Customer Reviews

DK Readers: Trojan Horse (Level 4: Proficient Readers)

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I have purchased quite a few DK Readers books for my kids. We love them. This one, for some reason, has failed to grab their attention. I barely made it half way through before the kids started to suggest that I read other books.

This book starts with the jealousy and conflicts among the Greek gods (which, the story goes, led to the Trojan war). About a third of the way through, one finally gets to the war outside Troy. In contrast, the real dramatic part of the Trojan war--the horse (named in the title) comes across as a rather minor point in the story. Which is a shame given that the Trojan horse most likely is more intriguing to young readers than the jealousy and power struggle among some Greek gods that the kids have not quite got a grip on.

Aside from lacking focus in this short book (and packing in way too much loose details on Greek gods), the book sounds rather dry. Perhaps all Level 4 books are like this one, but we are a bit disappointed.

I chose not to use this in our study of Greece. It had a very cluttered feel to it - you had the story and illustrations to go with it, and then pictures of actual items from ancient Greece around the borders. Visually very distracting.

The story of the Trojan war is not pretty. This version has Hercules dragging Hector's body behind his chariot in a very off-hand, non-emotional kind of way. I felt like this wasn't appropriate for my 7-year-olds and especially not with a "oh well, things happen" kind of attitude. There was no real 'feeling' in this book and I think the story needs it to work.

I used Trojan Horse by Emily Little this year. It's a brief overview without getting too in-depth or too gruesome. I'll use Rosemary Sutcliff's Black Ships Before Troy and The Wanderings of Odysseus the next time around when they're older and can handle the blood and guts and discuss the morality of the choices made with more clarity.

We are doing quite a bit of reading about Ancient Greece right now, and I brought this book home from the library. We have already read the Step-Into-Reading-Step-5 book "The Trojan Horse" by Emily Little, and this book did not add anything to our early knowledge.

This book has a good glossary, including words like avenge, beacon, immortal, nectar, plume.

Arrived in a timely manner and was in good shape