Most Helpful Customer Reviews
38 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Avoid! Don't be fooled by the cheap price, July 20, 2003
This review is from: Deep Ska (Audio CD)
I unfortunately own this one (not much longer) and have analyzed it carefully. There are several reasons for why you shouldn't buy this, even though the price is very low. 1. They are not all ska tracks. 5 of them are Rock Steady, 4 are Early Reggae, 3 are UK Reggae (by the Pyramids) and 5 sounds very modern, from the 80's or newer. This could have been acceptable if they were sequenced in an intelligent manner. They are not. 2. The mastering is poor. I have several of these songs on better compilations and by comparison these sounds harsh, like they have tried to increase the treble too much. 3. Many songs are not so great. Half of the songs are instrumentals, mostly by the Skatalities under other names (like Tommy McCoook, Roland Alphonso or Don Drummond). These songs are not the best of The Skatalites, more like the worst of. A few exceptions of course, classics like Silver Dollar, Eastern Standard Time are included. But if you like The Skatalites there are compilations with better songs and better sound quality. 'Foundation Ska' on Heartbeat and 'Guns of Navarone: The Best of' on Trojan comes highly recommended. 4. Proper seems to be a shady record label with a business concept that means they are trying to circumvent the copyright laws. They claim they have "licenced" these tracks from Enzo Hamilton, and he's often accused of being a notorious bootlegger of reggae music. 5. There would be room for all the songs on only 3CD's. A good place to start your ska collection would instead be this: Rough & Tough - The Story of Ska (2CD's, Trojan). Good songs, good sound, and it's rather inexpensive too!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An absolute steal, July 19, 2001
This review is from: Deep Ska (Audio CD)
If you want to hear an incredible amount of first-rate Jamaican ska at an incredibly reasonable price, this is the set for you. This collection is grounded in a lot of first-rate work by the Skatalites, including a lots of songs listed under Tommy McCook, Don Drummond, and other individual members of the band. There's also an excellent sampling of early Toots and the Maytals as well, including the classics "Monkey Man" and "54-46 Was My Number", and John Holt's original version of "The Tide Is High", which was later a big hit for Blondie, of course) is also here. In addition, there are literally dozens of outstanding songs from bands I'd simply never heard of, including Blue Rivers & the Maroons doing the ska classic "Guns of Navarone" and Nora Dean doing "Oh Mama." There's only one song by Desmond Dekker, one by Laurel Aitken, and none by Prince Buster, so this is by no means the last word in Jamaican Ska. However, there are CDs in print from each of these artists. A lot of the songs on this collection, you simply can't find anywhere else. As box sets go, the packaging is pretty ordinary--just jewel cases in a box with liner notes. As far as I can tell, this is the only sacrifice you make buying this set. There is an excellent essay filling the 20-plus page liner notes, but unfortunately, no details on the recording, though this could well be because this information simply doesn't exist. Still, it would have been nice to know who played on what recordings, since the lineups seem to vary so much. The sound quality is very good in most cases, though none of this music was recorded under pristine conditions, so don't expect audiophile recordings. A few songs seem to show the limitations of the source material. Though the price on this set is terrific, this would still be a first-rate collection at twice the price. Highly recommended to anyone interested in Jamaican ska, whether it's your first CD in the genre, or you have a substantial collection.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Despite some flaws, its still a five., February 9, 2008
This review is from: Deep Ska (Audio CD)
I picked this comp. up about a year ago for ten bucks at a Half-Priced Books (who doesn't love that place?) The 2 star reviewer here cites that a few of these songs are from the late 70s/ early 80s; he's right. But don't let that annoyance blind you to the fact that there's enough great tracks to have you listening for hours on end. Not only that, but it avoids bombarding you with overly popular names (Desmond Dekker's got one song, Toots has two or three(?), the Skatalites are unavoidable though, considering their being the backup band for just about everyone). While there's a bit of genre mixing too (rocksteady, ska, reggae, etc) most people don't know the difference and these artists all dabbled in a bit of all... so who cares?
I know that its a good collection worth paying twice the price I did. Its great to hear sounds from a time when there was still a lot of rollicking R&B piano and upright bass in ska. Duke Reid's tracks are my favourite, particularly "Duke's Cookies."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
