Customer Reviews

Darwin for Beginners

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

An illustrated narrative tells, all too briefly, the story of Darwin the man and his revolutionary discovery of how the living world came to be. Thanks to its amusing, but informative, cartoon style exegesis, this little gem is a uniquely powerful antidote to creationist propaganda in the classroom. The best introduction to Darwin and his ideas you're likely to see.

This lively, clever, humorous little book IS accurate -- "scientifically correct," in the words of Dr. Tim M. Berra of Ohio State University (author of "Evolution and the Myth of Creationism," 1990, Stanford University Press). I agree with him that it would be a great gift for students to give to their parents to help them understand evolution. The illustrations, many of which are worth a thousand words, are at once engaging, informative, and great fun. Solid history and science in superlative format.

This is a great lightweight book on Darwin's life and the development of the idea of evolution. Though it would be a shame to stop an exploration of natural selection here, it's a great starting point because it provides the context in which Darwin's thoughts came to be. It also discusses objections and criticisms of natural selection, how it has been misunderstood and abused, and how Darwin himself treated problematic aspects of the theory. I don't know that the illustrations and such are very revealing or useful, but they definitely make the book easy and fun to read, though the last few pages become more text-based. Overall, it's a well executed introduction to a very influential and oft misinterpreted person. But though this book is for beginners, please don't stay one... go and read "Origin of Species."

No-nonsense discussion on the Theory of Evolution, including a look at the people, places, and events that shaped its derivation. It provides a concise summary of Charles Darwin, the man and the scientist, including the dispelling of myths concerning his alleged anti-religious bent. The book is an easy read, yet is packed with factoids and information that provides an essential basis for evolutionary thought. While the book cover gives an appearance of child literature, young and old will find it enlightening and helpful.

This book is not exactly as the title claims 'Darwin for Beginners'. A more appropriate title would be 'Darwin for Beginners who are frustrated with reading other complicated books, but managed to get crude understanding of evolution from it.' Whew! I know, long title. But that is the truth.

This well illustrated book does not approached the theory of evolution directly, but instead presents the idea from the point of view of people (biologists) proposing and discussing plausible explanations for the variation in life - explanations which sometimes reinforced and sometimes conflicted with one another. To put it another way, it explains how the idea of evolution had evolved and was accepted among the scientific community.

In a very simple and easy to understand manner it gives us a window into the thinking of scientists of that time.

My printing of this book is circa 1980. I do not know if the newer version has made any significant changes to the content. The biggest question is who is this book's intended audience? The format of the book (comic book style) would seem to indicate that the book is intended for children and teenagers. Unfortunately the large amount of scientific jargon makes it unsuitable for children, and the lack of a basic narrative limits the benefit that teenagers could get from it.

This is not a biography of Charles Darwin although it tries to be. Nor is it an explanation of natural selection, although it tries to do that as well. This book tries to cover the scientific environment and basic evolutionary ideas prior to Darwin. It covers some events and people in Darwin's life. It gives a less-than-ideal presentation of Darwin's theory, and it gives a jumbled mess of evolutionary thought after Darwin including Mendel and various ways that Darwin was "wrong". This book tries to be all things and does none of them successfully. It is a mildy entertaining, mildly educational book to read while you are sitting on the toilet. It is not good for much else.

Great service and the item was in the condition they stated when purchasing online. Great seller.

It is a great shame the authors ruined such a good idea by doing no historical research. It is quite clear that the authors are ignorant of the wealth of research produced by the Darwin industry and of course the Correspondence of Charles Darwin. I could spend a long time doing a hatchet job on the book but I prefer to spend my time going to Snowdonia and walk over the mountains Darwin did his geology and read his geological notes where he wrote them. In all a silly book on a great scientist.. We desperately need a good simple book on Darwin, which avoids all the hype and inaccuracy