Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Democracy Despite Itself: Why a System That Shouldn't Work at All Works So Well Hardcover – January 27, 2012
See the Best Books of the Month
Want to know our Editors' picks for the best books of the month? Browse Best Books of the Month, featuring our favorite new books in more than a dozen categories.
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Viewed This Item Also Viewed
Democracy, like many other organizations and systems, is filled to the brim with flawed and irrational people. Democracy Despite Itself explains, with clever arguments, how we are able to transcend these limitations and harness them to our benefit through a perfectly imperfect democratic system.(Dan Ariely, James B. Duke Professor of Psychology and Behavioral Economics, Duke University; author of The Honest Truth About Dishonesty)
A provocative meditation on a profound question: why does democracy workat allwhen voters are so often irrational? In lucid prose filled with compelling examples, Oppenheimer and Edwards grapple with one of the deepest questions society faces: how to organize itself, in light of the inherent frailty of the human mind."(Gary Marcus, Professor of Psychology, New York University; Author of Kluge: The Haphazard Construction of The Human Mind)
A provocative meditation on a profound question: why does democracy work at all when voters are so often irrational? In lucid prose filled with compelling examples Oppenheimer and Edwards grapple with one of the deepest questions society faces: how to organize itself in light of the inherent frailty of the human mind.(Gary Marcus, Professor of Psychology, New York University; Author of Kluge: The Haphazard Construction of The Human Mind)
About the Author
Mike Edwards founded and regularly contributes to Leftfielder.org, a blog on politics and media.
More About the AuthorsDiscover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.
Top Customer Reviews
1. The authors (O&E) define a country to be "democratic" if it holds "free, fair and meaningful elections." Right off the bat, this neglects many other aspects of democracy, such as protection of minority rights and even human rights generally. But even within this classification, what are "free," "fair," and "meaningful"? The authors' acknowledge that this definition is "purposefully vague" (@5), but that's an understatement.
The state of democracy in Japan, where I live, helps to gauge how vague O&E's standards are. For example, they highlight Japan as an example of "meaningful" elections (@id.), because "winners of parliamentary elections become legislators, capable of creating the laws of the land." Technically this is true, but actually very, very few laws in Japan are written by elected legislators -- the vast majority are written by unelected career bureaucrats. Moreover, 5 out of the most recent 7 prime ministers in Japan were NOT selected in general elections -- in fact, in only 8-1/2 out of the past 25 years, i.e., during only 1/3 of all that time, has Japan been governed by PMs with electoral mandates. Maybe even more shocking to an American's sensibilities, Japan's Supreme Court has held several elections unconstitutional for violating the principle of 1-person, 1-vote -- but in each case has refused to set the election aside or to call for a do-over. This kind of puts a different spin on "meaningful" and "fair," but none of this is mentioned by O&E.Read more ›
In the alternately hilarious and depressing first half of the book, the authors explore the truth behind the first quote -- that voters are dismally ignorant about many issues and make terribly flawed decisions when choosing candidates. The authors combine great experimental data on decision making biases with real world examples of how those biases play out in real elections -- how election results are demonstrably influenced by the order of candidate names on the ballot, how they can be predicted by 100 millisecond assessments of how "competent" a candidate looks, how voting in a school or firehouse can prime voters to the issues of education or public safety, and dozens more interesting facts.
The second half of the book grapples with why, despite all this, democracies work better than any other form of government. It explores how the wisdom of crowds, a sense of fairness in the system, and opportunities for peaceful transitions of power lead to reasonable outcomes and incentives for both leaders and the electorate to fully participate and abide by the rules of the society. In one of the book's most moving sections, the authors describe how we should not take for granted an event like the peaceful transition of power from George W. Bush to Barack Obama in 2009, and how the guarantee of such events is one key to the success of democracy.
Overall, this is a great and thought-provoking read, useful for both amassing fun factoids about irrational behavior and for thinking seriously about why our form of government works, and what could still be improved.
This book, Democracy Despite Itself, is wonderful. It explains and addresses many of my questions. It does not necessarily resolve them in all cases but it has raised my understanding of the subject and introduced me to the research that has been conducted on democracy -- on different questions.
Things that are wonderful about this book are that it is: well written and well organized; concise and succinct, on the issue; and, in the end, gives the reader more faith in democracy.
I shall keep it book on my favorite books shelf for a long time. It has inspired me to do some research and look into some evidence. For me, the book was a joy to read!
You don't have to know a lot--or even anything at all--about psychology or politics to enjoy this book. Everything is presented in a clear and engaging manner. But there's no need to worry about being bored if you're an expert, either. The authors combine the disciplines in an exciting way that will make you think about both human decision making and politics in ways you haven't before. And whether you go into the book knowing a little or a lot, you'll come out having learned a lot, including a deeper understanding of our flawed nature, plenty of fun and fascinating historical and psychological tidbits (enough for at least several years' worth of cocktail parties), and--most importantly--a new appreciation for all that democracy does for us as citizens and allows us to do together as a society.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
Easy to read with interesting and humorous examples that simply and clearly
illustrate the key points. Read more
A very interesting take on how democracy offsets the ignorance and bias of many in the country, by randomizing effects. Read morePublished on November 22, 2013 by Kryptoc
So this book i had to get for school, so naturally I wont like it, but I got through the first part without too much pain so i hope the second part is not any worse. Read morePublished on July 21, 2012 by Laura
This book was a blast to read. Oppenheimer and Edwards concisely present fascinating research that details how democracies can be so flawed and yet function so well. Read morePublished on May 15, 2012 by Connor
From what I read about the book, I think it capitalizes on simple minded concepts; e.g., whether Democracy "works" or not. Read morePublished on April 26, 2012 by Amazonia
Having attended a lecture by the dynamic Professor Oppenheimer, I looked forward to this book. Although it doesn't have the same energy and enthusiasm as the author carries forth... Read morePublished on March 25, 2012 by M. Hyman