16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
LOVE AND ART, May 14, 2004
This review is from: Crosspoints: A Novel of Choice (Paperback)
This is a marvelous love story-and an exciting novel of ideas. An unsophisticated, idealistic archaeologist, Tara Niforous, falls in love-or thinks she does-with Leon Skillman, a potentially great sculptor who seems to embody her ideals. In fact, he has betrayed his soul, becoming a vicious, opportunistic cynic. Meanwhile, Tara's long-time mentor, the noble but aloof Dimitrios, realizes that he himself is in love with her. The action moves from an exciting underwater dive off the Greek islands to the corrupt, intellectually bankrupt New York "art" scene-and to a showdown in which Tara finally sees what kind of "sculpture" Leon has been spewing out.
This is a richly imagined novel. Alexandra York is a vivid stylist, and probes her multi-layered characters deeply, taking us inside their minds with enormous technical skill. She also understands how the choices we make affect our lives-as we stand at "crosspoints" (Tara's immigrant father's insightful confusion of "crossroads" and "turning points").
The first 9 chapters appeared (under the title "Becoming") in the "Atlantean Press Review," a showcase for writers inspired by Ayn Rand's literary legacy. Ms. York is now the third of the Review's authors to see their completed novel in print-preceded by Edward Cline's "Sparrowhawk" and Andrew Bernstein's "Heart of a Pagan."
Writing a good novel of ideas is a challenging task. The characters and events must be meaningful. They must also be exciting; one must never forget that one is writing fiction, not a treatise. As Ayn Rand said, the function of art is not to teach, but to show. But if a writer uses characters merely as vehicles for ideas-if he sacrifices them to some message he wants to convey-if he piles ideas on their backs like hods on a hod-carrier-the result may be closer to a tract than a novel. (That, sadly, was the case with "Heart of a Pagan.")
As Miss Rand observed: "... abstract ideas are proper in fiction only when they are subordinated to the story. Not when the story is artificially devised to expound some thesis. That is why propaganda writers fail. That is why propaganda stories are always so false and dull." ("Letters," p. 159)
Alexandra York's focus is where it should be-on story-telling-at least 90% of the time. Halfway through "Crosspoints" I did find it was getting too preachy; the characters were talking (albeit beautifully) at greater length about art than the story warranted. And I cringed at the name Ms. York inflicted on her art gallery-a heavy-handed borrowing from the world of "Atlas Shrugged." I winced when one of her minor characters started lecturing about Aristotle. (Fortunately, the other characters cut him off.) Admirers of Ayn Rand's novels would do well to note how seldom Miss Rand mentions or refers to Aristotle in her own fiction (as opposed to non-fiction); three of her four novels do not mention the great philosopher even a single time! Her magnum opus, "Atlas Shrugged," refers to him only 3 times in more than a thousand pages.
Fortunately, "Crosspoint"'s occasional faults are far outweighed by its virtues. It is full of exciting plot twists, as well as dramatic insights about the role of art in life-an issue about which Ms. York, a prime mover in today's revival of romantic, representational art-knows a great deal. This book deserves to be the # 2 bestseller-right after Ed Cline's "Sparrowhawk."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A safe place, December 31, 2003
This review is from: Crosspoints: A Novel of Choice (Paperback)
My favorite art gallery displays only "romantic realism." I call it a place of refuge because I know I will only find beauty there. I can let down my guard -- the guard against ugliness and irrationality that I have to maintain in today's world. That's how I feel about "Crosspoints." You can be sure that although there will be startling plot twists, you need never be on guard. Beauty and rationality and achievement are held up as ideals, and while there are a couple of sordid scenes, they are there only for contrast and realism. This novel approaches Rand's "Fountainhead" in its integration of a gripping plot with an intense philosophical message.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Romantic Renaissance, July 21, 2004
This review is from: Crosspoints: A Novel of Choice (Paperback)
For well over a half century there has been nothing new in literature to rival the sheer aesthetic wonder of Ayn Rand's novel THE FOUNTAINHEAD. Until now. Alexandra York's CROSSPOINTS follows the grand Romantic Realist tradition and expands upon it with a profound work that's sure to delight any reader who can appreciate an intricate and important plot developed through masterful use of language.
CROSSPOINTS tells the story of the beautiful young Greek-American marine archaeologist Tara Niforous and the two extraordinary men who love her. The first is her renowned Greek mentor Dimitrios Kokonas. The other is Leon Skillman, a celebrated American sculptor. Although she is attracted to both men in different ways at different times, she ultimately has to chose only one.
Within this basic dramatic structure there emerges a novel so rich and dense in both characterization and plotting that its depths are truly astounding. In viewing the love triangle of the main characters we are also presented with searing portraits of everything from contemporary New York's 'post-modern' art world to classical Greek antiquities, from wild scenes of sexual abandon to those of touching family life, from the luxurious dwellings of the super-rich to the plain studios of working artists. This is decidedly a novel of ideas--a novel of conflicting values and philosophies, yet it is also an exciting and entertaining story of larger-than-life characters making crucial real-life choices in exotic settings.
For those weary readers who have ceased to enjoy most of what's written today, this novel will be a welcome surprise. Its printed pages come alive with amazing visual imagery and sensuous details that continually advance the story in a fresh voice that's both intellectually and emotionally satisfying. CROSSPOINTS is quite simply the finest work of fiction yet produced in the 21st Century. It's also a promise of things to come--a brilliant first novel in what should become a brilliantly stunning fiction career.
--Bill Danks,
author of PROMETHEUS REBOUNDS
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No