8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent, Important Book -- and Publisher's Weekly Review Proves Author's Point, July 25, 2005
This review is from: Cult of the Mouse: Can We Stop Corporate Greed from Killing Innovation in America? (Hardcover)
Other customers reviewing Cult of the Mouse here have written that it's excellent and wise; a fresh, important inside look at the ossification of an iconic American corporation -- Disney -- due to its managerial snuffing of the very innovation and creativity that made it great. I agree and recommend the book to you without reservation.
What I need to comment on is Publisher's Weekly hatchet job "review," which fails to disclose a key fact necessary for any reader to judge that review's credibility: The publisher of Publisher's Weekly, Reed Business Information, is also the publisher of several entertainment industry trade publications such as Variety, Daily Variety, Broadcasting & Cable, Multichannel News, etc. etc. As any subscriber to these publications can see on a daily basis (and I am such a subscriber), Disney is one of Reed Business Information's larger advertisers and customers. Shouldn't a credible journalist or reviewer reveal such an important business relationship to the reader? Shouldn't the reader who comes to Amazon for information about a book be informed that the "Editorial Review" is not written, as most customers would assume, by an impartial reviewer, but by a reviewer in business with the company that is the highly displeased subject of the book? Isn't that usually the way journalists and reviewers behave -- disclose their conflicts of interest, rather than hide them?
Caroselli describes artfully within Disney the "don't tell the truth, just tell the toppers what they want to hear" type of communication that is so antithetical to the innovation and creativity that was once Disney's hallmark. Is Publishers Weekly and its parent, Reed Business, guilty of the same in its "review?" Hard to say for sure. But it's easy to say that ANY reviewer worthy of that name should disclose its conflicts. The failure to do so here illustrates just how important Caroselli's message is for corporate America.
So let me make my own disclosure: I met the author once, at a conference I organized about the harmful effects media consolidation and concentration have on creative artists. He asked me to read his manuscript and I was so impressed that I was honored when he asked me to write a jacket blurb. Now, that disclosure wasn't so painful or difficult, was it, Publishers Weekly?
Read the book. Decide for yourself. You won't regret it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Mouse That Roared!, February 15, 2005
This review is from: Cult of the Mouse: Can We Stop Corporate Greed from Killing Innovation in America? (Hardcover)
This not-to-be-missed read hooked me with the first line. Caroselli skillfully reeled me in, page by page, with fascinating tidbits and a call-to-action just subtle enough to keep me engaged. Yes, creativity needs to be nourished on a daily basis, and Caroselli's style of fresh, easy-going information had me thinking in big ways. I'm no Disneyphile and I prefer mysteries to anything that smacks of how-to. But this book cover caught my eye and from there on in, I enjoyed the ride. I last enjoyed a book this much upon discovering Dan Brown many moons ago. Get this one!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Look Out for the Idea Killers!, December 5, 2004
This review is from: Cult of the Mouse: Can We Stop Corporate Greed from Killing Innovation in America? (Hardcover)
The author's dead-on with his thesis. More than ever before, America's economic future depends on unleashing the creativity and innovation of it's people. We'd probably all agree with this statement. Even so, American corporations can't connect the dots between encouraging creativity and long-term economic profits. Conformist, rational thinking is often more highly valued than inspired creativity.
In an easy-to read style, the author does an excellent job describing the situation in one company (Disney) which should be at the pinnacle of creativity but suffers from a focus on short-term profits and top-down thought control. Sadly, the corporate cult references apply to most large companies today.
While anyone who invests in Disney stock or happens to be a Disney fan will find the insider commentary interesting, this is more than your typical business book. The author's successful career in advertising means he has some keen insights to share concerning the American consumer. He points out that we are also partly to blame, suggesting steps we can all take to battle the "fluff" and marketing tricks that constantly bombard us.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No