Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Surpised when i spotted this one...., April 4, 2005
What? Derek Bailey? Verso?
Picked this one up in a flash let me tell you. I have good things to say about this book and one or two not so good things, gave it four out of five after all...
I ve known of but only been sort of listening to Derek Bailey for about five years. Im impressed that a publisher went so far as to put this book out--not only a biographical book about a fairly obscure musician but also a healthy left-wing analysis of a relatively obscure music scene, improvisation. Creative and well written.
The information on Bailey is fantastic, the information about who he played with is even more special--sends you looking in new places. The book functions a bit like a catalog of improvising musicians, giving you info that is not that easy to come by. The tone is quite frank, Watson is not afraid to point out some of the less positive points of Baileys musical partners.
This is one of the problems with the book. Bailey is in the spotlight and can do no wrong. Classically trained musicians bear the worst of Watsons critiques. Im not sure how you can accurately critique improvising musicians, the whole point of this music is exploration. Maybe a few of Baileys muckups would have been good, he is from Yorkshire after all and his humour makes the tone of the book.
The other problem I thought about after finishing this book was the detail Watson goes into explaining the performances, it reads like a long concert review at times. I would have preferred to read about what happened after the show, before, maybe a bit more history on some of the artists and so on.
The part about ECM being bedwetting music for yuppies (sorry if i misquoted but i think im right) pissed me off at first but I came round after a while, look at some of the stuff they have put out in the last ten years.....
So i focused on what I didnt like in this review and hope that someone finds it useful. Its a unique book, even those marginally interested should give it a read.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
No darlings killed, June 15, 2006
My view of this book differs from the other reviews. Maybe it's wrong of me towrite a review, because I have finished the book, but not read it all. Still, this proves my point in a way; The book is too long.
The way this book is written, it reminds me of a method I used in school, and had to deliver a paper on a subject. Often, I chose special subjects where references were scarce, so I ended up having very few sources, just a sentence here and a sentence there. But just by writing around it, adding descriptions etc, I could make it look like this was some serious stuff that I had dug up, that I had done a lot of research on the matter, and I could usually present a long (though probably shallow) paper to the teacher.
In a way, this is what Ben Watson has done. He writes in extreme detail about small events. Only the difference is that he doesn't have few sources, like I had in school. He has an extreme amount of information, and nothing is left out. Like other reviews mentions, this includes his own analysis on certain concerts and recordings. This is to me not very interesting, much because Watson tries to write in a very intelligent way, and pushing his own views on the philosophical aspects of free improvisation. This might not be a problem for you. To me, it makes the book way too long.
There are, however, good sides. There are a lot of long excerpts from interviews with Bailey, and these are the most useful and interesting bits, I find. Bailey explains his views much better than Watson can analyze his way to. Unfortunately, there is less and less of this moving towards the end of the book, and more and more descriptions of events (like who played on this and that Company Week, and if Watson thinks it was successfull or not).
I am an improvising musician myself, I love biographies, as well as conceptual thinking about music. This book still was a boring read - way too detailed, unless you're a Bailey-freak.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wow, I'm the first to review this book- It's Unique!!, February 12, 2005
Finally, a book that focuses the spotlight on one of the great musical innovators of our time: Derek Bailey. This book mixes interviews, (past& present), with peer commentary, and a detailed personal history of Derek's upbringing and musical influences. Sadly, though the author bothers to present his personal interpretation of Derek's musical output, I think we can all agree on the futility of such attempts. Luckily this banter is limited to scattered slivers from the whole of the book; he's a fan and couldn't help it!
But aside from my bias, I can completly recommend this book for its content & rich historical perspective on one of the most cherished musical figures of free music. DB
best. jb
|
|
|
|