11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
rambling, disjointed meditation on Edgar Allan Poe, December 1, 2000
This review is from: The Cryptographic Imagination: Secret Writings From Edgar Allen Poe to the Internet (Parallax: Re-visions of Culture and Society) (Paperback)
Rosenheim, a professor of English and American Studies at Williams College, has produced a rambling, disjointed meditation on cryptography, Edgar Allan Poe, espionage, Thomas Pynchon, and the Internet.
Unfortunately, Rosenheim's attempts at discussion of technical matters are nearly always marked by severe misunderstandings of the mathematics and physics involved. For example, consider his definition of quantum cryptography, which appears in the glossary:
"A form of cryptography in which, under certain experimental conditions, pairs of photons may be created that exert an influence over one another that cannot be explained by quantum mechanics. Measuring the polarization of one particle immediately and identically changes the spin on its antiparticle. Such polarization takes place regardless of the relative positions of the two particles in the universe, in a result that seems to violate the second law of classical theory. It is theoretically possible that a stream of such polarized photons could be used to encipher messages that could be sent over space in literally no time at all."
There are so many errors in just these four sentences that it is difficult to know where to begin. First of all, the behavior of entangled photon pairs is, contrary to the claim, perfectly explicable through quantum mechanics. Second, practical quantum cryptography is not currently based on entangled photon pairs --- although Ekert did propose such a scheme --- but a different mechanism proposed much earlier by Wiesner and Bennett & Brasssard. Third, the reference to the ``second law'' is, of course, utter nonsense.
Other blunders in _The Cryptographic Imagination_ include conflating monkeys and apes, misstating Zipf's law, wildly over-estimating the amount of pornography on the Internet, misstating the name of the Usenet newsgroup "alt.sexual.abuse.recovery", and comically misspelling the name of one of the inventors of RSA as "Ronald Rivers". Rosenheim even makes mistakes in his own field: he claims that Georges Perec's book _La Vie: Mode d'Emploi_ was written without the letter "e", when in fact it is another book of Perec entitled _La Disparition_.
This is not to say that I didn't get anything out of Rosenheim's book. I was intrigued to learn about Lizzie Doten, a 19th century mystic who "channeled" ersatz poems of Poe and other writers such as Shakespeare and Burns. But the book is marred by the usual postmodernist excesses: making much of tenuous or nonexistent connections, second-rate wordplay (the series in which _The Cryptographic Imagination_ is published is entitled "re-visions of culture and society"; among postmodernists, this sort of gratuitous hyphen insertion is apparently considered essential), and opaque exposition. Consider the following two examples:
"When I claim that Poe helped end World War II, the `Poe' in that sentence represents both a particular author and the literary genre he helped create and for which he serves as a synecdoche." [p. 15]
"Such a homeopathic technique for the creation of mysteries produces highly cathected readers; the surface of the cipher produces a crypt in us, which we proceed to fill with our imagination, just as the semantic vacuity of Khumnhotep's [sic] glyphs contextually signified Khumnhotep's [sic] power and his resistance to comprehension." [p. 48]
_The Cryptographic Imagination_ will be of little interest to anyone wanting to learn about cryptography. In fact, I can scarcely think of a reason to read it, except perhaps to see an example of what passes for scholarly work in some academic disciplines.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful insights but a tough read, March 25, 1997
By A Customer
This review is from: The Cryptographic Imagination: Secret Writings From Edgar Allen Poe to the Internet (Parallax: Re-visions of Culture and Society) (Paperback)
About half of this book is directed at Rosenheim's fellow academics, arguing the significance of Edgar Allen Poe in technical terms that were outside my experience. But the rest of the book more than made up for it, drawing parallels between 'crypt' and 'cryptography' as it were. Rosenheim makes a good case for Poe's contributions to both the technical and cultural impact of cryptography today
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Jargon-choked, but at times insightful., December 25, 2003
This review is from: The Cryptographic Imagination: Secret Writings From Edgar Allen Poe to the Internet (Parallax: Re-visions of Culture and Society) (Paperback)
This is an unabashedly academic book, and it certainly provides some ammunition for people wishing to play Sokal for a day and make banal snipes at the Humanities. But it also contains some genuine insights about the way our psychological need to keep and uncover secrets has influenced the course of the last century. People looking for a perfectly accurate description of how encryption works should look elsewhere. People looking for an intriguing discussion about *why* people want so badly to encrypt and decrypt things have pretty much nowhere else to look; this is one of the only books I've found on the topic. It's a relatively strong start in an engaging direction of study. Fans of Poe, especially, are likely to find something of value tucked away in this piece of scholarship, though it is at times unnecessarily dense.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
