I've tried Holy Water and Paperback.
First, the bad: while paperback was a perfectly lovely scent, it had nothing to do with paperbacks. Smelled, actually, pretty exactly like cookie dough or cake batter. Raw flour, vanila, sugar, eggs- the works. It's lovely but absolutely nothing like the cedar-dust-sweet ink smell of a book. I did give it a bit of time, and rhe sweetness faded a bit, but still not enough to call it bookish.
Second, the really, really good: Holy Water is gorgeous. It took a bit to settle on, but when it did it smelled glorious on my skin and hair. Smelled like the best part of church as a kid, like beswax and incence. I think they did this one because they liked the smell but the Holy Smoke one had too much of a smoke overtone, so this might be HS without the smoke... Whatever, it's really, really nice.