From School Library Journal
Grade 4-7 The underlying themes of this book are memory and the Holocaust. However, unlike many recent books where the emphasis is on keeping the memory alive, this one has as its key the fading memory of an old man. When David's grandfather, Max, thinks that he has seen an old friend who was thought to have been killed during the war, everyone except David thinks that the old man's mind is playing tricks on him. David is convinced that Max is right, and he begins a quest to find Max' friend. He also, for the first time in his life, begins to learn about the Holocaust, and about his grandfather's experiences. When Max has a heart attack, David is more determined than ever to find Bernie Bauer, Max' old friend, but the man he finds denies knowing anything about Max. Only after Max' funeral does Bernie finally admit his identity to David. This novel operates on many levels; the Holocaust is an obvious theme, but the book also shows the close relationship between a young boy and his grandparents. The characters are, on the whole, believable, but Bernie is irritating. Although he tries to explain why he waffled about his identity, it just doesn't ring true. That's a shame, because it does a disservice to an otherwise good book. Susan M. Harding, Mesquite Public Library, Tex.
Copyright 1989 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"A good book for all children . . . to gain more understanding of the Holocaust and how it affected their grandparents'' generation,"—Philadelphia Inquirer
(
Philadelphia Inquirer )
"Intriguing . . . humorous and lively."—ALA Booklist
(
ALA Booklist )
"This beautiful book, originally published in 1988, has been newly updated and revised. None of the compelling style of the original edition has been lost . . . . This book is replete with wonderful values of friendship and family and honesty."—Jewish Book World
(
Jewish Book World )
"David and Max sets a new standard for young fiction. A charming and funny story of a grandfather and grandson woven deftly around a deeper and darker tale . . . sensitive, honest, and all the more powerful for its brave simplicity. This book is a treasure for any middle grade. . . English, social studies or civics classes. Its treatment of poignant and topical issues such as homelessness, divorce, and especially the Holocaust is unparalleled in its age group."—Mary R. Motew, Adjunct Professor, Worcester State College, Worcester, MA;
(Mary R. Motew )
--This text refers to an alternate
Paperback
edition.