3.0 out of 5 stars
Surprisingly, the videogame had a better plot!, September 28, 2011
This review is from: The Curse of the Black Cat (Nancy Drew) (Paperback)
Before i start this review, i want to explain that i saw the videogame first, so that may have swayed my judgement of this book.
The plot of the book is ok-with threatening letters and pranks (and sometimes more serious doings) happening to students and teachers at a girls boarding school. The only thing is, the videogame actually has a better structured plot! When the headmistress calls Nancy (and George in the book, not the game) to operate undercover and try to flush out the person responsible for the misdeeds, in the book she poses these 18-year olds as student teachers. At that age, they can pretend to be students-wouldn't that make more sense, because the students are more likely to confide (or let something slip) in front of a fellow student as one of their peers than a teacher? Also, the plot has been changed quite a bit for the game. But the thing is, videogames based on books are usually less cohesive than books-not more so (granted, i am referring to shoot-em-up games like Star Wars-Shadows of the Empire, which is a completely different genre. Since the book came out first, i would probably say it was an enjoyable read when released, but to me, a book, or movie loses all credibilty when a knock-off copy (whether a game, a remake of a movie, etc) exceeds it. Usually, remakes aren't as good in my opinion.
I'm sorry if this review dwelt on the game more than the book. The thing is-i played it with a friend, and that was the only reason i got the book. Which left me VERY disappointed
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
WOW!, January 29, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: The Curse of the Black Cat (Nancy Drew) (Paperback)
WOW, what an awesome book. This mystery was full of atmosphere and great scenes (very scary). The overall plot is very strong and felt like a very traditional Nancy Drew story. The writing was above par, and I would recommend this kids and adults. This felt like a very traditional story in an updated format. More like this, please!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No