2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Under--rated Western, December 12, 2007
This review is from: Dakota Incident [VHS] (VHS Tape)
Most movie guides -general and specialist-give this movie a bad rep.It is frequently dismissed as "Stagecoach" lite-a variation on stage passengers under attack from marauding Indians .Yes there are similarities and yes this is inferior to John Ford's groundbreaking 1939 masterpiece,but it does not merit the opprobrium heaped upon it by critics .
It is a movie of two halves .It opens when John Banner (Dale Robertson)is shot and left for dead by his two partners in a bank robbery.He is not in fact dead and makes his way on foot to a nearby town wherre he settles accounts with the backshooting pair .A motley group is assembled in town awaiting the arrival of the Laramie stage .The noisiest is a US Senator (Ward Bond)a moralising sententious bore who maunders on at great length about the need to adopt a more liberal policy towards Indians rathet than agree with the majority sentiment that wants troops despatched to the region .There is a glamourous entertainer (Linda Darnell)and her accompanist (Regis Toomey),not to mention Hamilton(John Lund)who seems to have an unusually deep interest in Banner ,to the extent of watching him like a hawk.
Despite the arrival of the stage showing evidence of an Indian attack the group sets out by stage only to lose a wheel and have the horses bolt .They come under siege and are trapped in a dried out stream bed .Their Indian adversaries alternately try full on assault and starvation/thirst to destroy the group which is gradually whittled down to just 2 survivors .
The final message is one of redemption and hope .The script is over wordy at times but the compensations are many -good colour photography by Ernest Haller,whose lighting skills saw him garner an Oscar for Gone With the Wind and whose work here shows the usually lacklustre Trucolor process at its best ,and a raft of better than average performances from a good cast.The action is well staged and this is a better than average B-Western
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A neat little westren, November 24, 1999
This review is from: Dakota Incident [VHS] (VHS Tape)
This 1956 movie is alot like the 1939 Stagecoach.While it is not as good,it is interesting.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
All aboard the intriguing stage to Laramie., August 17, 2011
This review is from: Dakota Incident [VHS] (VHS Tape)
An assorted group of people are waiting in Christian Flats for the stage to take them to Laramie. Once the empty stage arrives it's evident that it has been the victim of a Cheyenne attack, but out of need and bravery, the hardy souls decide to risk the journey regardless........
Very much a minor Western in the grand scheme of the 1950s offerings, Dakota Incident makes up for what it lacks in quality, by being an oddly structured film of intrigue. The actual "incident" of the film isn't until about the half way point, because prior to the inevitable Cheyenne attack, there is no shortage of character forming. In fact this might be the longest prologue in Western history! Basically crooked John Banner (Dale Robertson) is shot and apparently left for dead out in the hills by his two so called allies. Getting to the town he proceeds to annoy everyone with his oafishness and of course catch up with the two who wronged him. In amongst all this we are also following the interests of the few who will eventually make up the stage passengers. With sultry Amy Clarke {Linda Darnell}, John Carter {John Lund}, Regis Toomey's Minstrel and Senator Blakely {Ward Bond} being the main principals. All of whom have back stories as to why they are making this decidedly perilous trip.
It's very good stuff for its first half, in fact I tip my hat off to the makers for really giving the characters some substance. Yes we may not like them really, but at least our attention is held and as they board the stage, we are intrigued as to how things will pan out for them. The second half tho is a mixed bag, the action sequences are poorly put together but are off set a touch by the nice locale work at Red Rock Canyon State Park. While using the "Trucolor" technique really adds a vivid look to the action. None more so than the sight of the vivacious and curvy Darnell, resplendent in bright red dress, firing away at the Cheyenne with her newly acquired rifle. Dale Robertson and John Lund are average at best, but again it's not hurting the film too much because Darnell, Bond and Toomey are holding their ends up. The ending is perhaps a bit twee for some tastes, but it does work and closes the picture on a competent note.
Republic Pictures have done far better films than this, and this one is a tough picture to recommend to even the hardiest of Western fans. But it's got a beguiling factor, and an oddity that means it's definitely one to at least try to see if the chance should arise.
A cautious 6/10 from me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
