Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Compassionate and Insightful View of a Nurse's First Year, June 1, 2010
This review is from: Critical Care: A New Nurse Faces Death, Life, and Everything in Between (Hardcover)
Countless books, movies and television dramas have been devoted to the lives of doctors, but what about those unsung heroes: nurses? Nurses provide the vast majority of patient care: from administering treatment to monitoring vitals to cleaning up accidents to counseling patients and patient advocacy. Still little is known about the professional lives of these vital medical providers.
Stepping into this void is nurse-author Theresa Brown in Critical Care who documents her first year as a R.N. in the oncology ward of a large teaching hospital. Brown, a former Tufts University English professor, is better equipped than most to share the real day to day lives of modern nurses. Brown explains her mid-life career change from the ivy walls of academia to the stressed halls of the nursing floor as a choice for a more chaotic, but meaningful professional life.
Critical Care is a beautifully written insider's account of what really happens at a present-day hospital. And the truth is somewhere between the gloried angels of Marcus Welby and the pill-popping antics of Nurse Jackie. Some nurses pull rank and wield authority like a weapon. Some nurses help their colleagues and bond over cups of coffee. Some physicians expect to be treated like demi-gods. Some physicians treat the nurses and their patients with respect. Some patients and their families harangue their caregivers. Some patients praise their nurses as "angels." Every story is, however, compelling.
As Brown confesses:
Anyone hearing a true nursing story will not want to believe it. The level of vulnerability, dependence, and fear experienced by patients in the hospital remains far outside the realm of normal, everyday life, and none of us want to imagine ourselves in that position. But people find themselves there, regardless, and they find nurses there too. Doctors don't do poop; they're concerned with other things. That's OK, but it's a difference between the two jobs. Probably they don't do Bibles either. But nurses have to get to the heart of the matter, whatever that may be.
Getting to the heart of the matter - whether it is finding a Bible for a patient or listening to a few Bruce Springsteen songs with a patient - is what Critical Care does best!
Publisher: HarperStudio (June 1, 2010), 208 pages.
Advance Review Copy Provided Courtesy of the Publisher.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A Passable but Unexceptional Nursing Memoir, June 16, 2010
This review is from: Critical Care: A New Nurse Faces Death, Life, and Everything in Between (Hardcover)
Theresa Brown has made a mid-life career change, trading in her job as an English professor in order to begin anew in nursing. "I liked teaching, and at times I found in enjoyable enough, but I never felt passionately about it, for better or for worse," says Brown of her previous career, and given the serviceable but bland prose in which she tells her story one is well able to believe that English was never her passion.
Brown is extremely enthusiastic about her new job, and she is proud of what she does. Perhaps a little too proud. Her descriptions of grateful patients and her own tenacious, mongoose-like determination to do absolutely anything for them may give more modest readers a twinge of displaced embarrassment. Throughout the book she shares a number of patient stories with accompanying philosophizing. The stories of suffering oncology patients are inherently touching; her philosophy is of the Chicken Soup for the Soul variety, certainly deeply felt but nothing out of the common way.
The book, despite being written by a medical professional, is sprinkled with inaccurate statements and downright false medical information. According to Brown, cholera causes lethal dehydration that "only IV fluids can control". In reality, literally millions of lives have been saved with oral rehydration therapy as a treatment for cholera. She says, with "100 percent certainty", that no doctor in the United States ever collects feces for occult blood sampling. This actually happens quite regularly during rectal exams in family practice, and in many other circumstances. These may seem like minor quibbles but one does not like to see this type of factual error, especially as Brown heavily emphasizes the importance of patient education.
The best part of the book, by far, is the chapter entitled "A Day on the Wards". Brown really captures the reality of a day of nursing, making this chapter a great read for people considering a nursing career or for those who are interested in learning more about medicine in practice. Overall, the book is perhaps best for those that are very new to the world of medicine. Those who have read medical memoirs or been heavily involved in health care as patients or medical professionals may not find much that is novel here. However, one thing is very clear; Theresa Brown is no doubt an excellent and dedicated nurse.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent read, June 1, 2010
This review is from: Critical Care: A New Nurse Faces Death, Life, and Everything in Between (Hardcover)
My favorite books, whether novels or memoirs, are those that allow me to connect with the narrator, that speak with a distinctive voice, that offer a deeper understanding of our human condition, and that leave me feeling enriched by the encounter. This beautifully written book delivered on all fronts. I follow the author's columns on The Well (The New York Times's online health feature), so I was eager to read her in a more expanded format. I'm so glad I did. The whole book is an excellent read. The book gives us a fascinating view into Theresa Brown's introductory year as an oncology nurse, complete with unexpected professional and personal challenges that she handles with thoughtfulness and wit. I especially liked the way the chapter "A Day on the Floor" powerfully and effectively brings home the multi-layered experience of nursing, even to readers (like me) whose only medical experience has been as an occasional patient. I found myself reading many passages aloud to my husband. This is one of those books you want to share with your friends for purely selfish reasons, just so you can have the opportunity to discuss it together.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|