Customer Reviews

Cut to the Heart

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

While perhaps not technically a mystery, Dianne Day's new novel about Clara Barton is a richly drawn account of one indomitable woman's determination to serve her country during one of the darkest periods in its history. Set on Hilton Head Island, SC, during the Union occupation in 1863, "Cut to the Heart" rings with the authenticity we've come to expect from Ms. Day, whose Fremont Jones novels brought turn-of-the-century San Francisco so vividly to life. She has captured the lush, steamy landscape of the Lowcountry so completely you can almost smell the dank pluff mud of the marshes and hear the constant whine of the insects.
Accurate as well is Day's portrayal of the Sea Islands' recently freed black population, abandoned and forgotten by their white masters who fled inland ahead of the victorious Union Navy assault. Untrained to survive on their own, the former slaves are suffering from malnutrition and the many diseases riding on the fetid air of the swampy marshlands.
Enter Clara Barton, self-appointed "Angel of the Battlefield" and future founder of the Red Cross. Sent to the garrison on Hilton Head to await the next battle, Clara finds herself drawn to the plight of the local people. While she struggles to understand their lyrical Gullah language and strange blend of Christianity and ancient magic, Clara defies the military medical establishment by treating them as best she can. She enlists the aid of a young black teenager named Erasmus, whose thirst for learning stirs Clara's hope for his people's future. Together they gather and stockpile the wagonloads of donated supplies which have earned her the unique battlefield pass she carries.
Drawing on meticulous research into private letters and diaries, Ms. Day provides us with a fascinating, although fictionalized, vision of this revered woman. In her liaison with Col. John Elwell, the married commandant of the Hilton Head post, we discover a Clara Barton as passionate about love as she is about her mission. Stalked by a demented doctor who is obsessed with a revolutionary medical experiment that requires an increasing number of live "specimens," Clara soon finds herself enmeshed in a bizarre chess match with a faceless nemesis who may be much closer than she thinks. As local blacks -- both adults and children -- begin disappearing, Clara Barton turns sleuth and, in the process, may have unwittingly delivered herself into the hands of her tormentor.
The mystery may be thin, but this well-written historical novel is certainly loaded with suspense as well as a stunning ending. It is well worth the reader's investment

The author of the wonderful "Fremont Jones" series has made a dramatic move in writing CUT TO THE HEART and yet that same "you are there" sense of place and time that makes the Fremont Jones' series so great makes this book great also.
I admire the research, the time and the effort that went into this book and respect Ms. Day all the more for it.
Clara Barton, founder of the Red Cross, an image in my mind since childhood, is brought to vivid light and the vague ideas I had are embued with life thanks to this book.
Bravo to Ms. Day. I look forward to where she turns her pen next.

It's 1963 and Clara Barton, "The Angel of the Battlefield," is in Hilton Head, SC, awaiting the Union forces' attack on Charleston. She prepares her supplies, falls in love with a married man and has an affair, and becomes a sleuth, tracking down the psychotic who has stalked her and terrorized the community.

Barton is one of my heroes, so I enjoyed seeing what Day did in her fictionalization, even if it doesn't ring true with what I already know about her. I also adore the South Sea Islands area of the U.S., and Day more than does justice to the natural beauty of the area and its people. A nice subplot has Barton helping a young black boy become literate and find a future. The horrors of our Civil War are also brought to life well.

But the book's pace is too slow, and Barton's bodice-ripping romance is a bit amateur. Any reader of the murder-mystery genre will find the stalcker entirely predictable.

Get it at the library.

This author has produced a fanstistic series (Fredmont Jones) of historical fiction with great plots and mounting suspense. This departure (Clara Barton, a known historical figure and founder of the Red Cross) is very different from her prior work. There is no question that the author has really done her homework on the history of Ms. Barton and wove a fictional account of one segment of her life. Ms. Day truly brings out a depth of understanding the author has into Ms. Barton's personality and certain activities/events during the War Between the States. The book stumbles bit in setting the historic contexts so the reader tends to run out of steam half way through the book before the plot really starts to move. Despite this, Ms. Day is a real storyteller and her historic context writing makes this book come alive with understanding of the society and psychology of the time. The book is dark because of the 'bad guy' serial killer, but still is a very visual and thought-provoking glimpse into a turbulent time of our country. Worth the read.

I was very excited to read this book as I have just discovered the Fremont Jones series by the same author. Dianne Day calls her book "Cut to the heart" a fictional work set within a historical framework. Its main character is Clara Barton, founder the Red Cross. Ms. Day uses Clara's unpublished diaries and other historical papers in this book. While I enjoy biographies and mysteries I felt that this book did not mix the two together very well. I found that the book was very slow and not very mysterious and I had to force myself not to skip to the ending. I also found myself indifferent to Clara Barton.

This mystery is by the same author of the Fremont Jones series. The setting and principle character, however, could not be more different. In "Cut", Day give us the legendary battle field nurse Clara Barton during the short time she was assigned to Hilton Head Island to tend to the wounded Union Army Colonel John Elwell. In the area lurks an unknown evil psychopath who preys upon poor blacks and who throughout the book stalks Clara. Clara's ultimate success in uncovering the source of this evil is matched by the magical invocations of Annabell, a Gullah priestess and practitioner of traditional arts. Barton's real life strong attachment to Colonel Elwell also forms part of the plot.

Although Barton's Hilton Head sojourn formed only a small, relatively inactive part of her life, the book gives us fascinating glimpses into army life on the eve of battle, of the workings of Civil War hospitals, and of Barton's feelings regarding the rejection of her services by Dorothea Dix and the U.S. Sanitary Commission. Day's description of island waterways and marches, and the life of the ex-enslaved Gullah population is valuable as well. The use of some of the sources mentioned in the bibliography in the back of the book plus a search of the internet will help readers place Clara Barton's Hilton Head experiences into the larger context of her whole life and accomplishments.

If you are a Fremont Jones fan, you are not likely to enjoy this book. I was so repulsed and disgusted by the story line that I stopped reading about 1/3 of the way through, checked the last chapter and threw the book away. It is not up to the standards that Ms. Day has previously achieved under the name of Dianne Day.