The Immortal Iron Fist". Despite his excellent superhero work, he began his career and made his name in the more noirish field of crime and espionage fiction (influences which clearly carry over into his best work). Eventually, after becoming a star at Marvel, he opted to reunite with "Sleeper" (Vertigo) co-creator Sean Phillips on this series for Marvel's creator-owned ICON line. This volume collects the second story arc, issues 6 to 10, titled "Lawless" and following the character of the same name, Tracy Lawless.

Of the two collections currently published, I would say that "Lawless" is the superior to "Coward", and anyone looking to try out the series might begin with this; a caution, though, that reading this arc, while mostly self-contained, will reveal some spoilers for the preceding story.

This is a straightforward (in a sense) revenge story, with Tracy Lawless making his way back to his hometown to find out who killed his brother Ricky; more generally, Tracy has not been home for fifteen years, and, in the process of his investigation, he uncovers what happened to his more innocent (in his mind) younger brother in the years Tracy was gone. Fans of the crime genre will recognize a lot of familiar types, but spun in interesting ways, and, just generally, done well (cliches became cliches because they were effective). Tracy is, like most crime story protagonists, not strictly a sympathetic character, but the audience is made to take his side anyway; everyone's the hero of his own story, after all.

Both story and art are deceptively simple, and that's how Brubaker and Phillips get you hooked. Tracy Lawless is a bad dude going after other bad dudes -- the ones that killed his younger brother. Classic revenge story that never gets old. This book (along with Asterios Polyp) restored my faith in comics. I'd stopped reading them for a long time. But Lawless delivers and I'm hooked on Brubaker and Phillips. Bravo!

All the other reviewers have pretty much covered everything I might have to say about this so all I can add for my two cents is that I agree with the positive reviews on this product.. personally I found myself liking Volume 1 "Coward" more than this but it's still a good read.

Greetings,

I usually find it pointless to comment on a ongoing series because future publications can really impact my impression. However, I am confident that this series will continue to shine.

I am also confident that Lawless, the second book, will remain the highlight of the series. It is the highlight not only because of the great story and characters but because it succinctly sums up the whole voice of the series.

We live in a world that is driven by the law at the expense of justice. The difference between the law and justice is so apparent that even a child knows the difference yet adults turn a blind eye to it every day.

Well not the characters in Criminal, especially Tracy. That is why his name is so apt. An ironic play on words. He doesn't need rules, or laws, to tell him what is right and wrong. He knows. We all know. He is lawless, in name and in action. He doesn't need the law; he needs justice.

Ed Brubaker is one of my favorite writers on the DAREDEVIL monthly comic, which he's still currently writing. He constantly produces razor-sharp dialogue, believable emotion, and enough twists and turns to keep me on my toes. He also had an incredible run on CATWOMAN. His recent work on CAPTAIN AMERICA (especially concerning the resurrection of Bucky Barnes as Winter Soldier and the death of Steve Rogers) catapulted him to national attention.

However, I enjoy Brubaker's CRIMINAL comics as much as anything he's written. So far Brubaker and artist Sean Phillips have finished three graphic novels' worth of material. The series won an Eisner Award in 2007 for Best New Series.

Brubaker and Phillips put stories together whenever they can, then run them as mini-series before they're eventually gathered into graphic novels. I love the stories because they're hard hitting noir tales about tough guys, violence, and constant danger. There's not a superhero among them, and very few innocents.

LAWLESS is the second collection, and it's a barbed-wire punch to the throat. Sleek and deadly as a bullet, the story of Tracy Lawless's quest for revenge after his brother ends up dead rockets along to a climatic finish that belongs on the big screen.

Brubaker's narrative, echoed by Phillips's art, is interesting in this arc. Instead of simply breaking the story out from start to finish, Brubaker reveals everything in episodic chunks. He starts with an action, like killing a man on a rooftop and disposing of his body in a Dumpster in the alley, then circles back around to tell readers who the man was and why Tracy killed him.

Looking back through the graphic novel, I noticed how deliberate the reveals were. Brubaker dropped pebbles of plot into the pond of his story, then chased the ripples out for the readers till everything came together. The method is very effective, like getting a bite-size chunk of a mystery that allows you a look at only one piece of a larger puzzle.

Tracy's background isn't delivered in a large info dump either. Nor is everything completely explained. I still want to know what happened to Tracy and Ricky's father, and even what happened to Ricky that put him into a life of crime. That's because the character feel so real on the pages. Even though I didn't get every answer, Brubaker and Phillips provide enough that I knew Tracy Lawless and the kind of guy he was. He's the same kind of guy who's adventures I enjoyed in the pages of the Gold Medal novels I read while growing up. Evidently Brubaker haunted the same aisles in similar bookshops.

Ricky Lawless was a wheelman for a gang. He drove the getaway car. But after a heist goes bad, Ricky ends up shot to death. Tracy is a soldier, a man with a harsh past that has no problem killing people he thinks needs to be killed. The problem is, he's not sure who killed Ricky, but he knows once he finds out he's going to kill whoever it was. In the meantime, he has to infiltrate the gang, help break out one of the members from prison, and stay out of the clutches of a mysterious group of killers that have somehow gotten onto his tail.

The art in the book complements the story, providing mood and atmosphere. Phillips's style and take on grungy metropolitan areas and action is fantastic. The layout of the scenes, the exposition of the surroundings and the snap-focus on characters, show just how easily the story could be rendered to cinema.

The language and story are harsh, so LAWLESS might not be everyone's cup of tea. But fans of noir are going to feel right at home in these pages.

This trade paperback collects issues #6 to #10 of Marvel's Criminal series from the same creative team as the outstanding 2003-2005 DC/Wildstorm series Sleeper. These five issues comprise a second story arc with a (mostly) new set of characters. Tracy Lawless leaves the Army and returns to "The City" to avenge the death of his estranged younger brother Ricky. Unlike most comic book plots, the gritty, rated-R realism herein requires no leaps of faith from the reader. This book met my high expectations and is very strongly recommended for both regular fans of comics and graphic novels as well as a much wider audience.

This is A great crime story from the team that brought you Sleeper and the first volume of this series Coward. Ed Brubaker(Daredevil,X-men,and more infamously the man who killed Captain America) and Sean Phillips(Batman,Wildcats,and Marvel Zombies)have created what amounts to a hard kiss on the mouth to noir.Brubaker's writing is amazing pulling the story into the present while keeping the flavor of the decades (or centuries or millenium) old revenge story.The art by Phillips is incredible and detailed from the intense covers to the handle taped snub nose it just doesn't get any better than this. I would also like to note that you should be buying this in single issue (Amazon faux pas) for the essay's and extra's in the back pages of the book by other artist's who love the genre.This series starts up again in Feb. 2008 so be sure to pick it up when it hits until then if you see me at the Undertow buy me A beer I could use it.