7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I was surprised that the book had wrong tribal identification., December 20, 2005
This review is from: Deeper Than Gold: A Guide to Indian Life in the Sierra Foothills (Paperback)
I was surprised the book had wrong tribal identification for Les James.
Les James is not a Southern Sierra Miwok, but a Chuchansi and Casson Yokut. Yokuts are not Miwoks.
The same with some of the other people.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
I bought this book to see what reviews were about. Now I know., July 12, 2006
This review is from: Deeper Than Gold: A Guide to Indian Life in the Sierra Foothills (Paperback)
I bought this book after I read the reviews below to see for myself and started to investigate their reviews.
First I must say that Dugan Aguilars photos are some of the best photos of Native Californians around. There are some very beautiful photos by him.
Now the last part of the book I have to agree. I am related to some of those people and found it interesting that they are going for federal recognition, because I always thought they were already enrolled members of Paiute tribes. At least their children are.
The tribal ancestry is off in the back part of the book, but the photos are excellent. The last part...well that is a different story. How could they be original Miwok people of Yosemite when the original inhabitants of Yosemite were Paiutes? You can't be an original Yosemite Indian and be Miwok.
I know that is what the park is telling people, but they should read Lafayette H. Bunnell's book the Discovery of the Yosemites. That has the true story of the first conversations between Chief Tenaya and the good doctor.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Uhhh...Chief Bautista story Uncomplete., December 26, 2005
This review is from: Deeper Than Gold: A Guide to Indian Life in the Sierra Foothills (Paperback)
Uhhh...Regarding the story of Chief Bautista in Deeper than Gold.
Sure Chief Bautista was one of the chiefs to first fight Major James Savage and the whites, which was short-lived...BUT LATER...
Chief Bautista and Major James Savage became great friends. Bautista was Savage's right hand man. He helped Savage keep the Indians in line. Where was that in the book?
He gave Major Savage his women to seal their friendship.
Chief Bautista or Vow-chester made his people work for Savage in Savage's gold mines around Sonora and Mariposa. Where was that in the book?
Chief Bautista was also Major James Savage's cook.
Chief Bautista also had his men capture run-away Indians and bring them back. The whites heaped praise on Chief Bautista for his assistance.
Chief Bautista used his influence to keep the Indians in line, but he could not keep the Chowchilla Yokuts and Chief Tenaya's band in line for the whites.
March 1851, after Savage's trading post was attacked and burned in Dec. 1850, the whites asked Chief Bautista to make the other surrounding chiefs sign a peace treaty. Some of the whites distrusted Bautista because they distrusted ALL Indians and remembered years ago he had fought them.
To show them he could be trusted Bautista brought all the neighboring chiefs in to sign. All but two who he had NO control of the Chowchilla Yokuts and the Ahwahneechees refused to listen.
That is when the name of the "Yosemites" was first documented.
Chief Bautista, along with Russio, named the Ahwahneechees the "Yosemites" because they were afraid of them. Yosemite in their language meant "The Killers or "The Grizzlies". Bautista and the other neighboring chiefs were afraid of them and would never enter Yosemite Valley.
In the Stockton Republic, in the same week of March 1851, Chief Bautista was quoted in another version of the Ahwahneechees calling them the "Monahs" which meant they were Monos. He mentioned the Chowchilla Yokuts and the Ahwahneechees (Monahs)in the Stockton Republic and in Bunnell's Book.
After Chief Bautista had brought all the neighboring chiefs to sign the Fremont "Peace" treaty those doubting whites changed their mind about Chief Bautista's alliance.
Also in the Stockton newspapers there is something that was never mentioned before in Lafayette Bunnell's book "The Discovery of the Yosemite, 1851". You see not only was it Major James Savage and the Mariposa Battalion who went after Chief Tenaya and the Yosemite Indians, but mentioned in the Stockton newspaper were also "100 of Savage's Indians".
Without the help of those Indians the whites stated that they would have never captured Chief Tenaya and his people. They helped find them.
For his service in assistance in capturing Chief Tenaya and the Yosemites, Chief Bautista received "a scarf, a shirt and a pair of pantaloons".
Where is that in Deeper than Gold?
I heard Brian Bibby is now a Honary Miwok.
Maybe that is why he forgot that part of the story?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No