Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Exceptional debut, February 15, 2002
This review is from: The Dark Room: A Novel (Hardcover)
There are two sides to every story. the vast majority of Holocaust literature has dealt with the victim's story. With her debut, Seiffert provocatively describes the guilt, remorse, and confusion that must exist for the German side of the Holocaust. While many of us view all Germans of the World War II era as Nazis active in the genocide of unwanted groups in Europe, Seiffert shows us that this is not the case. She writes three vignette novellas on the experience of an innocent uninvolved German ; the innocent children of a Nazi officer ; and a young German man who discovers the Nazi connections of a beloved grandfather. But this book is more than historical fiction. It encourages introspection. How would I respond if I were suddenly confronted with the unsvory past of a loved one? Would I have the courage and strength to survive should life as I know it suddenly fall apart? What am I made of? The three vignettes do not link at all, casting doubt on the book's billing as a "novel," but that matters little. Seiffert creates such sympathetic characters that the reader is drawn into their plights and struglles along with them. Her prose is wonderful and the book becomes difficlut to put down. I expect future great novels from Seiffert. She is a terrific writer.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Dark Lives, October 29, 2001
This review is from: The Dark Room: A Novel (Hardcover)
There have been many narratives which deal with the world's reaction to the atrocities caused by the Nazis, but few have dealt so directly with how Germans feel about inheriting the knowledge of these crimes. Does sharing a national identity with people who have committed such crimes make you a criminal as well? This is the issue that Rachel Seiffert follows with such tenacity in her incredible first novel. The question is beautifully threaded throughout the three narratives of Germans at different points in the century. The final narrative of Micha's digs the deepest into the problem. The three central characters are connected to the Nazi warfare and are trying to understand if their relation to it is something integrally related to themselves. What emerges is a well-rounded picture of the difficulty of living with the fact of this history and trying to peacefully make it a part of your identity. Yet, this novel isn't a meditation only for Germans to deal with their own history. (After all, who doesn't belong to a nation that has committed governmentally enforced crimes against a group of people?) It makes an important statement about World War II but also one about the human condition and our relation to the past. The human relationships are tenderly drawn. All the characters are intensely selfish in their own way, but have encountered numerous difficulties in their lives which have moderated the way they relate to people. The book moves much more slowly at the end and becomes very meditative. At times this becomes more tedious than insightful. However, the final picture is a complicated portrait of national guilt wrapped with small examples of human kindness and forgiveness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very Well Done, May 30, 2001
This review is from: The Dark Room: A Novel (Hardcover)
Ms. Seiffert's book, "The Dark Room", is notable as not only an auspicious debut for this young writer, but additionally for her remarkable talent in relating a feel for human events that took place decades before she was born. None of these three stories is based on Historical Fact, what she wrote she created. That the stories probably did occur in some manner, takes nothing away from the writing she offers readers. The book contains three stories or novellas that are not dependent upon one another, and while not all carried the same impact, the three are consistently well written. The Author writes in an understated manner, this is not a series of stories that shock by atrocity alone. The book is replete with human suffering both inflicted and endured, but it is delivered with a subtle pen. Ms. Seiffert also has taken a less familiar perspective in this book. The book does have a camp survivor as a pivotal player in the final story, however generally we see the other victims of the crimes of this war. The events that forever damage these people are explored both as they happened and as they are uncovered generations later. The final story is, "Micha", and I found it to be the strongest. Those who were affected by being present during the war and its aftermath generally struggle with grief or rage that is more familiar; they are the immediate victims of the conflict. The final story painfully demonstrates that certain conduct has ramifications that never subside, as they literally inhabit the generations that follow. Time does not in fact heal many things. I look forward to more of what this woman will offer as she has a manner of writing that that slowly invades the mind's eye, and in this case encompasses it with its horror and crimes. It is a powerful method of delivering themes that are all fundamentally appalling, without any added emphasis. She presents her stories without flourish and without preaching. A very talented young Author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|