Most Helpful Customer Reviews
61 of 66 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Good history, but with disappointing errors, April 30, 2004
This review is from: Death Metal Music: The Passion and Politics of a Subculture (Paperback)
Death Metal Music is valuable for its history of death metal, as it knowledgeably jumps from band to band and provides helpful descriptions that will likely lead readers to discover new bands. However, in Chapter 3 (pp. 39-49), which describes the lyrics of death metal, the author makes some surprising mistakes that soil her credibility and call into question how accurate her findings might be. The biggest problem occurs during her discussion of the social messages in death metal. She writes, "Anti-abortion messages may be found in songs like `Altering the Future'" (48). I have seen this mistake made before, but anyone who has heard this song by the band Death knows that the lyrics are not anti-abortion, but in fact pro-choice. The first verse describes the rotten life that follows for a baby born to a mother that is not capable of being a fit parent. The verse ends with this statement: "To exist in this world may be a mistake / The one who is with child, it's their choice to make." Clearly, Chuck Schuldiner is advocating a woman's right to choose. The second verse describes the necessity of capital punishment for murderers, but the chorus makes a clear distinction between abortion and murder. The chorus goes, "Abortion, when it is needed / Execution, for those who deserve it." The whole point of the song is that sometimes lives need to be ended to improve the future. To call it anti-abortion is to deny part of the legacy left behind by a death metal giant, and if any band should be well represented in this book, it is Death. Chuck described his views on abortion in a 1995 interview as follows: "It should be legal. If I was a woman surely I would like to have a choice to have a child or not. In [the] U.S. [a] lot of new-borns are killed because they were unwanted. It is better to solve it immediately when a woman finds out about the pregnancy and she doesn't want a child. Better to go for an abortion than to kill a baby. That is terrible. Men cannot force women to keep a child when they themselves feel they can't." See http://www.emptywords.org/SparkMagazine07-95.htm for the whole interview. Another statement suggests an ignorance of the metal bands that prefigured death metal. The author writes, "Mysticism and the occult accented the lyrics of major 1970s bands like Black Sabbath, Led Zeppelin, Witchfynde, Iron Maiden, and others" (40). Iron Maiden? Iron Maiden was formed in 1977, yes, but did not release its first album until 1980, and even then its lyrics were dedicated to reality and to retelling classic stories; mysticism and the occult did not become part of Maiden's repertoire until a few years later in songs like "The Number of the Beast" and "Revelations." To group Maiden with Sabbath and Zeppelin, both of whom recorded their most important material in the early 70s, suggests a shaky understanding of metal history. The author makes another glaring error concerning time, again on page 40. She brings up H. P. Lovecraft because his horror stories of chaotic gods and hoary magical secrets influence the lyrics of bands like Morbid Angel and Nile. Unfortunately, she refers to him as "a 19th century author" (40). Lovecraft was born in 1890, and though he wrote a couple stories as a child, the bulk of his writings came from the final ten years of his life (1927-1937), obviously making him a twentieth-century author. These may seem like small points, but they are all easily documented facts that the author was simply too lazy or too careless to get right, all in the course of ten pages. How many other mistakes did she make? Can her scientific studies later in the book be trusted? I enjoyed the history she provides of death metal, but I'm not going to keep a book on my shelf when the author cannot summon the respect to correctly write about Death or Lovecraft.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Note to Potential Readers, October 21, 2006
This review is from: Death Metal Music: The Passion and Politics of a Subculture (Paperback)
Hello, potential readers. I'm the author of this book, and I just wanted to write a little something to let you know what the book does and does not do, and what some of its strengths and weaknesses are.
While some critics have said the book reads like a grad school thesis or dissertation, this it was not. I actually wrote it while I was in college, but it was a labor of love that I produced on the side. Most of it was written when I was around 19-20 years old, though it took me a couple years to edit it and get it published.
I really do feel this is a unique look at the Death Metal subculture from an insider angle. I spent many years penetrating every part of the scene (shows, "metalfests", labels, zine-producers, touring bands, radio stations, etc.), and really became a member of it myself. I was surprised at how fully I was able to embrace and enjoy the music as well as all of the social aspects of the subculture. At the same time, I did plenty of research on what had already been published about metal heads, horror fans, and similar groups.
With that said, a lot of the research done for this book was very informal. Because nothing had really been published on death metal in particular (with the exception of some pretty unreliable sources), I relied to an unusual extent on "authorities" in the scene. I built a rough history of the scene through extensive interviews with death metal fans and musicians who lived through it. Quotes from these scene personalities and authorities are scattered throughout. These are not the most reliable sources, but they were definitely the best available. I feel confident that I ended up with a thorough and accurate sketch of the Death Metal scene.
(One of the readers who criticizes my book on this page points out what he feels are three small but worrisome errors. In one case, he interprets a lyric differently from me. In another case, he has found an editing error ["19th century author" should have read "19th century-style author"]. And in a third case, he justifiably worries that I grouped one band with a series of other bands from a different decade. In the larger paragraph, I was trying to illustrate the similarities in lyrical content among these bands, but I phrased this particular sentence in such a way that drew attention to the time period, and this was a mistake.)
For me the biggest failing in this book is the section where I report survey results. I do bring cursory attention to the fact that my sample of death metal fans wasn't selected in a scientific fashion that permits generalizing the results to all death metal fans. But at the same time, the way I write about this group throughout the section seems to ignore my own warning. In some ways, I wish I could go back and re-edit this, now that I know much more about conducting social-scientific research.
So what does my book offer? While it's a bit dense and too information-packed to be a quick easy read, it can serve as a good reference book for those with an interest in the history of the scene, especially the bands and albums that characterize different subgenres and eras of the scene. It also provides a nice broad sketch of scene dynamics and the ways in which this subculture has functioned and changed over time. But most fundamentally and most importantly, I do feel that the book really gives voice to the fans and musicians of death metal. It provides a strong a challenge to some stereotypes about metal heads and the music they love. Later chapters also discuss in detail the value and function of subcultures like the death metal scene, and the significance of the lyrical themes and pervasive dark imagery of metal. To me, these are the heart of the analysis.
So, in conclusion, I hope you'll find my book an interesting and worthwhile read. Because it was published by an academic press, the price tag is pretty steep. You might want to check it out at your local library to decide whether you're interested in owning it.
Thanks for taking the time to read this,
natalie
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not what I expected, but better because of it., December 29, 2004
This review is from: Death Metal Music: The Passion and Politics of a Subculture (Paperback)
I had initially expected this book to be your typical "history of ..." and, judging from the other reviews, I think many other people were expecting this as well. I'll warn you now: if you're looking for a book on the history of death metal, this is NOT the book to buy. However, if you want to delve into the world of death metal from a purely academic perspective, this is a pretty damn good place to start.
The book reads much like a thesis paper or a supplementary textbook, focusing on the socio-political aspects of the death metal subculture. The history provided is minimal at best (and contains a couple of errors, but nothing worth the abuse that suttercane202 laid on it), providing a very brief overview that is best targeted to those outside of the death metal scene. There are plenty of interviews, quotes, and references throughout the book, and the author uses them wisely, although I believe the book could have delved a little deeper into some elements. The only serious flaw I find in this book is that many statements are repeated throughout the book, taking space that would have been better occupied by additional, new material.
I have been an active member of the death metal scene since '86, and I don't really find anything new in this book, but it was still enjoyable to read.
Based on material alone, I could definitely see this book becoming a very useful addition to a socio-political course in a musical institution in the near future. And speaking as an avid death metal fan, I would like to see this book added to curriculum outside of music institutions so that outsiders can finally get an objective insight into the scene - maybe then they won't freak out so much when they see us walking down the street.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
