I saw Justin Bond for the first time around Christmas this year, and was blown away. A few months later, Justin was playing again a few blocks from my apartment. I didn't know it was the CD release party (which was an amazing show!), but was really excited to see this for sale. When I first listened to it at home, I felt that it didn't have the same power as live. And, there was an amazing song from the show that I desperately hoped was on it. Nonetheless, I listened to it again.... and again.... and again.... and LOVE it.
Is it as good as a show? No. But, I'm not sure that it would be possible to ever bring the power of the shows into CD format. And, despite the initial disappointment that evening, this earns a rare 5 stars in my book.