Customer Reviews

The Crow: The Third Book of Pellinor (Pellinor Series)

5 star:		(20)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Many reviews seem to dislike this book because it is about Hem. I liked Hem from the start and was disappointed that he was not mentioned in the last book at all. Hem really grows is this book and I think the prose is some of the best Alison Croggon has written so far. This is very interesting and well written book. The character development is really wonderful and it allows the reader to have a better idea of how the war is going and being fought around the world by a variety of people. I'm really looking forward to book 4!

I was not expecting this book to be about Hem since book one and book two featured Maerad. At first I was kind of dissapointed because that was the appeal of the series to me - the main character was a FEMALE and not a "supportive role" character. I had nothing to fear. Maerad is still very much to main character. But her brother Hem is very important too and has something that will be needed by Maerad in --- Book Four!

I have to say that I was nervous about starting this book, knowing that it was written with a boys point of view. However, when I finally started it, I couldn't put it down. This is definately a book worth buying, and shows the strengthes and weaknesses of a young boy named Hem. Despite being an outcast he faces all odds and starts to discover himself, and also realizes that he starts to discover the true meaning of love and loss. He loves his sister, mentor, an untamed young girl, and an outcast white crow, much like himself. He feels many losses and the pains of the war surrounding him, but even with these sadnesses he can't hide who he truly is, which is a born hero, who is worth much more than he knows. To those of you who love the Pellinor series, this is a definite must buy, and those of you who already read this fantastic book, I know you are as anxious as me for the fourth book of Pellinor, The Singing, to come out.

I was very excited to get my hands on this book. I have been ordering this series from Amazon.co as they are released as I can get them several months ahead on their American counter parts. I must say that I was disappointed with the beginning of the book. First- Hem is not the character that I wanted to read about. Second- the start is slow and the plot drags a little. But- all is forgiven after 100 pages. I warmed up to Hem. I actually think that the authors writting style has improved each book and this book just feels right. I was done reading way before I wanted to be done. The ending is nothing but action. I put the book down entertained and wanting more. What else can you ask for in a work of fiction

I have to say that I was nervous about starting this book, knowing that it was written with a boys point of view. However, when I finally started it, I couldn't put it down. This is definately a book worth buying, and shows the strengthes and weaknesses of a young boy named Hem. Despite being an outcast he faces all odds and starts to discover himself, and also realizes that he starts to discover the true meaning of love and loss. He loves his sister, mentor, an untamed young girl, and an outcast white crow, much like himself. He feels many losses and the pains of the war surrounding him, but even with these sadnesses he can't hide who he truly is, which is a born hero, who is worth much more than he knows. To those of you who love the Pellinor series, this is a definite must buy, and those of you who already read this fantastic book, I know you are as anxious as me for the fourth book of Pellinor, The Singing, to come out.

I am a huge fan of the Pellinor Series and must admit I was weary of reading the third book, knowing it focused solely on Hem's story. I found the book as hard to put down as the previous two. However, some of the content could be viewed as disturbing to some audiences. Croggon's writing is enthralling none the less.

At first I was apprehensive because of the point of view that the story was coming from. I thought that Hem would leave a boring life in the warm, sunny city of Turbansk, but I was thoroughly wrong. This story was written with such brilliance of mind and talent that it was unmistakible in the way the words just brought to life an imagine in my mind. The most compelling part of the novel was where Hem had to endure the horrible existence as part of the "cur". The author just built a horrific yet tantalizing scene that in parts just made you want to cry for the poor children and their victims, and feel furious at the world that the Nameless one had built. Alison Croggon is in my view perhaps the best fantasy writer I have ever encountered. She writes in a way that secretly captivates your mind until you can not put her book down. In any case I hope she writes more books like this in the near future.

I was a little disappointed when i found out the third book was about Hem and not Maerad, but I had to get it anyway. I'm glad I did, it was just as well written as the two previous books, and just as exciting and real. Alison Croggon does an excellent job of making her characters come to life. I can't wait for the forth book...

Stepping away from Maerad's story we get into the thoughts and feelings of her brother Hem. Not quite fitting in at his new school, Hem is a little bit of an outsider. While stealing fruit from a local man, Hem stumbles across a creature in need of a friend, like him: a white crow, he names Irc. Soon things turn for the worst. Turbansk is at the brink of war and everyone is being evacuated. Hem chooses to stay with his teacher, Saliman, and stumbles again on a misfit in need of a friend, even though she may not know it. This book is a joy to read. It isn't as exciting as Maerad's story, but its nice to have a change of scenery. Alison Croggon does it again. With so much adventure and miseries I can't wait for the next chapter of this amazing series.

Unlike some previous reviewers, I very much appreciated getting to know Hem. I found his story just as fascinating as his sisters. Alison Croggan is really showing us how they are both part of this story and I am looking forward to the 4th novel.

This is an intelligent, well written & thoroughly engaging series.