Customer Reviews

Cry of the Penguins

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

This film is the only English language film made by a Norwegian(?) director and easily qualifies as being one of the strangest most patchy films I have ever seen.

The story is simple enough. John Hurt playes Forbrush, a spoilt rich post graduate student who is supposed to be studying biology at the University of London. He is very good in his chosen field, but is largely wasting his time drinking and chasing women. He decides that he wants to impress Hayley Mills, and semi- accidentally gets signed up for a 6 month tour studying penguins on his own in Antarctica. Once there, his loneliness drives him half mad, and he becomes paternally attached to the penguins he is supposed to be studying. In the course of the six months he grows up and becomes an adult as opposed to the fop that he was

The first half hour of the film is almost excrutiating. John Hurt wades through an appalling script (by none other than Anthony Shaffer) and does his best to be drunk and fey and enamoured by Hayley Mills. This part of the the film resembles an Ealing Comedy forged by a drunk Estonian. Once the story arrives in Antarctica, things pick up. Hurt's acting improves markedly, and the penguins start trying to steal the show. There is a heavy duty snowstorm, heaps of literally astonishing scenery, and Hurt starts chewing the scenery as he goes mad.

The main thing wrong with this film is the script. The dialogue is frequently stilted and shows a poor understanding of motivation and character. (Particularly in the earlier scenes). To make matters worse, the direction is thoroughly uninspired. The odd thing though, is that the spirit of the film shines through these mechanics. This was a film made in hardship, and made with love. You CARE for Hurt as he grows up, you can see why he becomes attached to the penguins, why he hates the Skuas, and how his time alone and his hardship makes him grow into a far improved version of his earlier self.

While it is far from being the best made film that you will ever see, I think that this film's spirit will live with you for a long time. Anyone who has ever needed adventure in their life, will understand and probably love the journey that this film delivers.

The DVD master is appalling. There are almost random changes in aspect ratio, from 1.85.1 (occasionally) through to the standard 4.3 fullscreen. There are frequent major distrubances in the image, partly caused by bad storage of the original film, and partly by what looks like a semi-broken telecine machine.

That said, I am glad I own this one. It makes me feel happy to watch it and it makes me think. While it is a curiosity its' whole adds up to far more than the sum of its parts.

...And it is definitely one of the oddest films ever made.

This is a very quiet movie, but beautifully and lovingly made. I never in my life thought I'd become engrossed by a movie about penguins -- well, surprise, surprise. By the end of the movie I was wishing it would never end.

I loved the film but should point out that I'm the only reviewer I have ever come across that seems so to do. I watched this a long time ago and have been searching for a copy of the film ever since. The Antarctic scenes are beautiful and John Hurt plays his character with sympathetic flair. If you're an animal lover and relish the thought of a film filmed mainly on location in arctic conditions, then you'll love this.

An ambitious claim for a film? - let me explain...

When I was 13 or 14, sometime many years ago, I was off school laying on the sofa with some real or imagined illness. In the afternoon, this film came on the tv. I thought - Wow that looks great I'd like to go to Antarctica!

So when I grew up I did - as a marine biologist. If I hadn't then my life would have taken a different path - so "This film could change your life" - it did mine.

3 stars, because it's not really that great as films go, but I am glad I saw it that afternoon in the 70's.

If you buy this DVD, it should be for your curiosity or interest in penguins. This is really not much of a movie if you're expecting a storyline, and it is a little slow getting started, but the information given on the migrations and life cycle of the penguins is truly remarkable and worth the (price). (DVD was transferred from film, so picture quality may not be what you'd expect from a DVD!)

Hayley Mills' character is the impetus for John Hurt's character to go to the Antarctic, but she has little screen time compared to the wonderful creatures that are the centerpiece of this film. Beautiful photography (Arne Sucksdorff, Dir. of Photography)highlights Mr. Hurt's struggles with nature. While a bit dated in the bits in London, Nature is never dated and the increasing empathy between the scientist and his subjects is touching and heart-warming. Some of the scenes are not for small children or even some large ones, but the film is a treasure.-+

This film is a great example of how not to make a movie. The story jumps from England to the South Pole in a very unnerving manner. It is sad that the quaint love story at the beginning is not developed and John Hurt and Hayley Mills never get together until the last 5 seconds of the film. Penguins, penguins, and more penguins. If you are writing a term paper on penguins, don't miss this one!

I agree that the first 30 minutes are fairly forgettable except for the very English loveliness of Hayley Mills. For one thing, although John Hurt gives a great performance, no one could ever buy that someone who looks like him, even a young John Hurt, could be a womanizer - except for the fact that in this film, his character apparently has lots of money left to him by his aunt.

I would not call this much of a SPOILER, so I'll continue on to say that it was rather ridiculous that a blizzard blew out a window in the Shackleton Shack only after Forbish arrives - a structure that supposedly had survived (as of the time of the filming in 1971) some 50-plus years in Antarctica.

I bought this in Wal-Mart for $1 and it was worth it for the penguin photography and behavior, as well as the realistic cruelty of nature they must endure.

Well sent. No worries with packaging either. Just a wonderful documentary all the way through. Both actors do a stunning performance.

This movie was totally worthless, kick myself for ever buying it. Watched half and through it away so nothing interesting about the movie at all.