Customer Reviews

Crossing the Line (Wess'Har)

5 star:		(12)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

"Crossing the Line," is the gripping sequel to "City of Pearl." It continues the story of Shan Frankland, who's been infected with alien DNA, c'naatat, which makes her pretty hard to kill. She's become involved, well stranded more or less, on a double-planet system revolving around Cavanagh's Star. (How this came to pass is explained in "Pearl.")

This time out, Frankland finds herself engaged in an intricate quadrille with three other terrestrial species as well as a sea-dwelling one. Frankland, a former cop who had specialized in ecological crimes back in the UK, can't go home to Earth because of the life-extending and life-protecting c'naatat, which various interests want for obvious reasons, and would take her into custody. So she hooks up with the wess'har Aras, who also has been infected with it, and who's appointed himself the protector of the sea-dwellers. They, along with a human colony, occupy one of the double planets; the wess'har occupy the other.

While this might sound like standard space opera it's actually anything but, because the author is as much interested in her characters as she is in the action, which is far from a bad thing. And the characters, alien as well as human, are for the most part over the top. Among the aliens, the matriarchical wess'har, and you'll meet a few, have very alien ways of showing who's the alpha; the ussissi act as translators; the cities of the isenj (they want to make deals with the EU for tech) are crowded more than somewhat. As for the humans: we have Eddie, who becomes the journalist with the heart of gold; Rayat is a creepy spy; and then there's everyone's worst nightmare, the sociopathic Lindsay Neville, the commander of the original expedition to Cavanagh's, who's not wired well at all.

There's a political element to the tale as well: Ms. Traviss, who's British, imagines a future in which the European Union is a major player in the space race, with the other nations less enthusiastic about the idea that humans have contacted other intelligent species. Then too, the author has a rather Green outlook. Some readers are likely to agree with the author's ideas (humans, called gethes by the wess'har, are greedy warlike beasts who prey on the enviroment and then pray for forgiveness). Other readers may be put off. Nevertheless, the story never turns preachy. It concludes memorably and will leave you satisfied although surely looking forward to the next episode.

Karen Traviss's previous title, City of Pearl, was but a prelude to Crossing the Line in many ways. That's not to say that the book doesn't stand alone--it can, I believe--but Crossing the Line takes some of the plots and themes established in the first volume and explores them further.

The line in the title is both physical and metaphorical: how far will you go to acquire for king and country? How far will you go to defend yourself and your people? These questions are what the book's plot revolves around, inspired by the loose thread left dangling at the end of City of Pearl.

Traviss manages to stay fairly agnostic in her presentation; each side in the various conflicts is given a fair shake, and for the most part no side is presented as inherently more rational or moral than another. This lends a degree of credibility even to those parties I didn't agree with, and helps to make the conflicts more believable.

As before, we are given aliens who are more than reshaped humans. This is one of Traviss's strong suits: creating understandable-yet-alien cultures and behaviors. A key part of both of her books, it is these aliens that are at the heart of the books, as they--not the reactionary humans--are really the ones driving the plots. It is they who make this book shine, and make the book stand out from the rest of the pack.

Though the ending of Crossing the Line will leave the reader waiting for the next installment, it's simply another iteration of how nothing ever ends neatly--the basic premise of the book, in a way, as Crossing the Line's plot started as cleanup on City of Pearl's hanging plot thread. I have no qualms in saying that Crossing the Line is an excellent read from an author whose work is worth seeking out.

Shan Frankland is now host to an alien symbiot that makes her both incredibly dangerous and valuable. Lindsay Neville still grieving over the loss of her baby makes some decisions tainted with revenge that will make her cross a line from which there is no return.

This is a complex novel where the humans aren't always the good guys. Where not all decisions are good, but all decisions have consequences - and as the aliens are quick to point out, its not "why" you do something that is important, but the consequences of your actions that count.

This book is a stepping stone to the events in book 3, THE WORLD BEFORE but it is a turning point from which there is no return. Earth is about to find out that decisions far out in space by a small number of humans is about to affect all of them at home and the Isenj will also not escape the consequences of their past invasion attempts.

If you like SF that makes you think about how badly humans might deal with true aliens given our attempts to deal with "animal" life on earth, these books ask some interesting questions, with some characters that are more sympathetic than others.

CROSSING THE LINE is the latest in her Wess'har Wars universe and is the follow-up to her first book CITY OF PEARL which was published in early 2004.

Though it forms the middle of a trilogy the book stands well enough on its own as we are once again introduced to characters from the first book such as Environmental Enforcement Officer Shan Frankland, a disturbingly complicated protagonist whose past gets a deeper look in this sequel.

Aras, an alien of the Wess'har who has been infected with a bioweapon that has made him a near immortal warrior for the wess'har, and a subject of embarrassment now that the war he fought is long over, also returns.

Traviss deftly weaves a series of plots together while touching on matters of spirituality, government, ecology, sociology, and ethics. Traviss' first obligation seems to be to the plot, her second to the characters, and she leaves her soapbox at home in favor of spinning an entertaining read.

The action takes place on the world of Cavanagh's Star, sight of the war which saw Aras destroy the settlers from the alien Isenj race and wipe their cities from the planet when they threatened the ecological balance of the world's native sea dwelling and technically unadvanced sentient race.

This time the story concerns itself with the subject of the title as the main characters are forced to consider and cross moral and ethical lines as human settlers and military reach the colony world of Cavanagh's Star.

Yet Traviss doesn't dwell on those decisions, instead she pushes on and tells her story, leaving the reader to try to piece together any deeper meaning. Though her novels have been compared to Le Guin's thanks to her ecological slant, the universe that Traviss writes is a pragmatist's one and her characters range the full spectrum leaving no clear heroes or villains.

Just as we begin to get a feel for Shan Frankland, her past as a police officer and the violent means she employed to achieve her ends are revealed. The stoic Aras, who suffered horribly at the hands of the Isenj as a POW and who through the middle of the book seems more human in his thoughts and feelings then Shan, is revealed as the alien he is in mind and body when he is confronted with a threat to the ecology of the world he is charged with protecting.

While readers looking for a more literary style of writing ala Le Guin or a dose of the New Weird as delivered by Charles Stross or China Mieville may be disappointed by Traviss' straightforward prose style, there is a depth to her work in the strength of her story and characters.

CROSSING THE LINE stands on its own but is best read as part of the series which wraps up with next year's THE WORLD BEFORE. Readers can also catch up with Traviss in her Star Wars novel REPUBLIC COMMANDO: HARD CONTACT out now.

CROSSING THE LINE continues the compelling story of Shan Frankland and the alien soldier Aras she met at Cavanagh's Star. Tensions mount between humans and the aliens they encountered there, as various factions vie to get Aras's parasite, which renders its host unkillable and immortal. As before, Shan is wonderfully realized, a pragmatic law enforcer who finds herself increasingly estranged from the human world as she becomes closer to Aras's culture. While there is a romantic element to this, this would never be mistaken for a Regency bodice-ripper: she is among non-humans and her relationship to Aras, while physical (discretely described) is more the intimacy achieved between battlefield comrades. Lest the romance-phobic reject this, there is more than enough military detail, alien ecology, and intrigue to overwhelm a lesser novel. While enough information is provided to understand the action, it would be best to start with the first novel CITY OF PEARL. Then enjoy this book... and suffer through the months until the third concluding novel is published.

Deft. Bold. Confident. All descriptions that describe the main character of this series, Inspector Shan Frankland, and the growing ability of its author, Karen Traviss. Between this hard action, brilliantly complex and exquisitely detailed world of a not all that distant future, and Traviss' other new novel of a group of special forces warriors in the Star Wars universe, the bar has been raised for techno-thriller sci fi. I've read other reviews of Traviss that wax poetic about her Ursula K. LeGuinn tendencies and depth of emotional range, but for me, its her amazing sense of realism when dealing with political and military matters that has me already impatient for the next book!

Karen Traviss is definitely a new, strong voice in the world of sci fi.

WARNING: THIS CONTAINS SPOILERS REGARDING CITY OF PEARL

The second of Karen Traviss's Wess'har Wars 6 part series (although only three have been published to date) is Crossing the Line.

This book starts in February of our year 2376, shortly after the conclusion of the events in City of Pearl, with Shan Frankland reflecting on her new C'naatat status and Eddie watching the Thetis beginning its return trip to earth.

We see that those on Earth have had some realisation of the existence of and potential uses for C'naatat and the lengths to which some will go in trying to secure/eradicate the parasite.

We also see that many people have to make choices about where to draw the line in making decisions and following orders, some making better decisions than others - and with some of those decisions having a catastrophic impact at a personal and broader level.

The book continues the story of Aras and Shan, plus a few extra characters that we did not expect to see again. We also get more of a look at the Wess'har - their homes, their lives and their political structure - and how Shan settles into life as a refugee among them. The Bezer and Constantine settlement also feature, as do the Isenj, with Minister Ual's character being developed further.

As with the first book in the series many issues are raised - issues of environmental responsibility continue to feature and be developed to an even greater degree than in the first book. However the author continues to do this is a subtle way with the reader being able to empathise with most characters and their views.

Once again the narrative is very fast paced but fabulously descriptive, the characters continue to be well developed with those central characters that survive being ones that I am certainly keen to follow in future books. The ending is absolutely stunning.

The book is even better than the first and I again highly recommend it to everyone (but strangely once again the cover doesn't seem to really reflect what happens in the story).

CROSSING THE LINE takes off where CITY OF PEARL started, with gritty top cop Shan Frankland, who worked with the elite Envro Corps back on Earth. Now she has teamed up with a new partner, who happens to be an alien infected with a parasitic life form, which gives the host eternal life. The characters are well developed, the plot is fast paced and it will leave you looking forward to the next book. However, I did find it tedious at times, was Karen Traviss telling us an great story, or was she making a political statement? Shan Frankland seems to be the only Human who knows the TRUTH; the human race's only desire is to cut down the trees for profit and skin all the bunny rabbits for coats, and no one can see the damage that they do except Shan, and now she is going to kill us all to save the apes. Hopefully the next chapter will find Earth has intellegent people, who are not fanatics, that can turn this mess around..

After reading "City of Pearl", I couldn't wait to read "Crossing the Line", though I did have to wait as it was hard to find a copy of this book in good condition. This one picks up where the previous one left off. I love Karen Traviss's writing and this book therefore doesn't disappoint. The author deftly handles writing a series, adding elements little by little while still habing pay-offs along the way.

In a word: Fantastic.

An imaginative and compelling sequel to City of Pearl. Some may say that Karen Traviss perpetrates a rather dismal illustration of humanity with this book. Have you seen the news lately? I say that she is spot on in her assessment. If only enough of us could observe our own folly from the perspective of other species capable of rational thought, perhaps more people would recognize this.