Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Shakira is a great singer (in any language), February 4, 2000
Not fluent in Spanish? Can't see yourself buying a CD if you can't understand the lyrics? Hey, that didn't stop you from picking up all of REM's early releases! Bet you're still trying to decipher what Michael Stipe was singing about! (Here's a revelation - he was reading the Athens, Georgia telephone directory backwards!) You can wait until Shakira delivers her much-anticipated English-language CD, but you'll be depriving yourself of some great rock-and-roll music that just happens to be in Spanish. "Donde estan los ladrones?" is, from beginning to end, a great album. There isn't a single song on this release that could be categorized as "filler." Shakira possesses a voice that can tear into fast-paced straight-ahead rock-and-roll tunes or caress a slow ballad with equal ease and skill. Any musical comparisons to Alanis Morissette (and there have been many) are ill-conceived, at best. Any physical comparisons to Morissette are played up by Shakira with her tongue firmly planted in her cheek. She's always having fun with her image, but her music is what it's all really about. "Ciega, sordomuda," "No creo," "Inevitable," "Que vuelvas," and the title track, "Donde estan los ladrones?," are some of the catchiest rock songs that have been written in the past decade. "Moscas en la casa," "Tu," and "Sombra de ti" show a softer, but no less impressive, side of Shakira. This is a woman who could cover a Janis Joplin or Celine Dion song and make it her own. When it ultimately comes time for Shakira to compile her "greatest hits" album, she is going to have a treasure trove of songs to choose from. Fortunately, she has many more productive years ahead of her which means that much more great music for her present and future fans.
|
|
|
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Alanis Who?, December 22, 1999
These frequent comparisons between Shakira and Alanis Morissette are tenuous at best and off base at worst. Sure the two share similar voice inflections, but while Alanis beats her listeners over the head with the same tired "I hate all men" anti-social psychosis ad nauseum, Shakira sings from the entire emotional spectrum, and whether her listeners want to get up and dance to such infectious numbers as "Ciega, Sordomuda," calmly reflect over "Tu," or travel through time to distant lands in "Ojos Asi," there is enough going on in "Donde Estan Los Ladrones" to make for a complete, satisfying and entertaining musical experience.(Plus, Shakira is incredibly beautiful! ) But before you write off another pretty face (as you should with Jennifer Lopez, LeAnn Rimes, Britney Spears and their ilk, who have never written or produced a piece of music, let alone sing well or even play a musical instrument), keep in mind that Shakira writes or co-writes all of her songs, plays a guitar and even helps produce her work (special kudos to executive producer Emilio Estefan for harnessing Shakira's raw energy and power without turning "Donde Estan ... " into just another sugar-sweet slab of pop pap a la Miami Sound Machine). Pay careful listen to "Si Te Vas," "No Creo," and "Donde Estan Los Ladrones," and especially "Inevitable," "Octavio Dia" and "Ojos Asi." Both lyrics and music offer a rainbow of styles, moods and intensities. If you don't understand Spanish, so what? There's more than enough in the music to enlighten you. Sure, this "gringo" (with a special No Thanks to "Miami FL" 9/22/99) knows enough Spanish to last into the next millennium, but what separates music of this caliber is that it transcends language, borders and continents. Artists like Shakira are better than the Ricky Martins and Jennifer Lopezes that comprise today's "Latin Explosion." Shakira's music stands tall amongst the best of today's pop (not there's much out there) and deserves a listen, whatever your language. But for those who need that Alanis comparison, fine. Perhaps we should call Ms. Morissette the North American Shakira.
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Shakira is CLEARLY the greatest artist alive in the sense..., November 24, 1999
Shakira's poetic voice and lyrics melt your heart and make you fall deeply in love with her mind. Beside's the fact that she is very beautiful you can't help but stay still and just absorb her words as she speaks...it can bring tears to your eyes no matter how many times you've heard a particular song. "Donde..." is a masterpiece which can be appreciated by all. It brings the feel of a hispanic culture and shows that love, no matter if you think it's good or bad, is the most important thing in the world. "sombra de ti" is one of my favorites..but that changes everytime I hear the album. EVERY song is great and that would not be an exageration. Pick up the CD, let it run completely..3 or 4 times..and let your soul wander, it's the best thing you can do. That's what makes this album one of the greatest I've ever heard.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
by Shakira 
