7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dramatic tale of Kids making a difference, August 21, 2001
This review is from: A Cry for Character (Hardcover)
This was a super read about a bunch of high school kids who were fed up with the problems at their Illinois school and decided to do something about it. The book chronicles, in dramatic fashion, the steps they took to take their controversial concept of a student-taught character education class and push it up through the maze of the public school system. Nothing, not skeptical teachers, wary administrators, a frowning teachers union or a politically minded school board could stop them. In less than a year, they accomplished their innovative goal of being given a part of the school day to have no-holds-barred discussions covering everything from alcohol, drugs, to premartial sex. From the moment the classes started, things began changing at the school for the better. This was mostly because the students now had a place to vent their anger and frustrations regarding all the typical,and not so typical, teenage problems. Author Dary Matera does a great job of taking a backseat and allowing the students who created and pushed the program to tell their stories in their own words. Because of this, the book will strike a cord with teenagers everywhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Good Book ...., January 13, 2002
This review is from: A Cry for Character (Hardcover)
if you possess the prejudice that administrators and teachers are "roadblocks" (p. 39) and "stodgy" (p. 40) and want to have that prejudice reenforced in the most simplistic of terms.
As a reform-minded secondary school teacher myself, I could not read more than three pages of this book at a time without putting it down and counting slowly to 100. I picked this book up hoping to find some interesting ideas for student-initated and faciliated change and a blue-print for reform. This is hardly it. Instead, this is trash-journalism at its worst.
Matera, rather than being even-handed or objective, is often schizophrenic in his portrayal of the teachers and administrators. The two descriptions above come from a chapter titled "Teachers to the Rescue." He doesn't bother to look at reasons why teachers might not want to jump on the latest bandwagon; he merely talks to those teachers, and students, who were in favor of the reform and allows them to trash, in print, those who were "lukewarm" in their support. He puts white and black hats on his subjects.
He writes as though the school exists in a vacuum, and all that was wrong with its values was the fault of the teachers and administrators, rather than being a reflection of the community. He doesn't turn a critical eye toward the parents, despite that the crux of one mother's complaint was that the pivitol cherry incident made the town look bad in the paper (p. 21). Where were they when the kids where throwing beer-blasts? Matera never bothers to ask--he already has his scapegoat.
The worst part is that, despite his experience as an "investigative reporter" (inside back flap), he contradicts himself on the most simple issues. For example, he calls one teacher's French class a "difficult *elective*" (emphasis added) then in the next sentence claims that it "is usually an unpleasant high school language *requirement*" (p. 33, emphasis added). Furthermore, these same "roadblocks" to change and reform had during the year prior to the events in the book implemented a new block schedule and eliminated valedictorian and salutatorian titles (p. 31).
If you are interested in school reform there are many, many much better books that will give you a substantive view of how change occurs and why, sometimes, it doesn't.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Kept My Interest All the Way, August 24, 2001
This review is from: A Cry for Character (Hardcover)
Most high school stories today are all bad. This was a big difference. The book was just as interesting as the wild and crazy stories, but the difference is that the good kids who wanted to make things better are the heros instead of the typical jerks you see in movies like American Pie. I loved the book and feel good that it's making a difference.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No