Customer Reviews

Curious George in the Big City

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

For an English 105 assignment
3-27-02

Curious George in the Big City is written in the common traditions of Margret and H.A. Rey and illustrated by Martha Weston. With the same features as the other Curious George titles, the comfort and enjoyment from the Curious George collection is involved as another adventure of George.
This book takes George and his friend the man with the yellow into New York City for Holiday shopping. As usual, George gets curious and finds himself separated from the man with the yellow hat. The book shows the landscape of New York City while George attempts to locate the man with the yellow hat.
This is a good book for family involvement among parents and kids. The child is involved in the soothing watercolor illustrations as the parent reads the story. Not only this, but the book uses simple sentence structure, words, and large print making it a fun book for beginning readers. Repetitive phrases help construct sentence structure and the use of verbs and nouns.
After either reading the book or listening, the child can learn the morals of life from Georges adventures. In this particular book, the lesson is learned that although the world is an interesting place, it is dangerous for young children to be alone in the city

For those who don't already know, Curious George is the beloved monkey hero of H.A. Rey's children's books. Mr. Rey (along with help from his wife Margret) wrote and illustrated seven of the Curious George books. The "original seven" are available individually or all-in-one as part of "The Complete Adventures of Curious George, which should be the first "George" books one should read - they are still the best by far. But for true fans of Curious George, those seven books just aren't enough. Since H.A. Rey's passing away several years ago, attempts have been made to continue the series; some more successful than others - but none really matching the originals. Often those "new adventure" books have been formulaic and even poorly illustrated. Although I haven't read all of the "new" George books, one of the better ones is "Curious George's Dream" - that's one of the few I thought was worthy of the "originals", even though still not quite up to the H.A. Rey standard. So how does this latest effort, "Curious George in the Big City", compare?

Well as you could tell from the title I used here, the illustrations are fabulous. Martha Weston is not only a talented illustrator, but it's clear that she loves Curious George - and has made every effort to re-create the world that H.A. Rey brought to life so brilliantly. While it would be impossible for her to "be" H.A. Rey, these drawings are as close to the originals as anyone could ever hope. Yes, when I look at these drawings, I know that George is back! Almost every picture is incredibly well drawn; George is very cute and expressive (looking very much like the George in "CG Takes a Job" and later H.A. Rey books), and the background settings look as though they were drawn by H.A. himself (highest possible praise!). As far as the story goes (which was evidently NOT written by Ms. Weston and is uncredited), well it's formulaic and not nearly as creative as the stories of H.A. Rey's "original seven". At least the prose does follow the original H.A. Rey writing style (beginning each story with "This is George", etc.). The plot is definitely lacking in this one (compared with the originals), but the for serious CG fans, the drawings are worth the price of the book. In fact the cover illustration alone is worth the price: with George waving from the top of the Empire State building (a nod to "King Kong"?) with all of New York City including the WORLD TRADE TOWERS(!) in the background. It's hard not to get emotional seeing this cover, considering what happened the very month this book was first published (September 2001). But seeing the cover takes us to a happier, more peaceful time, that's something George has always been able to do for children and everyone else - to provide a calming effect and make us smile, even when we deal with so many difficult times. Yes - thanks to Martha Weston, our George is back, and the World Trade Towers are back too. For that we can be very thankful, and should buy this book! I hope that Ms. Weston will continue to illustrate George's further adventures; perhaps it would be even better if she wrote the stories as well. I'll bet even H.A. and Margret Rey would approve.

My son is hooked on Curious George! This is a great series for toddlers as it is not only colorful and entertaining, but it actually teaches children basic concepts that are important building blocks for their education. Curious George in the Big City is one of our favorites, and allows us to "see the sights" right along with George.

This sort of book is very amusing to young and old, but from when a child is only a few months old it is already appealing due to all the primary colors on each page. When a child learns to read to himself I would say this is probably a very good choice as it is very comprehensible.

Good book. It's one of the older George stories and drawings, not one of the newer George stories and drawings.

I love all the curious George books. Who Doesn't?

author of "Hobo Finds A Home"

Authors Margret and H.A. Rey's wrote the children's book Curious George in the Big City, and this book is another Curious George adventure from this husband and wife team. This children's story is about a little curious monkey and his adventure of the big city, but his whole adventure was without his friend in the yellow hat. Curious George in the Big City is a good book for children because it carries on the classic story, colorful images, and moral meanings that have been found in the Curious George books in the past 50 years.

This classic story of two friends should be read to children of all ages. It has an influential story teaching children the values of friendship and other important life values. The colors used in the pictures to explain the
story are bright and full of life.

This is a great book for kids, but this book should be purchased in hard back if possible. This easy-rip book would last a lifetime if it were more complicated to destroy. All Curious George adventure books are an excellent addition to any young child's library.