9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Modern View of The Cadillac Desert, November 20, 2005
This review is from: Deep Water: The Epic Struggle over Dams, Displaced People, and the Environment (Hardcover)
In the United States the building of large dams has basically ceased. The failure of the Teton Dam in Idaho and the publication of the seminal book 'The Cadillac Desert' pointed out that the construction of such dams had gone far enough. Of course the fact that most of the best sites had already been used may have had something to do with it.
This book brings the same study to what is going on in other parts of the world, specifically India, Southern Africa and Australia. Each of the three main sections takes on one of these regions from the viewpoint of the dams.
In the epilogue of the book the author finally gets to express his view of the future. A view of the time when the dams are full of sediment, collapsing because of the aging concrete -- as he calls it, the ultimate litter. As he says, the future will look back on the dam building era, the automobile era, our time as an anomoly in the history of the world.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating and Disturbing, April 8, 2010
Jacques Leslie writes detailed reports on the development of major dam systems in India, Southern Africa, and Australia. He examines all aspects of the politics involved in planning and financing these dams through the World Bank. He also describes on how these projects focus only on the main "benefits" of the dams such as irrigation or hydro power to the detriment of everything else including mass resettlement of local (poor) peoples that sound too similar to the constanting shifting of native peoples in the United States to make room for "civilization" and "development." In the process Leslie goes in to significant detail on the history, ecology, anthropology, and economics of these regions. This book should have received five stars, but for glaring omissions of the publisher. There is no index and no list of sources. Leslie is a journalist and this book reads like a series in a magazine. His content is wonderful and should not be missed. However, the editors should have included more detailed maps of the areas being discussed and diagrams or photographs of the dams would also have greatly added to the work (not even the cover photo has anything to do with the dams under discussion). In addition, Leslie had worked with photographers on some of these investigations and photographs of the dams and the areas in question would have been very helpful. Google Earth is a good backup to fill this void, but it seems like the publisher wanted to save money in publishing this book. As a result, Leslie's work is first rate, but the book as a whole has limited usefullness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good implicit indictment of dams, but could have gone farther, and weak on solutions, September 3, 2007
This book examines the consequences of large dams around the world. Leslie has constructed his book much like John McPhee's classic _Encounters with the Archdruid_. Whereas _Encounters_ had environmentalist David Brower confront three environmental "villains," Leslie simply hangs out with three would-be heroes: an anti-dam activist, a consultant who works on the human consequences of dams, and a water-system manager who is trying to manage the system in an environmentally responsible way.
The first third of the book looks at activist Medha Patkar and her efforts to stop the dam on the Narmada River at Sardar Sarovar. This was the first project the World Bank ever left before it was finished, though it is still being built without Bank support.
The second third examines Thayer Scudder, an anthropologist who got started in the dam business by studying a people in Zambia whose homeland was destroyed by a dam. After this, he was often hired as a consultant on (underfunded) resettlement projects - - someone who could propose remediation in exchange for giving his support. He spent his career searching in vain for a good dam, always optimistic that a properly-managed dam would be good for people. Ironically, his greatest success came in stopping a bad dam at the Okavango Delta, not helping a good one.
The final third of the book looks at Don Blackmore, a water manager who is trying to make Australia's huge Murray-Darling project sustainable.
Like McPhee, Leslie tries to stay in the background and let his three characters speak. Leslie clearly admires the commitment of the anti-dam activists; in contrast, he all but calls Scudder a sell-out. However, it's interesting that he concludes with Blackmore, the most powerful and pragmatic of the three.
Though Leslie doesn't spin it this way, this book provides a "damming" indictment of engineers. They love playing with their toys, and if anything goes wrong they simply blame "politics" or "greed." But Leslie makes clear that, even when a dam helps some people, it comes at the cost of harming a lot of people whose lives are destroyed by the reservoir - - to say nothing of a damaged ecosystem. This means that dams cannot be anything but "political" because the winners will lobby for the dam and the losers will try to stop it. Leslie doesn't examine dam financing but it is equally, and inevitably political: taxpayers (or aid donors) pay for a project that helps some people but not others. Why, exactly, should everyone give money to help only a few?
The book could be used to make a good case for free market environmentalism: if dam builders had to compensate all the people harmed, both upstream and downstream, and pay for the dam out of their own pockets, no dams would be built. They are neither individually profitable nor socially beneficial. They exist only because they benefit wealthy people - - and engineers.
The only question that remains is what we should do with the dams we have. Leslie's Australian hero, Don Blackmore, is struggling with that question. So is Leslie, and that is a major limitation of the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
