From School Library Journal
PreSchool-Grade 4-This unique picture-book and tape set provides a fresh look at the Earth from the perspective of some of its most important inhabitants, endangered animals. The lyrics for each of the 10 songs are printed in the book along with a portrait of the featured animal, creating a gallery effect. With a tone more heartfelt than preachy, the songs celebrate our planet while offering a gentle environmental message. The language is simple, poetic, and rhythmic. The first song describes the jungle as "Home to cheetah/Home to bat/Home to human wearing hat/Monkey and machete swing high/Under same blue sky." In "Pretty Tree," a guileless giant panda wonders at the funny sound "(chop! chop!)" that shakes the ground beneath his bamboo tree. Some of the selections are a little lighter in tone. In "I've Never Eaten a Princess," a Komodo dragon complains about the negative image perpetuated by fairy tales, and a great egret declares with great dignity, "I am not a hat." Weeks's crystal-clear voice is pleasant to listen to and the catchy tunes have a nice variety of tempos and styles. While younger listeners will find the music appealing, the lyrics are sophisticated enough to interest older children. Ehlert's brightly colored-collage illustrations are breathtaking. Presented against a clean background of brilliant orange and deep green, the simply constructed images capture the essence of each animal. A Galapagos tortoise lumbers slowly across the page on huge, knobbed, green legs, and a green-eyed tiger shows off his stunning coat of stripes. Although the songs could be read aloud, this invitingly innovative look and listen at planet Earth works best as a package.
Joy Fleishhacker, New York Public LibraryCopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 4-7. Written from the points of view of endangered and extinct animals, Weeks' songs express a variety of thoughts, from the Komodo dragon's protest that he would never
dream of eating a princess ("Surely her crown / Would get caught going down / And all of that taffeta--ick") to the dinosaur's lament ("Nothing left of me but a bunch of bones / That some museum in Cleveland owns") to the idea of Earth as a spinning top ("It's a perfect spinning circle / Balanced on a pin / Don't touch it, don't touch it / Let it spin"). Sometimes funny, sometimes touching, the songs succeed in entertaining listeners as well as persuading them to think more sympathetically of the animals' points of view. Although the tunes would be difficult for children to sing aloud, Weeks' lilting voice on the cassette tape that accompanies the book may inspire them to try. Ehlert's bold colors, distinctive collages, and sure sense of design make this a visually dynamic book for sharing with a classroom full of children. Consider multiple copies, since teacher demand for this effective book/cassette kit could skyrocket around Earth Day.
Carolyn Phelan