Customer Reviews

The Day the Earth Caved In: An American Mining Tragedy

5 star:		(16)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

Having been born and raised in Mount Carmel, which is about 4 miles west of Centralia, I can claim some familiarity with this tragic series of events. As I am now the solicitor for the Borough of Centralia (or what's left of it), I know many of the people written about in the book. There are only about 15 or so folks remaining in the town, but these are people that absolutely refuse to leave. It's almost impossible to have all of the borough council offices filled, so next month we are going to court in Columbia County to receive permission to reduce the number of required council members. In the hard coal region, there are numerous people who were born, married from, lived in, and were buried from, the same house. Centralia, like most small hard coal towens, was an extremely close-knit community where everyone seemed to know everyone else, and everyone else's busines. As an example, in Mount Carmel when I was in high school in the early '60s, there were about 6 or 7000 people, but a letter addressed to my parents, with just their names and no address, would be correctly delivered to our house.That close-knit feeling in Centralia was shattered when Frank Jurgill (a high school classmate of mine), came running from the town dump in 1962 to announce that it was on fire. I take no stand on how the fire started. I know that Dave DeKok, whom I knew when he was a reporter here, and whose book I also own, disputes how the fire began. That really isn't the point of the book, rather it is what happened after the fire was discovered that is the heart of the book. These were folks who refused to leave their family homes until there was so much danger that they just had to go. There is a lot of anger on the part of the remaining citizens, who still suspect some type of conspirary to uproot them so that one of the former local politicians, who is involved in strip mining, has the opportunity to get control of the mineral rights to the ground, which now belong to the borough. It is that stubbornness to yield to what they perceive as an injustice that will keep those diehards in their town until the last one dies. I admire them for their courage in the face of adversity, and intend to continue to represent them legally as long as they will have me. They are true heroes, and when you read the book, you will easily pick out the villains in the woodwork.

I first found out about the underground coal mine fire at Centralia PA and the devastation of the town above it while surfing the Web, looking for information about urban ruins. The photos I saw on various websites were eerie: where a small town once stood there was now only streets and sidewalks. A sliver of a dwelling that had once been part of a string of row houses stood alone, propped up on either side by brick chimney-like buttresses that provided the support that other dwellings, now torn down, once gave. Steam rose from cracks in a twisted and abandoned highway or from patches of scorched earth surrounded by dead vegetation. While these photos were very creepy and intriguing, I didn't stop to read much about the story of Centralia; I was on a quest to find out more about abandoned sites closer to my home in New York State's Hudson Valley region that I have seen for myself and visited: the Lente house, Bannerman's Island Arsenal, and the Cornish Estate.

Years later but a few weeks ago I happened across the last five minutes of a segment on C-SPAN's Book TV that caught my attention. Joan Quigley, author of "The Day the Earth Caved In" was talking about the Centralia mine fire. From the little bit I saw of the show it was clear that there was much more to the Centralia story than what I gathered from the photos on the Web. I eagerly wrote down the name of the book and its author so that the next time I visited Amazon I could order it. After adding the book to my shopping cart, Amazon suggested that I also might want to check out David DeKok's "Unseen Danger", an earlier volume on the same subject. I ordered both.

As chance would have it, "Unseen Danger" arrived about a week before "The Day the Earth Caved In" and now, having read both books, I'm glad it did. I have a busy life and don't have a lot of time to read but I found Mr. DeKok's telling of the story so compelling that I neglected a lot of my duties around the house to make time for it. I took it to work and read it on my lunch and dinner breaks. I stayed up into the early morning hours, far longer than I should have, to finish it in a couple of days instead of the weeks it usually takes me to read a book.

As the blurb quoted on the cover from the New York Times Book Review states, there are "enough bureaucratic villains [in this story] to fill a Dickens novel." I would add that there were some Centralian citizens (especially one infuriatingly obnoxious homeowner in particular who I kept hoping would disappear into a subsidence) and the local Catholic church (who should have also suffered the same fate) who deserved to be included in that category as well. This is a story of missed opportunities, inter-governmental squabbles, denial of the present realities and local feuds all working together to turn the lives of the residents of this beleaguered town into a living hell. Mr. DeKok does a fine job of telling the story and it is obvious that he put a tremendous amount of effort into researching it and a lot of detective work into trying to separate fact from fiction, especially when it comes to the matter of how the mine fire got started in the first place. He paints a clear and terrifying picture of what the residents who were most effected by the danger had to go through before they got some relief, and the unconscionable indifference that government officials showed to the plight of their constituents in order to protect their own political behinds. The cast of characters in "Unseen Danger" is large and varied and includes the above mentioned villains and a few heroes too. The attention to detail is astounding and makes for extremely compelling reading.

However, in my opinion, the book is not without its flaws. While the above mentioned attention to detail is most welcome, at times it can be confusing, especially when trying to picture the relative locations of the events. Three small maps are included in the paperback edition that I read; one showing where Centralia is located in relation to large East Coast cities, a local map indicating local landmarks and some street names along with the locations of the fire's origin and the site of one especially scary event, and a third map that indicates where the fire hot spots were located in 1983. These graphics are only helpful in a minimal way and don't go far enough toward clarification.

Photographs appear at the start of each chapter and there are a few in the bodies of the chapters. In terms of graphic clarity (not subject matter) all leave much to be desired and in many cases they are of such poor quality as to be useless. They have the appearance of being photocopies of photocopies of photocopies and are of such high contrast that the very features that they were intended to illustrate have become invisible. I do not blame Mr. DeKok for this - his publisher should have done a better job. As for the type of photos included, there are many of Centralians effected by the fire, some of the government workers who had to deal with the situation on almost a daily basis, one of the fire itself, and many of the government figures involved. However there is one glaring omission: aside from the cover photo which is obscured by the bold lettering of the book's title there are no pictures of the town, either as it was at the beginning of the story, during, or after. For those, one must go to the various websites dedicated to the subject.

Ms. Quigley's book generally does not suffer from these kind of setbacks. Even before her Prologue we are provided with a nearly full page map which clearly indicates street names, locations of local landmarks, locations of the principal character's homes, indications of the sites and scope of efforts to stop the fires, and a distance scale to help us better grasp the relative proximities of the places and events described. I wish I had this map while I was reading "Unseen Danger", it would have increased my appreciation of that book all the more. "The Day the Earth Caved In" contains eight pages of black and white photographs, all well reproduced, including one of the authors' grandparents row home from 1984, and one taken in 2000 of a tourist observing a cloud of vapor emanating from a non-descript area in the woods, as well as photos of mine workings from the 1880's and pictures of some of the people central to her telling of the story. As with "Unseen Danger" wide angle photos of the town before and after are absent and their inclusion would have helped drive home the immense scope of this catastrophe. Again, one has to search the Internet to find those kind of pictures.

While David DeKok relates the Centralia story by presenting an almost day by day account of the events that occurred he does not get inside the heads of the principals too deeply. He doesn't have to - anyone who has an atom of imagination can empathize or sympathize with the horrors that these people must have been through. But what left me scratching my head in bewilderment after I finished his book was why the Centralians were so reluctant to leave their homes and flee the danger. I suppose this is because I was born and raised in New York City and have moved to new homes five times since I left my parents house - once because the dangers of living in a loft on NY's Lower East Side became too much to bear. It wasn't until a few days ago while discussing the matter with a co-worker who grew up in a small town in upstate New York (population about 2000) that I really began to understand what made Centralians want to cling to their homesteads so tenaciously. Joan Quigley, by telling her version of the story through the eyes, histories and emotions of a few of the key players attempts to explain that sense of attachment, but is only partially successful. Ironically enough, it is DeKok's sparse explanation that comes closest to what my co-worker told me and what I've observed since moving from NYC to a small town: that many people living in small towns are fearful of the outside world and are much more likely to cling to surroundings that are much more familiar and therefore comforting.

Quigley's device of presenting the story by delving into the personal histories and feelings of her selected subjects is a welcome supplement to the mine fire disaster story as told by DeKok but ultimately it falls short in conveying just how desperately dangerous their situation was. At times I got the impression that she feels that the personal relationships between husbands and wives, parents and children or neighbors and neighbors is the interesting part of the story and the mine fire and its dangers were just a backdrop to that soap opera. Major events, like one man's close encounter with death by carbon monoxide poisoning while asleep in his bedroom and the circumstances leading up to it are described in great detail in "Unseen Danger" while Ms. Quigley mentions it almost in passing, preferring to more often dwell on what clothes a person was wearing. (What bearing does who wore what color pants suit on a particular day have on the story at hand? Inexplicably, these kind of observations appear far too frequently.) This is generally indicative of both authors approach to their subjects.

Similarly, Mr. DeKok tends to speak with authority and presumably understanding on technical matters while Ms. Quigley shows some lack of comprehension. For example, at one point she states that oxygen was the fuel that kept the mine fires burning. Just for the record: coal is the fuel that is consumed by the fire while oxygen needs to be present for oxidation - burning - to occur; oxygen in and of itself does not burn. This is elementary Junior High school science. While I realize that the point Ms. Quigley was trying to make was that some scientists proposed that if the mine fire were to be deprived of oxygen then it might go out, it is this misunderstanding of basic physics that influences me to trust Mr. DeKok's opinions over hers.

One rare instance where Ms. Quigley's narrative excels over Mr. DeKok's is in her scathing indictment of the Reagan administration and of the local Catholic church, an institution highly revered and trusted in Centralia, who let their parishioners down as shamefully and grievously as the government had. Mr. DeKok also criticizes these institutions, but instead mostly relies on the method he employs when dealing with other facets of the story, that of letting the facts speak for themselves. Ms. Quigley does this as well, however, she goes one step further on this one point by including examples of government official's blunders not cited in "Unseen Danger", in particular those of the lunatic James Watt (who was Secretary of the Interior near the end of the story) whose public statements were so insane that President Reagan gladly accepted his resignation, and none too soon: after Watt left office he was indicted on charges of influence peddling. None of this information about Watt was in "Unseen Danger" and I strongly feel it should have been.

Both books tell pretty much the same story (though from different perspectives and not equally as well), but one disagreement between the two is about how the fire started in the first place. In my opinion Mr. DeKok presents a far more plausible explanation, citing specific evidence in chapter 3 of his book while Ms. Quigley covers the subject in an author's note at the end of hers. While she states that her research provides strong evidence for her version of the events, she reveals very few specifics of it and appears to rely heavily on the testimony of residents living near the ignition site, claiming that they had no reason to lie. I view this claim with a lot of skepticism. Her own depiction of the character of the Centralia residents (especially some who lived near the dump) leads me to conclude otherwise. Also, Ms. Quigley seems to overlook one gigantic 500 pound gorilla in the room: Why would the town dump be set on fire if it was already burning? It seems painfully obvious to me that they wouldn't. In any case, the cause of the fire is only one part of the story and either scenario would have led to the same result.

If one is interested in reading about this subject my advice is to get both of these books. Read "Unseen Fire" first (it is by far the better of the two because in part it tells the horrific story in much more frightening detail) but keep "The Day The Earth Caved In" handy so you can refer to its superior map. Then read Ms. Quigley's book as a supplement, to flesh out some of the characters involved and to learn a handful of interesting but not necessarily essential facts that were left out of Mr. DeKok's. Some may find her more personally intimate and emotional method of storytelling preferable to DeKok's somewhat dry, fact based delivery but I for one did not. For as much as I enjoyed "The Day The Earth Caved In" on a certain level I think I did so because I already knew the facts ahead of time. Much to her credit, Ms. Quigley invoked in me even more sympathy for the people she chose to focus on than I had before, (at least those who were deserving of it,) especially one young couple's story of being pulled apart because of wanting different things out of life, which paralleled my own personal experience. However, I feel that this concentration on the private lives of a select few takes too much attention away from exploring and understanding the broader picture of governmental incompetence that any one of us could fall victim to under similar unfortunate circumstances.

Hope that nothing like this ever happens in your town.

I would not have thought that the story of a coal mine fire could be so fascinating, but Joan Quigley could probably bring excitement to any subject she chose to explore. Her portrayal of the characters and events involved is vivid and compelling, as is her scrupulous research. Highly recommended.

In 1981 Carrie Wolfgang sees a cluster of federal officials across the street. Centralians were always suspicious of government strangers ever since the coal mine fire plagued their town 19 years ago. She calls her daughter, Flo Dombrowski, who dispatches her 12-year-old son Todd to investigate. Todd finds his cousin Erik fixing a flat tire on his motorcycle in Carrie's backyard. Todd, lingering with Erik, sees a wisp of smoke coming from the ground. Ever curious, he moves in closer. The ground caves in and swallows up Todd. So begins Joan E. Quigley's account of the disastrous Centralia, PA coal mine fire.

This is not just the story of a coal mine fire, but the tale of the tenacious people who survived the frequent heartbreaking woes of a coal-mining community. The chronic oppression caused by the uncontrollable demon of fire, the insidious and relentless pollution, and the helplessness of the people facing the governmental bureaucracy begs the question of why they remained loyal to this town. Out of this morass, strong characters emerge who provide leadership in the struggle to save the town. Joan Quigley, an award-winning journalist, has interviewed the principals and examined the evidence to present this compelling book. She digs deep into the human spirit tested by this disaster.

First-time author Joan Quigley tells the compelling story of the nation's worst mine fire and what it left in its wake; the book is an enjoyable read and a remarkable story. Extensive and meticulous reporting (plus Quigley's personal connection to the town of Centralia, Penn.--her grandfather and great-grandfather were miners there) allowed the author to craft a gripping story that reads like a novel. Through the residents of Centralia--fiercely holding onto their burning town--we move through the horrific drama and learn about the government's gross mishandling of the situation. I was quickly drawn into the narrative and would recommend this book to anyone interested in a well-told, (unbelievably) true story.

Joan Quigley's book tells the heartbreaking and gripping true story of Centralia, a small town sitting on top of
an underground coal mine inferno that eventually consumed everything
the residents had cared about for generations. Her meticulous research
and elegant writing enrich the story with deeply human characters, and
she makes painfully clear that corporate greed and governmental apathy
fueled the fire that decimated the Pennsylvania town. Quigley, who is
the granddaughter of miners, brings a personal passion to writing
about the disaster that shows on every page. Her focus on the hard
history of the coal miners who settled the town makes clear that the
residents had to pick between desperate and dangerous choices from the
beginning, and similar options brought the town to an end.

If you are looking for facts on the Centralia fire this isn't the book to start with. This book focusses on three people out of the hundreds affected and then only during a period of time from 1979 until 1983 when the government finally agreed to do something for Centralians. Considering her comments in the afterword about the immense amount of research and information she went through, this book is a disappointment.

As others have noted, Quigley seems fixated on what people supposedly were wearing and a lot of similar minutiae that is distracting from the story. I also find it hard to believe anyone would remember after all these years exactly what they were wearing on any particular day, or whether there were leaves crunching underfoot, etc. It's a book that doesn't know if it wants to be a historical record or a "reality" novel.

Quigley also adds little (one fact really) to David DeKok's excellent history of the mine fire. And without footnotes or references it's hard to tell where Quigley got her facts from.

As to the cause she puts forward, it defies logic. While hot ashes could well have started the fire I have my doubts. I grew up with an coal heater in the basement and the ashes never would've stayed hot enough to ignite anything unless one took them from the heater directly to the dump. Even then I have my doubts. I'd bet heavier on the fire department setting the dump on fire as the former chief admits to her.

It's probably the first book I ever bought that I almost wish I hadn't since it was a waste of time and money. Though, as another reviewer pointed out, the pictures and map are better than the ones in DeKok's work. Still, not worth the price.

This is a great pic, though I would have like many more pictures - everyone should read it, as it shows the stupidity that occurs with big government, and even little government - this tragedy could have been stopped fairly easily early on, but as it wasn't dealt with properly, eventually it destroyed the entire town of Centralia, PA - I would still like to see this fire (now 4 fires) put out for good, and the town restored, either as a town, park, or something useful for the community of Centralia.
This book brings to mind many of our government programs to benefit all - and how they backfire, causing more problems than they solve -

I have been interested in the story of Centralia for a long time, and this by far was the best telling of the story from the people who actually lived there durring this time. Very quickly you loose yourself in this story and you heart goes out to the people who suffered this horrible tradgety.

This is a story that needed to be told. And there are many more out there, quite similar, it seems, that we also need to hear. I found the historical aspects particularly fascinating, and will look for more information in that regard. However, I wasn't as taken with the long sections about how the local residents fought for government action. The egregious failures of the state and local governments are an outrage. Seeing more recent disasters, such as Katrina, sadly makes one aware that, the more things change, the more they stay the same.