11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An exciting ride and new depth with old friends., December 9, 2006
Sarah D'Almeida has written a mystery for Dumas fans everywhere. But if you aren't a Dumas fan, take heart - the mystery itself is so absorbing that you will also enjoy it a lot.
Dumas is very hard to pastiche - not only does the author have to deal with what people remember of the books, but the author must also work with what people remember from the movies. Sarah D'Almeida succeeds admirably. Athos is complex, D'Artagnan is intelligent and ambitious, Aramis truly is a ladies' man intended for the church, and Porthos is not stupid, but more inclined towards deeds than words.
The interaction between the characters is very much from Dumas, but takes on a new dimension as they struggle to solve a mystery that could leave Richelieu ascendent over both the Queen and King of France. This mystery does have some romantic scenes in it, but there isn't anything that I would object to high-school students reading.
Some of the history in this book is clearly Dumas-influenced, but some genuine seventeenth-century history shines through. The daily life and empty purses of the historical musketeers is clearly evident, and D'Almeida has done an outstanding job of integrating historical fact with Dumas without letting the story suffer.
And the story! Although anyone who has read Dumas is familiar with some elements of the story, they've been reinterpreted in a breathtaking fashion. The mystery was not obvious, and galloped to its conclusion. I tested this with a family member who is not a Dumas fan. She, too, was gasping in the last few chapter. Musketeers, a mystery, and an exciting ride. Wow!
I'm eagerly awaiting the next books in this series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Tour of Seventeeth Century Paris, December 9, 2006
I was impressed with how authentic the seventeenth century mindset of the characters seemed. And four very different personalities, at that. From the brooding Athos, the womanizing Aramis, tongue tied Porthos, and the young but clever D'Artagnan we see four views of the world. And what a world! The descriptions of Paris and the people of Paris are delightful. The writer pulls the reader so far into the world that one feels that one could easily get lost if one made a wrong turn down a street.
This is not the real seventeenth century, but rather Dumas' Seventeenth, full of the coincidences, resemblances, class prejudice, chivalry, and casual bloodshed in the name of honor that decorated his literary world. A fun read, with a good mixture of characters and action.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fun, swashbuckling tale!, December 9, 2006
LOVED it! A fun, swashbuckling adventure for modern readers. Ms D'Almeida does a fantastic job in this (the first of a series of adventures) tale. The fights are pure classics! With the twist of INTELLIGENT musketeers (something Dumas failed to do!), musketeers out to solve a murder! Great story! I can see why it was selected to be offered as a Mystery Book Club edition. Many kudos to the authoress for an excellent book. I look forward to the sequels!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No