|
90 of 92 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazingly Accurate Protrayal of the Kingdom, January 8, 2002
By A Customer
Before I begin my review, I would like to say that the offer for Desert Royal with Princess Sultana's Circle is not good as they are the SAME book. The Desert Royal is the British edition of the book and the CIRCLE is the American edition. Reader's beware! Amazon: Please pay attention to such situations!As far as the content of these books: I am a Muslim born in Lebanon but raised in America and I have traveled to the holy city of Mecca three times. I was pleased at the descriptions in this book of the pilgrimage. I disagree wholly with Mr. Jaeger from New York. (September 24.) He appears to be wrong in his judgement of the descriptions. I read the entire book very carefuly (three times, actually) and I could find no wrong doings in the descriptions of the cities or of the Ka'ba. I feel the gentlemen has been mislead by someone, as I have firsthand experiences in the Kingdom of Arabia. I have noticed various other reviews that appear to attack without basis and I can only assume these are people who wish to discredit these valuable books for some reason or another. It is understandable that this happens for so many people in Saudi Arabia refuse to accept the fact they are backward in their treatment of women and so they react angrily when someone tells the truth. While I am saddened at many of the descriptions, as a Muslim woman I will say that many of our men believe it is their right to beat a woman or mistreat her in other manners. For this reason, this is a good book to read. It is good that the Princess and the author are helping women in whatever way they can. I saw how women in Saudi Arabia are treated, and the author has described these situations perfectly. Sadly, nothing seems to be changing in Saudi Arabia--the women are educated but they cannot use their brillant minds in a good way. It is time for the Muslim world to discontinue mistreatment of females and move forward in a modern world. I say this as a Muslim woman who has lived a good life with a good family, but too many Muslim women do not have this opportunity. For this reason I believe that every school in the world should have the books about a Princess in Saudi Arabia as required reading. Perhaps if the young are changed, the world can change. I thank you for your time.
|