Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
not kiernan's best by a long shot..., June 30, 2007
I am a huge fan of Caitlin Kiernan's work, but this may be her weakest novel; she says in her introduction that she's never struggled with a book the way she did with this one, and unfortunately it shows. The story tells of the intersecting paths of Soldier, a woman who has forgotten her past and is slaughtering her way around New England on errands for the ghouls, and Emmie, a stubborn 8-year-old who is only now (for no clear reason) being hunted by forces who need her power. There is a *lot* of talking in this book, and much of it is repetitive and off the point. Emmie in particular spends most of the book insisting, constantly, repeatedly, that everything happening to her is all a dream and just stupid; this gets a bit exhausting by page 300, and makes her dialogue remarkably repetitive. Soldier's amnesia means that her character is not grounded in the way that Kiernan's characters usually are, by their past or other ties. The truly creepy sequences that Kiernan produced in Threshold and Low Red Moon are missing here, traded for less-than-subtle action or drawn-out dialogue, and instead of the vulnerability of a Chance Matthews or Deacon Silver we are left with Soldier and Emmie, both of whom are resistant to the reader-- Soldier because of her ur-competence, and Emmie because she simply doesn't want to be in the book. The reasons for Soldier's and Emmie's experiences, and the timing of them, are never resolved, nor does the end make much sense. Altho' readers of the first two books in this series will probably read this just to find out what happens next, anyone looking for an introduction to Kiernan will find much better work by her in her other novels.
|
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Stunningly Beautiful, January 14, 2007
Daughter of Hounds is a finely crafted novel that contains stories within stories, and it's beautifully and skillfully written. Objects and places that would normally be considered mundane become the pillars of an intricate mythology that can instill feelings of both wonder and revulsion. It's the kind of writing that works all of the emotions at once and plants itself deep within the reader so that Kiernan's mythology quickly becomes your own.
I'm reluctant to categorize the novel, because Caitlin R. Kiernan is an author that defies the constraints of genre. The best that I can do is to call this a mesmerizing fairytale that is both dark and light, ugly and beautiful, classical and modern, and all the things in between and beyond. If you're looking for intelligent fantasy, please do yourself a favor and purchase this book.
|
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
CRK continues her unparalleled reign as my favorite author EVER., January 9, 2007
I first fell in love with Caitlin, her words and her worlds, with Silk (my paperback copy of which is now sadly tattered and much-loved; I first heard of it via Poppy Z. Brite's The Crow: Lazarus Heart). Daughter of Hounds continues her legacy, and hasn't disappointed me yet--nor do I expect it to.
Daughter of Hounds has changelings, hounds, demons, beings that may or may not be ghosts, and magick. Time goes in its circular motion--not backwards and forwards as most believe; different options--different realities--occur at the same instant. As with Threshold, Daughter of Hounds doesn't stay in one time or in one reality. It endeavors, at the least, to expand your understanding of time and reality, and the wormholes therein. CRK's worlds, as in reality, don't always make sense or have answers.
If, at the last page, you're expecting everything to be resolved, neatly labeled and boxed, then you're mistaken and obviously haven't read CRK's works. One thing I love about her is that her stories don't necessarily have endings--or if they do, they're very open-ended and not necessarily good ones.
She makes you think, instead of solving the puzzle for you all at once. And she does it so beautifully. Every book of hers that I read changes me indefinitely, opening my mind up to other worlds.
"Words are magick", indeed, Caitlin. You, above all others, have taught me that. I am forever in your debt.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|