DOCTOR ZHIVAGO (REISSUE)
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Top Customer Reviews
No, when I sat down to watch this 2002 adaptation of the Boris Pasternak epic I was all prepared to be both disappointed and resistant to a newer version of the Omar Sharif/Julie Christie favorite - so what happened? Why am I now sitting here so impressed and involved in what should by all accounts be a poorer step child to the colorful, star-filled 1960s movie.
Simply put this movie has the advantage of time. A whole hour longer than the other movie that extra time gives the production of filling in some of the blanks that inhabited the original and more fully exploring the human relationships and interaction between characters. Matheson may not have the acting ability of Sharif but what he does have is the opportunity to more fully realize the character of Zhivago. In this sense this movie is more faithful to the source material and all the better for it.
Matheson plays the part of Zhivago, a man brought up in the shadow of tragedy who feels the pull of loyalty to his wife (and childhood friend) Tonya and a deep infatuation for Lara. With the violence of World War I and the Russian Revolution as a backdrop, Zhivago travels through life torn by conflict.
Less colorful than the original this mini-series compensates with a strong, well defined script and some star turning peformances by Sam Neill and one-time Bond girl Maryam D'Abo (as Lara's mother).Read more ›
Hans Matheson relies more on the poet aspect of Yuri Zhivago than the towering hero of his physician nature. Keira Knightly finds more of the innate sense of innocence lost in her Lara. Alexandra Maria Lara finds more credible and three dimensional humanity in Yuri's wife Tonya. Sam Neill takes away the one-sided villain (as Rod Steiger portrayed him in the Lean film) of Komarovsky and shows how a man of such cruelty can still believeably attract not only women but the trust of idealistic men.
The battles are realistically presented, the Urals are magnificently portrayed, the devastation of Yuri's home in Moscow transformed into a grimy ghetto is well shown. For this viewer the story was told more through the eyes of Yuri as Poet - a bit idalistic but at the same time living life for the moment and enduring decisions harsh under anyone's criteria to follow both passion and duty. In the end, Pasternak's story is so profound and sensitive that it would be difficult to demean his intentions. See, and enjoy, both versions.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Not so Hollywood much more down to earth, still beautifully filmed. Loved it,Published 7 days ago by Arlynne S Olk
EXCELLENT MOVIE!!! WONDERFUL ACTING!! Kiera Knightly is a superb actress. I enjoyed every minute!Published 2 months ago by rose
Very good acting, but with the cast involved I knew it would be. Watching certain scenes tho I couldnt help but compare to the original, like the icy winter house they were held... Read morePublished 5 months ago by mary marks
It having had been forty years since the making of the David Lean Dr. Zhivago classic, it seemed an appropriate time for a remake, even if a full ten years after the collapse of... Read morePublished 8 months ago by It is a small ringdom, but...
Violent, with stupid sex scene, and lots of crude anti-communism which is not true to the spirit of the book or its author.Published 8 months ago by California Steven
Much more in depth of feelings and emotions due to the more acceptance openess of the scenes versus the original film with Omar SheriffPublished 8 months ago by Bruno J. Gallianp