Customer Reviews

The Death of An Irish Tinker (Peter McGarr Mysteries)

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

If you like your mysteries raw you will appreciate this one. A carefully crafted whorl is begun with the first telling of the story and it soon sucks you into the pages. I figure it's a good book if I have nightmares about it after reading before I go off to sleep. This one did it.

This book did not have its usual satisfying trappings of character development among McGarr and his staff, nor was there any of the procedural/deduction angle that makes this series so enjoyable. It was heavier on the action (very good at it, too) and there was an interesting emphasis on the Irish Tinker (Gypsy) culture. A very entertaining read but you'll get more out of it if you read some of the other McGarrs before you read this.

Note to Gill, nee, McGarrity: Don't leave us hanging on the Ruthie/Hughie angle! You've got to issue another book in this series!

Investigating the 1984 murder of Mickalou Maugham, a Traveler well liked and admired for his gentleness of spirit and his playing of the uillean pipes, Chief Inspector Peter McGarr focuses on Desmond Bacon, known as the Toddler, who is the sadistic head of the drug trade in Ireland. Mickalou, missing for weeks, has been found dead at the top of a giant sequoia tree in County Wicklow, and Biddy Nevins, his wife, a former addict and sidewalk artist, has fled from Ireland, fearing both the Toddler and the possibility that one or more Garda members may be working with him. Twelve years later, Des Bacon catches up with her, and shootouts, home invasions, car chases, and a high body count result, as he tries to protect his turf and avoid prosecution.

As he does in the rest of this series, Gill develops stories on two levels--the immediate action and excitement of a specific mystery, focusing on some lesser known aspect of Irish life (in this case, the Traveler community), and the stories and relationships of his continuing cast of characters as they develop during the series. Ruthie Bresnahan and Hugh Ward, whose discovery of each other was a huge and often hilarious part of an earlier mystery (Death of a Joyce Scholar), have now had a years-long relationship, which is about to be tested during the action of this novel.

Gill's intensely realized descriptions--of the abuse of a Traveler by the Tod, of an addict in need of a fix, and of a teenager trying to fit in at a dance, for example--make his scenes come alive, while his understanding of the vagaries of police procedure gives a sense of reality to his less than perfect detectives. McGarr is a strong and caring main character whose sense of justice and honor are paramount (even if it means bending the rules), while his well developed cast of likable and amusing subordinates, who continue to grow in successive novels, provides the reader with long-term rewards throughout the series. Mary Whipple

I would recommend any of Gill's books. I first read him in 1980. He gives you a sense of the place and the history of Ireland as well as a good read about police procedures etc. Characters are always well drawn.

More a tale of action than a mystery, this book is still a great read because of Gill's understanding of the various Irish characters he creates: the blowhard Dublin good old boy cop, the lazy lout from Belfast, the hardworking upright Dub detective, and the real stars of this book- the Travellers, as they prefer to be called. Gill tells a good yarn and gives us some honest insights into this misunderstood, generally disliked part of Irish society. His ear for dialogue and translating the accents is spot on. A pint for ye, Bartholomew!

I will admit upfront that I couldnt finish reading this book. So my review is based on the little bit that I could manage to finish. This story started out interesting enough to hold my attention but I quickly got bored with the story and found it impossible to finish reading. The writer was overly descriptive and left nothing to the imagination. To me a writer needs to leave you guessing on at least one thing - a little something for you to imagine is a good thing. If you feel the same way then you probably shouldnt pick this book up. Im not saying the book isnt a good story because I didnt finish it but I was bored by the details and couldnt stand to read on.