Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Serial Witchery, March 8, 2005
This review is from: Crone's Moon: A Rowan Gant Investigation: A Rowan Gant Investigation (Rowan Gant Investigations) (Paperback)
With this volume, the 5th in the Rowan Gant Investigation series, Sellars stakes out new ground, some of which I'm not entirely comfortable with. Let me start out by saying that I read and watch a lot of horror - I'm comfortable with a fair amount of violence. And violence really isn't the issue here but whether it contributes to the plot, is gratuitous - used in place of a plot. Crone's Moon skates very close to that latter and it bothers me since, after all, this is supposed to be an investigation, not a torturing.
This time Gant discovers that the blackouts that started during The Law of Three were actually due to a connection with a different series of killings by yet another serial killer. To make matters more complicated, Gant's wife Felicity has interfered with Gant's own connection to the spiritual and has managed to get hooked into the same circuit that has been zapping Rowan. Felicity becomes as frenzied as Gant in trying to stop the crimes and both seem to drive each other into fits where the connection to the victim threatens to kill one or both Gants. Throw in a lot of chasing around and some arguments with the authorities and you pretty much have the entire plot.
Other than the collusion of Felicity, this is pretty much standard Gant fare, although I wish Sellars would just once take the time to work out why all this keeps happening instead of just describing what a witch would call a 'bad hair day.' But there are only two plot devices in play, Rowan's arguing with his wife, and the secondhand violence suffered by witches in connection with the victims. And the latter is where most of the writing effort went. So instead of a few shocking episodes to set the atmosphere we get a continual flow of spooky epileptic fits and stigmata. This build tension for a while, but it also bogs down the plot. So you get to wince at the secondhand torment of the Gants and wonder why all this is happening to the main characters.
We never really get an answer. Instead, the conclusion is a frantic chase, followed by a very short wrap up. And now we have two witches who can't maintain enough self-control to be truly effective instead of one. And an Indian police detective who keeps calling people 'white man' and 'fire hair'. How you react to this will depend one what you are looking for. What I wanted was a mystery story with a couple intelligent witches (yes, there are intelligent witches). What I got was a standard fare serial killer suspense thriller with some spooky parts.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
four stars for the fifth book, December 14, 2004
This review is from: Crone's Moon: A Rowan Gant Investigation: A Rowan Gant Investigation (Rowan Gant Investigations) (Paperback)
Rowan Gant wakes up to find that he's had a seizure. He's had these before and gets the sinking suspicion the malady has more to do with his practice as a witch than it does failing health. When Rowan and his best friend Detective Ben Storm witness the mayor's daughter being kidnapped and the headless corpse of a local school teacher is discovered, Rowan's suspicions become concrete. Once again, he is channeling the pain and torture of a serial killer's victims.
Felicity, Rowan's wife, and a strong witch in her own right, tries to protect Rowan with a binding spell. Unfortunately, the spell backfires, putting her on the receiving end of the victim's calls for help. With both witches being pulled into the ethereal world, they need the help of Detective Storm, his sister, psychiatrist Helen Storm, and old pal FBI special agent Mandalay in order to catch the killer before he strikes again.
M.R. Sellars's action packed paranormal suspense, CRONE'S MOON, is the fifth book in the Rowan Gant Investigation series. I've enjoyed each and everyone and highly recommend this book for those who like the genre.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Enjoyable paranormal investigative tale, October 31, 2004
This review is from: Crone's Moon: A Rowan Gant Investigation: A Rowan Gant Investigation (Rowan Gant Investigations) (Paperback)
Months have passed since witch Rowan Gant has worked police cases and he hopes that phase of his life is over, but on a subconscious level he knows his fate is to put the bad guys in jail using his psychic powers. His wife Felicity is also a witch but she grounds Rowan so that he never loses his connection to the world. His friend Detective Ben Storm believes in his powers but Lieutenant Barbara Albright, a right wing bible thumper, deems Rowan and Felicity are the Devil's tools.
When Rowan starts having seizures, he knows someone is being tortured and he is being called into the case by whoever is being killed. Rowan and Ben witness the kidnapping of the mayor's daughter and the mayor wants them on the case much to the chagrin of Albright. Felicity picks up the pain the woman is undergoing before she dies. Next Felicity's friend Kathy is captured and tortured; Felicity feels her pain and knows with her spouse and their police friend they must find serial killer although they risk becoming the next victims.
A Rowan Gant mystery is always a pleasure to read as the audience is taufgt that witches are benign people trying to do good deeds whenever they get a chance. The relationship between Rowan and Felicity is so romantic it is what legends are made of and his friendship with Storm shows that people of different religions can still be good friends. It takes respect for one another and an open mind as shown by Storm's trust in Rowan's powers. CRONE'S MOON is an exciting crime thriller with touches of the supernatural that add spice to a flavorful repast.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|