8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
better than the last one..., September 26, 2009
This review is from: The Dance of Death (Roger the Chapman Mysteries) (Hardcover)
This is the latest in the Roger the Chapman series and although I think is it better than the Green Man, the previous release in the series, this is still not up to the standard of the earlier books about Roger and his travels. The story itself is OK but I thought it wrapped up way too quickly at the end - it seems like the story goes on and then all the sudden you are 20 pages from the end and wonder how it will be solved with so few pages left...it wraps up too tidily for me, almost like Sedley got tired of the tale and just finished it to get it done.
I also think part of the problem in these last 2 books is that Roger has gotten away from his "roots" both literally and figuratively. In the earlier books, he traveled as a chapman, or pedlar (sic) based from his home in Bristol and so you witnessed the interplay between Roger and his wife, Adela, his neighbors and his ex-mother-in-law Margaret, who is also related to Adela. In the earlier books, you could feel for Roger - he is a simple working class medieval man and doesn't really want to be a spy, but his curious nature or "long nose" gets him into these situations. Roger was always a chapman and family man first, and being a spy was secondary.
The last 2 books have had Roger away from home traveling to Scotland in the Green Man and now to France in this latest release, but not as a chapman - he is solely a spy in these last 2 books, and so we have not had the "grounding" of Roger's family and base in Bristol. He does complain about not having been home for months, but Timothy Plummer of course convinces him he must do his duty to the Duke and the King. I think even Roger recognizes that he needs to be close to home & hearth and is weaker in spirit when he is so much away from Adela, hence his second time "straying" from his marriage vows in the Dance of Death.
I just think in the earlier books, it was easier for me to believe in Roger and identify with him as a simple chapman who is "put upon" by his circumstances, his customers, and his wife and family, and understand that he only works a spy due to his loyalties to the Duke, whom he feels a kinship with because they share a birthday. I really "felt" for Roger in the earlier books, but I just don't feel so much for him in these last two. I hope he gets to go home in the next one so he can get back to being Roger the Chapman and not so much Roger the Spy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No