From School Library Journal
Grade 2–4—This remarkable story was created from a single line reference in Boone's autobiography. He was in fact captured by Shawnee warriors and brokered a deal where he would remain with them and work to convince settlers to give up without a fight. When he learned of their plans to attack his family's settlement in Kentucky, he could not sit idly by. He escaped in an effort to get word to the settlers of the tribe's plan. Boone's journey back home was the stuff of derring-do as he eluded the Indians who were tracking him. Pushing himself beyond human capacity, he ran for more than four days and a total of 160 miles. For young readers interested in history and those who are drawn to adventure, this true story is a compelling one. The illustrations, however, at times seem a poor fit for the text, depicting Boone in an almost comic fashion. Nevertheless, this well-documented vignette from the frontiersman's life will find a place in most collections.—
Joan Kindig, James Madison University, Harrisonburg, VA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Spradlin presents an episode from the life of pioneer Daniel Boone that’s long on excitement, but short on sourcing. On a snowy day in 1778 that “would change his life forever,” Boone is hunting when he is spotted by Shawnee warriors. The Shawnee, furious over deaths and broken treaties, take Boone captive; then they allow him to bring men from his fort to live with the Indians as a sign of good faith. The description of this episode is confusing: how did Boone get his men to agree? And when Boone later escapes, he apparently leaves his men behind. Moreover, the epilogue states that this escape is “reduced to one brief sentence in Boone’s autobiography.” Though the epilogue speaks authoritatively, there are no source notes, or even a bibliography—a disservice to children—which will leave adult readers wondering about authenticity. That’s too bad, because the pictures—created with watercolor, colored pencil, and ink, and with lots of crosshatching—practically jump off the two-page spreads. No doubt kids will be caught up in the adventure, but how much is truth, and how much fiction? Grades K-2. --Ilene Cooper