19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best Atlas by a Pretty Margin!, March 24, 2002
This review is from: DK World Atlas: Second Edition (Hardcover)
Dorling Kindersley have redefined what an atlas is, by shifting the emphasis from rather technical cartography (as other atlases have) - to providing a lively range of written explanations, annotated 3-D diagrams, colour photographs, and graphical semi-3D maps, for each region. Their rethinking of the priorities does bring smaller, less detailed maps - but the detail is still more than ample, provided you don't need to know where every last little hamlet and stream is. After buying this atlas, you'll never go back to the old-style ones: it's like upgrading from DOS to Windows.
My credentials: I set out on a quest to find a book like this, and I didn't know whether such a book existed. It was to have maps, photographs, and a detailed realistic write-up, for every country and region in the world. I spent several afternoons scouring the larger bookshops, picking up perhaps hundreds of atlases, maps and travel guides. Then I found this :) And I had lots of money left over.
Content: The entire book, I must say, is very nicely presented, with flowing page layouts and colour everywhere. It is divided into 3 main parts:
1. World overviews.
2. The continents & regional maps.
3. The index.
1. A series of world overviews, as found in most other atlases - the planets, politics, wars, etc. etc, but better. They are graphical and colourful, with many little diagrams & photos. Everything is explained neatly and in plain english.
2. The maps themselves are organised first by the continents, then by regions (a region is typically one country, or a group of countries); some regions are given extra treatment for the more populous areas.
The bias is noticeably western-centric, with more space devoted to Western Europe, the USA, Japan, etc: for example, Europe gets 46 pages, but Africa only gets 18! I would happily pay more money for a more complete & unbiased coverage, and this is my first main gripe (of 2) against this otherwise wonderful book.
* Each continent has a 6+ page introduction with maps & photographs covering: physical geography, climate, history, population, transport, language, industry, natural resources, etc (similar to the world overviews).
* Every regional page offers a mixture of maps, diagrams, photos and text, all in technicolour. Almost all regional pages contain:
- a written introduction, with a small map showing where you are in the world.
- the main map. These are colourful, dramatic, easier to understand than traditional flat-as-a-pancake maps, and come in irregular shapes according to the regional/country boundaries. Every map also has its own scale and key, so there is no need to rummage around for those. But the scales vary considerably and wierdly, like 1:7,750,000 on one page, and 1:7,000,000 on the next, and obviously the maps have been scaled to whatever fits nicely on the page, with no concern for standardising them. This makes it difficult to compare 2 different maps, or to develop a natural sensibility for reading them. (This is my 2nd gripe).
- about 6 mini-photographs of interesting landscapes or cultural features - with explanations.
- a small physical-geography map, showing the main mountain ranges, rivers, and areas to note (which are annotated with fascinating little descriptions, often with photographs).
- a small land-use map.
- a small map of transport routes and industry.
- sometimes another small diagram or two to explain things.
* It also contains statistics & flags for every country.
* My UK edition also includes a 24-page atlas-within-an-atlas (with its own index) for the british isles.
3. The index covers all of place-names & natural features found on the maps, and is also very nicely done, telling you the page, grid ref, country, & lat/long for each entry.
* Summary. Much thought and intelligence has gone into this book. It gets 5 stars for being *easily* the best atlas I could find on my little quest, despite my 2 gripes.
Even people who wouldn't normally bother buying an atlas, should consider buying this: it sits well near the television, for a quick glance whenever there is a global news story, or a documentary about some remote place.
It is interesting that Dorling Kindersley should be the people to make this leap forward, having always primarily made books for children, while the other publishers continue to slave away at their overly-detailed technical maps!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No