1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
IF EDWARD HOPPER HAD WRITTEN COMEDIES INSTEAD..., June 5, 2010
This review is from: Dead Man's Cell Phone (Paperback)
In one of Edward Hopper's most famous paintings (Automat, 1927), a woman sits alone, a cup of coffee on the table in front of her. She is alone, as most of the people in Hopper paintings are, even when others share the landscape with them. (See Nighthawks [1942] and Office at Night [1940].) Dead Man's Cell Phone, by the young playwright (she was born in 1974) Sara Ruhl, conveys much the same mood as Hopper's paintings, though presented in a very different medium and a radically different style. It's a play about disconnectedness -a comedy really, because, for all the seriousness of its theme, the play is really funny. (In some ways, Ruhl is close to Arthur Adamov, the now-forgotten offspring of the absurdist era in playwriting.)
The play's protagonist, meek, mousy Jean (described by another character as "a paleish woman, sort of nondescript") becomes alive handing on to people she doesn't know imaginary messages from a dead man she's never met (while he was alive, that is). The characters in Cell Phone all talk past each other, out of their own self-fantasies or from a need to connect. Each presents a different picture of Gordon, the dead man, who, it transpires, was truly awful. The effect is pointillistic. Visual images come and go behind the actors, or people swirling around them, umbrellas on high and cell phones up to their ears. Disparate meetings and the soliloquies of various players coalesce to build a mood of separateness and misunderstanding, which is played out through each character's incomprehension of the other characters' motivations and inner fiber. What is surprising, though, is the humor. In even the most savage passages (the "dead man's" monologue in Act II, for instance), how funny the lines are! A love scene in the making is disrupted by a cell phone ringing and Jean's inability not to answer it. Her wooer Dwight admonishes her: "Life is for the living," he says, but the phone rings again and Jean, of course, answers it again. "When something rings, you have to answer it, don't you?" she queries in another scene. My favorite line? It's from the dead man Gordon. "Life is essentially a giant Brillo pad," he says; our goodness is scrubbed off even as we leave the house in the morning to start the day.
"I try to interpret how people subjectively experience life," Ruhl has said. "Everyone has a great, horrible opera inside him." It's also a terribly comic opera.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Expressionistic journey, November 15, 2009
This review is from: Dead Man's Cell Phone (Paperback)
This is a contemporary expressionistic/surrealistic view of a woman who investigates a dead man's family by tracing the information in his cell phone. There are some clever black comic moments, such as when the cell phone owner dies, dinner is experienced with his mother and his family and the romance which springs between the dead man's brother and the cell phone woman.
However, the plot becomes too far fetched when the profession of the dead man is depicted---he sells and ships dead body parts for transplants. Ruhl tries to paint a black comic society of users and those trapped within routines. However, her symbolism ans expressionism fall short since she does not use them judiciously. Everything becomes exaggerated here--including the romance between the brother and the cell phone discovery woman. The plot and atmosphere become too MUCH ALL OF ONE--TOO MUCH THE SAME; SO THAT CONTRASTS AND DELINEATIONS BECOME MUDDLED INTO A MASHED UP CHAOTIC UNIVERSE.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
not a bad gimmick, but a gimmick, May 13, 2009
This review is from: Dead Man's Cell Phone (Paperback)
Begins with promise, then slowly fizzles. Some literistic phoniness -- as when Dwight says to Jean "I dreamed you were the letter Z." Nobody's ever dreamed that. It's doubtful that anyone has ever announced they've dreamed that, either, other than here in Scene Two.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
