Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Unlike the rest of the world, it won't leave you unimpressed, May 30, 2001
By A Customer
Unlike other attempts to unmask the members of this band, this book finally got it right! Amid the controversies, near fatal tragedies, and stories of excess, you will gain an almost intimate perspective of the personalities involved within the band itself. Starting from the group's humble beginnings in Basildon, and ending with the recording of Ultra, the chapters fly by as you read about one of the least understood bands today.What speaks loudest for the book, is that former Depeche Mode member Alan Wilder says on his website that the book is mostly accurate as opposed to previous attempts by other authors. While the book has been criticized by some as being mostly influenced by Alan's views on the other band members after he left the group, his comments are often balanced by what others had to say about the same people and events. Martin's drinking is addressed, as well as Dave's highly publicized overdose and Fletch's nervous breakdowns. Alan is said to be a loner by others, although he contends that he tried to be part of the group. The only thing that really irritated me was that the author makes the same mistake as most critics when he tries to dissect the meaning behind Martin's lyrics. The lyrics, which Martin doesn't like to explain, can't be explained away as easily as most critics think, and it does tend to annoy me when I read an entire song explained by a phrase or sentence- especially when I don't agree with the sentiment! Overall, a highly enjoyable read with many quotes from Martin, Dave, Alan, and Fletch, I would recommend this book to hugh DM fans and also those who have little more than a curiousity about the band.
|
|
|
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not horrible; not great, either., September 22, 2003
By A Customer
A worthwhile, in-depth biography of Depeche Mode was certainly long overdue when this particular volume was published, and Steve Malins obviously tries to give a balanced, behind-the-scenes portrait of the band. Is he successful? Well, yes and no.The book happily avoids the worst kind of scandal-mongering so common in the rock biography genre, and draws heavily from interviews with the band members and close associates. It's readable, the quotes are often amusing, and Malins does a fairly good job at illuminating the various personality conflicts and interpersonal relationships at play in DM. His take on the music is generally well thought out, though he does veer into arbitrary lyric analysis a bit too often for my taste. However, the book does have its flaws, not least of which is truly dreadful editing and an uneven, idiosyncratic writing style. The fact that the book is heavily laced with interviews from band members is on its face a good thing, but this becomes less desirable when one realizes that most quotes are merely lifted from magazine and newspaper articles. For those rather trainspottery DM fans (like me) who've already read those articles, there's very little new ground here. The book also relies quite heavily on comments from Alan Wilder (not a problem for me, personally--I found Al's comments insightful and entertaining--but if you've an anti-Alan bias, be forewarned). And again, the lack of an index is irritating. Altogether, we're left with a well-meaning but ultimately patchy history of Depeche Mode's lengthy career. It's better than nothing, I suppose.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Must-Have for Every Depeche Fan, August 24, 2001
This is a highly informative book starting from the very beginning, showing the evolution of the band. Highlights include quotes from band members and friends, giving both positive and negative comments on the progress of Depeche Mode. Malins also shows the tensions between band members and problems they faced, such as drug addiction, breakdowns, and heavy drinking. While this book is extremely informative, Malins tends to devote a little too much attention to David's drug problems.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|